Secret and semisecret societies are inherently fascinating, and yet challenging as a subject of an academic inquiry. Marc Baer takes up this challenge and successfully turns one of these societies, the Dönmes, into the subject of his book. The Dönmes were the descendants of the followers of a Jewish “messiah,” Sabbatai Sevi, who created one of the most influential messianic movements, surfacing in 1665 in the Ottoman Empire and extending to major centers in Europe and Asia, including London, Amsterdam, Moscow, and Isfahan in 1666. When the Ottoman authorities forced Sevi to convert to Islam in the same year, some believers followed in their leader's footsteps, converted to Islam, and formed a secret community. While Sabbatean messianic ideas continued to exist among Jews and Christians (via Frankists, who, under the leadership of the Sabbatean Jacob Frank, outwardly converted to Christianity and formed a crypto-community in Poland in 1756) until the 19th century, they survived among the Dönmes, as the title of Baer's book suggests, in various forms until the present. Mostly concentrated in Salonica until the 20th century, the Dönmes created a messianic universe parallel to their outward Islamic life, with secret rites and rituals, communal leaders, worship houses, courts, and cemeteries.
Similar to several other crypto-Jewish communities in the Ottoman Empire, the Dönmes were considered Muslims by Ottoman authorities but perceived as “nominal converts” by many Muslim Ottoman subjects. The Jewish attitude toward them traditionally ranged from aversion to strong antipathy. Because of this, the Dönme suffered from a kind of double illegitimacy in both communities. Unlike crypto-Jewish Marranos and crypto-Muslim Moriscos who were forced to convert to Christianity in the Spanish and Portuguese inquisitions in the 15th and 16th centuries, the Dönmes initially converted to Islam without any apparent coercion, leading some Jewish scholars to refer to them as “voluntary Marranos.”
Needless to say, the study of this transnational, transreligious, and transregional movement in both past and contemporary times is linked to many major historical and contemporary issues in European, Islamic, Ottoman, Turkish, and Jewish studies. Although students of Jewish and European studies have examined the movement, neither the movement nor its sectarian development as it existed within the matrix of Ottoman (and Turkish) social and religious developments has yet received the attention it deserves, in part because of the lack of access to documents in relevant languages. For example, Gershom Scholem's magnum opus, Sabbatai Sevi: Mystical Messiah (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1973), mostly disregards the Ottoman context, concentrating mainly on the intellectual history of the movement within the life span of Sabbatai Sevi (1626–76). In that regard, Baer's book is the first major, published academic work of length devoted to examining the Dönmes within the larger historical context. By combining architectural, epigraphic, oral, archival, genealogical, literary, and official sources in Ottoman, English, German, French, and Greek, Baer overcomes the challenge posed by what was thought to be the paucity of documentary evidence. The Hebrew and Jewish sources used by Scholem, however, are underutilized in the author's analysis. The book focuses mainly on the period between the 1860s and the 1950s, since the author thinks that “the sources are most reliable” for this period (p. xi). It should be noted first that there are relatively more Jewish and European sources about the early period of the movement and that there has been an increasing amount of new oral sources about the Dönmes since the 1990s. Second, the issue of the “reliability of sources” in Sabbatean studies is always at stake due to the controversial and secretive nature of the subject. In other words, almost all of the historical and contemporary sources (oral, written, epigraphic, and the like) were constructed either by the Sabbateans or by “outsiders” who could obscure and manipulate the past (or present) with their teleological concerns, such as secrecy, religiosity, secularism, and anti-Sabbateanism. Therefore, no period of Sabbatean history is necessarily richer than any other in terms of reliable sources.
After the introduction, which deals briefly with early Sabbatean history between 1666 and 1862, the book is divided into three parts and nine chapters. Part I focuses on Dönme beliefs, practices, schools, and trade and economic networks in Salonica between 1862 and 1908. Part II deals mainly with Dönme politics in Salonica during the first quarter of the 20th century, when the Ottoman Empire dissolved and the Turkish nation-state was born. Part III is concerned with the Dönmes after the population exchange and within the context of the rise of a homogeneous secular nationalist Turkish identity out of a pluralistic religious Ottoman identity. Here Baer states that the Dönmes maintained their social and religious distinctiveness and institutions in their new homeland by establishing self-segregated neighborhoods, schools, and cemeteries. He rightly suggests that the wealth tax episode during World War II showed the failure of both the Dönmes’ attempts to assimilate and the secular nations’ promise to treat them as equals. In this part, he also deals with one of the unknown chapters of Dönme history: a small number of Dönmes who remained in Greek Salonica and faced similar challenges within the context of the Greek nation-state. In the conclusion of the book, Baer traces how the transition from cosmopolitanism to nationalism, racism, and anti-Semitism affected the Dönmes and their cultural memory, emphasizing how their opponents used “ethnicized religion and racialized” nationalism in their anti-Dönme discourses (p. xi). The book ends with a postscript that discusses the rise of a crude anti-Dönme rhetoric during the mid-20th century and the assassination of a famous Dönme journalist, Ahmet Emin Yalman, by a young right-wing activist, Huseyin Uzmez, in 1952.
