This is a book full of wisdom, the investigation of what death leaves behind and how societies have dealt with corpses, written by a historian modest enough to assert that poets, novelists, and philosophers will write better books about the history of the meaning of death, while he can only trace how we have lived with it. Laqueur brings prodigious compassion, erudition, and independence of thought to his task: every page is instructive, whether he is discussing the pollution caused by crematoria, the problems of pauper burials, the belief that undressing a corpse and opening windows makes it easier for the soul to leave the body, or just the listing of the names of the dead. The text is enriched by pictures (some too small in scale to be effective), which allow us to look at Luther on his deathbed, the Cock Lane ghost seen in 1762, the tomb of Abelard, Voltaire's arrival in Elysium, the Dortmund crematorium, and the Tollund man. Like the pictures, the use of fiction and of poetry intensifies the narrative: The Mill on the Floss is quoted to remind us that “nature repairs her ravages, repairs them with sunshine and human labour,” and then “nature repairs her ravages,—but not all. … To the eyes that have dwelt on the past there is no thorough repair” (485; this passage, and George Eliot, are not listed in the unsatisfactory index). Laqueur has chosen to investigate the unbearable presence of the dead among the living; aware of the impossibility of writing of the experience of death, or of the terror of death, he has chosen to explore continuities and discontinuities in attitudes to dead bodies, where, what, and who those bodies are.
Vico stated that burials, matrimony, and religion were the three institutions which produced and sustain civil society. This book asks how and why the dead make civilization, focusing in England between 1680 and 2000 and building on the insights of the French sociologist Robert Hertz on social death, Drew Faust on the naming of American Civil War dead, and Robert Pogue Harrison's The Dominion of the Dead, but also on William Godwin's 1809 Essay on Sepulchres.
Laqueur is admirably lucid about his enterprise and its limitations: “I take the work of the dead to be perhaps the greatest and most mysterious triumph of culture” (26); “the mystery is our capacity to make so very much of absence” (27). Throughout the book, there is a tension between “deep time and its jagged stratigraphy” (32), a sense of enduring human patterns of behavior responding to deeper cultural pressures and of those specific features that may enable the historian to understand and to explain change. Hence he can demonstrate that there were fewer ghosts after the Reformation, discuss the alignment of bodies in churchyards, the presence of yew trees in churchyards, the price of bodies for anatomy demonstrations, the replacement of the date of baptism by the date of birth in the registration of births and deaths, the fate of the dead at Peterloo, the names of the English dead at Agincourt, and the attempt to use cremated bodies as fertilizer.
Caring for the dead has always been about comfort for the living. Augustine, writing in 422, affirmed that the bodies of the dead “pertain to the very nature of the man.” Thomas Aquinas was less concerned with the man than with the body as a temple of the holy ghost living and operating in it. Laqueur wants to show how the remains of the dead call the living to imagine a moral order. Originally burial in the churchyard of one's parish was a right, though there was no right to hold the grave in perpetuity, and the theft of a body from a grave was not a felony. In his chapters on the churchyard, Laqueur might have quoted Wordsworth's Essays upon Epitaphs: “A parish church, in the stillness of the country, is a visible centre of the community of the living and the dead.” But Wordsworth felt the need for a genial warmth deriving from a belief in immortality.
Protestantism had little effect on memorial practices, but as Laqueur shows in his discussion of a series of court cases, Anglican clergy often refused to bury dissenters. Disgust at corpses rose in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Laqueur gives detailed accounts of the deathbeds of Spinoza, Voltaire, and Hume, and the efforts of their detractors to prove that they died in the horrible misery that the impious deserved. Hume claimed to be arguing with Charon, the ferryman of the underworld, that he should be allowed to live to see the downfall of systems of superstition, only to be told “that will not happen these many hundred years. Get into the boat this instant” (207). After illustrious deathbeds, there is an account of public funerals, far more frequent in France than in Britain, of the mass attendance at the funerals of Chartists and even the horse of Orator Hunt, and of the burial of Darwin and Hardy in Westminster Abbey. In 1880 the Burial Amendment Act made burial in a churchyard a civil right, and any kind of service, or no service at all, might be read at the grave.
