The memoirs of an academic embroiled largely in the study of what political parties and governments do, how public policy is made, and what ordinary people think of their own political milieu does not immediately strike one as the most fascinating of subjects. But for those engaged professionally in the study of politics, an intellectual life-story by a leading figure in the field can hold much interest in terms of the events they have witnessed as well as the ideas they have developed in the context of their experiences. Richard Rose's account of his own intellectual development takes us from St. Louis schoolboy through some sixty years of a career which included studies at Johns Hopkins, the LSE, and Oxford, several years as a journalist, then academic appointments at British universities. Strathclyde has been his principal base since 1966.
The narrative is structured thematically rather than strictly chronologically, ranging back and forth over events, and Rose's responses to them, to illustrate key aspects of his intellectual development and publishing career. His experiences of postgraduate education in the U.K., at the LSE and Oxford, reveal a certain scorn for several notable intellectual figures like Harold Laski and many lesser ones, most of whom he regarded as mere amateurs as far as the study of politics was concerned, interested only in argument without evidence. A number were further tainted by close association with Marxist ideas. As far as his own politics is concerned, Rose identifies as a “Truman Democrat,” although he does not explain to the uninformed reader exactly what this means. Whatever else it may entail, Rose declares allegiance to the negative-freedom-from-government version of liberty and virtually all references to socialist or left-leaning views are dismissive at best. At the same time, he insists that his own analyses rely strictly on evidence rather than ideology. This is the hallmark of a professional approach to the study of politics. Indeed, Rose devotes much space to an account of the professionalization of “political science” in Britain based on his personal experience. This account also reveals a dismissive attitude to those who have resisted the “science” label for the discipline, preferring the more open term “political studies” that accommodates not only the narrower “scientific” methodological approaches but normative, historical, and interpretive approaches as well.
As far as the events recounted by Rose go, the conflict in Northern Ireland and the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union provide by far the most interesting insights. Both are arenas where governance had failed spectacularly, albeit in very different ways and under vastly different circumstances. A particular focus in these sections is on how Rose and colleagues have developed comparative analytical tools underpinned by survey data, providing material previously unavailable to political analysts, especially when working across the different successor states in the former communist areas. Rose's more general comparative method has much to recommend it. Repudiating both overly abstract universalism and narrow particularism, Rose has pursued a strategy of identifying differences and similarities within an overarching conceptual framework that is flexible enough to capture features relevant to meaningful comparative analysis. And although quantification is clearly a key feature of his methodology, mindless empiricism is not. Rose also emphasizes the importance for analysis of interdisciplinary perspectives. Economics, sociology, and history, in particular, are clearly very relevant to the comparativist, although he appears to have little time for anthropology.
Rose takes great pride in his writing style, and writing well is certainly a skill that any aspiring academic should work hard to develop. He provides plenty of useful tips, from the importance of constructing a coherent text in which sentences and paragraphs follow clearly and logically from one to the next, to the differing requirements for short essays, journal articles, books, and so on. But he does not always seem to follow his own advice. Some of his own paragraphs contain non sequiturs or at least unconnected sentences, and the structure of the last two chapters is not well organized. The autobiographical genre is also one which may encourage self-congratulatory overtones, and Rose finds these rather hard to resist. He clearly has much to be pleased about, as his impressive list of publications, grants, and honors attests, but he is at times a touch too smug. Despite some shortcomings, Rose's reflections on a life studying politics is a worthwhile contribution and certainly of interest to anyone engaged in the same enterprise.