One of the major problems in Dönme studies is the conflation of multiple subgroups and the undifferentiated use of the term Dönme. To begin with, the Dönmes were divided into three subgroups in the early 18th century and evolved into the Yakubi, Karakaş, and Kapanci in the 20th century. Second, these subgroups divided yet again along the lines of orthodox, reformists, and liberals/assimilationists, as a reaction to the challenges of modernity and “rationality” in the second half of the 19th century. Although Baer acknowledges the differences among the subgroups, he mostly disregards the second level of differentiation, and that confusion affects several areas of his analysis. For example, in his discussion of “religious actors and societal transformation,” Baer claims that the Dönmes were not secularist before 1923, and that their activities cannot be said to anticipate secular nationalism (pp. 60–64, 79, and 100). Although this statement is true for the orthodox Dönmes, it is not necessarily true for the reformists and assimilationists who, like some of the positivist Young Turks and Freemasons, did not hesitate to advocate an inflexible drive toward “progress,” “modernization,” and “secularism” at the expense of religion and tradition. Therefore, it is perfectly possible to imagine that some of the Dönmes, as well as some of the “liberated” Turks, Armenians, and Rums, were the historical forebears of Turkish republican secularism.
Likewise, Baer suggests that Dönmes, like other Muslims, prayed in the New Mosque (built in Salonica in 1902), but added Dönme prayers and rituals, just as they did at their private burial services (p. 40). Could we apply this argument to all the Dönmes? Apparently not. From other sources we know that only a few “chosen” Dönmes tended to attend the mosques or to go on the pilgrimage to Mecca in order to fulfill public Islamic duties, as required by the Eighteen Commandments.
In portraying Dönme religious life, Baer assumes that the Dönme “religion” (p. 12) was a syncretic one, combining elements of Kabbala and Sufism (pp. 5–7, 16–17, 243). It is hard to prove that the impact of Sufism on Dönme theology and life was as powerful as has frequently been stated. It is true that during their formative period, some Sabbateans borrowed various “forms” from Sufi practices, such as the master–disciple relationship, takiyye (dissimulation), and zikr (mystical recitation). It is also true that some Dönmes became Sufi dervishes and shaykhs over time. But, as their numerous prayer and hymn books, mystical texts, and oral traditions suggest, Dönme theology and mysticism have essentially remained parts of postmessianic Jewish mysticism. Therefore, rather than forming a syncretic religion, they created a metareligion that transcended all the existing religions. The lack of discussion on the nature of this Dönme religious life is perhaps the weakest part of the book.
Another major assumption of Baer's book is that the Dönmes disappeared after the founding of the Turkish Republic, when endogamy “brought the real end of Dönme distinctness” (p. xi). However, contemporary testimonies demonstrate that a small functioning community of believers has survived until the present time, although its numbers are steadily dwindling.
A crypto-Jewish community is a hard subject to study, and it is difficult to write a book like this without making some factual mistakes. Baer's book reflects this difficulty. For example, Baer considers the Dönme Mehmet Cavit, the famous Ottoman minister of finance, to have been part of the delegation of the Committee of Union and Progress that delivered to Sultan Abdülhamit II the directive that he had been deposed in 1909 (p. 108). The delegation was composed of only Emmanuel Carasso, Ayan Aram Efendi, Arif Hikmet, and Esad Paşa. Another factual error is the author's assumption that the last Ottoman mayor of Salonica, Osman Sait, was the son of the famous mayor Osman Hamdi; in fact, he was his nephew. Also, the assumption of the Dönme origin of Dr. Nazım Bey, who was one of the masterminds of the Committee of Union and Progress, and İbrahim Alattin Gövsa, who was one of the intellectuals and MPs in the early Turkish Republic, requires more substantial evidence.
In the end, this is an important book that sets a high standard for later researchers of the subject. However, a work combining the religious, social, and economic histories of the Sabbatean movement and the Dönmes from the 17th to the 20th centuries has yet to be written. There are many challenges to conducting research within the culture of secrecy, and Baer has already managed to overcome most of them. His book will undoubtedly be essential reading not only on the Dönmes but also on other religious and cryptoreligious communities in Jewish, Ottoman, and Islamic histories.