A major theme of this book is that the cemetery, which included unconsecrated ground, represented a rejection of history, offering instead “a historical jumble of borrowed bits of different pasts” (212). Père Lachaise in Paris provided an international model for the cemetery as a museum of sculpture and architecture, and there is an excellent account of the economics of the cemetery and the horror of the pauper funeral. The dead of the Crimean War and the Boer War did not receive individual memorials, but Laqueur gives a full account of how the British dead of the First World War were recorded by name. For Field Marshal Haig, “the work (of the Graves Registration Commission) is of purely sentimental value.” By their cemeteries and vast memorials (72,194 names at Thiepval, 54,382 at the Menin Gate), a particular community of the dead was created, and despite frequent requests, bodies of soldiers were not returned home; the next of kin lost their rights. Instead, uniform tombstones were provided with a particular form of words for those bodies whose names remained unknown. The discussion of these names is enhanced by reflections on names and naming, on the Vietnam Memorial and the AIDS Quilt. Greek grave steles and Woody Guthrie's “Deportee” help to answer the question, “How does one name of a working-class soldier among 34,785 others who have no known grave come to matter?” (398). Exploration of deep time, Homer and Herodotus, Mill and Freud provide a perspective which allows Laqueur to write of a “new emotional infrastructure” (401) emerging in the eighteenth century in which ordinary people are remembered. The dead shift into an immanent sphere, and there is a moral imperative to read and inscribe their names.
The final chapters deal with the rise of cremation, promoted as both sanitary and rational. The body would lose its special status, though attempts to use human ashes as fertilizer were resisted. Cremation was seen as irreligious by the Catholic Church and by Jewish rabbis. In Britain it was promoted as an ancient Celtic custom by a Chartist vegetarian and archdruid who twice tried to burn the body of his infant son Jesu Grist, and was ruled not to have committed a criminal act.
Though he quotes Bismarck on “the idolatry practiced at the graves of those criminals whose every tombstone boasts of ‘Freedom and Rights’” (214), Laqueur says surprisingly little about how people reacted to graves, as opposed to funerals. It is worth quoting Wordsworth at the grave of Burns:
I shiver, Spirit fierce and bold,
At thought of what I now behold:
As vapors breathed from dungeons cold,
Strikes pleasure dead,
So sadness comes from out the mould
Where Burns is laid.
And have I then thy bones so near
And thou forbidden to appear?
As if it were thyself that's here.
But Laqueur's extensive reading of collections of epitaphs, accounts of deathbeds, and descriptions of crematoria give this magnificent book a rare sensitivity to human hopes and fears, and the ways in which they have changed and have been changed. Laqueur's dead are never anonymous. In his careful exploration of Serge Klarsfeld's French Children of the Holocaust, the record of 11,400 murdered Jewish children, Laqueur acknowledges the problem we face in confronting such huge numbers and praises Klarsfeld's achievement: a recovery of the person “thrusting the past into the present” (439). He tells us that he dwells on this one history because it is exemplary (445). Few historians are as concerned with this sort of exemplarity as Laqueur: in this tracing of intertwined histories, this complex meditation on our treatment of the dead, he too provides us with an example to follow and to praise.
I have noticed a number of minor errors: on p. 50, Shelley's poem should read “lone and level sands,” not “lone level”; on p. 59, Bach's text should read Ich will Jesum selbst begraben, not Ich Jesum; on p. 82, Michel Montaigne (for de Montaigne); p. 97 Gregory of Tour (for Gregory of Tours); on p. 177, Magdalene College Oxford (for Magdalen); and on p. 410, in the quotation from Casabianca the text should read “pennon” and not “penion.”
