In 1993, historian Hal S. Barron called Grey Osterud's Bonds of Community: The Lives of Farm Women in Nineteenth-Century New York “the most thorough and sophisticated reconstruction of the relationships between rural men and women that we have for the nineteenth century.”Footnote 1 Indeed, Osterud's pathbreaking work has undergirded the studies of a generation of historians of rural women – including this reviewer's. Her meticulously researched community study of farm families in New York's Nanticoke Valley thoroughly refuted the notion that “separate spheres” existed among most nineteenth-century northern farming families. She demonstrated that a flexible gender division of labor and strong mutual-aid networks built and maintained by women provided Nanticoke Valley farm families with the resources to survive and even thrive in the uncertain agricultural economy of the late nineteenth century.
In Putting the Barn before the House, which Osterud describes as the sequel to Bonds of Community, she carries the story of Nanticoke Valley farmers into the twentieth century. Using the same exhaustive research and careful analysis, Osterud demonstrates that in Nanticoke Valley, farm families maintained flexible gender roles and strong mutual-aid networks, as well as a “culture of mutuality,” well into the twentieth century. Men and women agreed that “putting the barn before the house” was a vital strategy to enable the family to persist on the land and convey it to the next generation. While the demands of the family farm shaped women's lives, Nanticoke Valley women did not see themselves as “drudges” in service to a patriarchal system. Instead, they negotiated with their husbands or other relatives to achieve a gender division of labor that accommodated their own preferences to the needs of farm and family. Since the work of each family member contributed to the family economy, women enjoyed and maintained positions as partners in the farming operation.
Osterud argues that the types of agency that women were able to exercise varied in part with their connection to the land. Women who inherited land from parents or founded farms with their husbands often displayed more autonomy and control over family decision-making than women who married an inheriting son. Yet, almost without exception, early twentieth-century Nanticoke Valley farm women strove to “create marital partnerships characterized by mutuality rather than marginality” (170).
Nanticoke Valley farming families also rejected the efforts of Country Life reformers and, later, agricultural extension agents who urged men and women to adopt both progressive commercial farming strategies and the ideology of separate spheres. Instead, they sought to embody “the core values they espoused: gender integration and mutuality, reciprocity and mutual aid, and social equality and collective action” (240). In the early decades of the twentieth century, Nanticoke Valley farmers organized marketing and producer cooperatives designed to increase their control over their fate in the agricultural marketplace. They also worked through political organizations like the Grange to lobby for their own interests. Women played important roles in the organization and operation of early cooperatives and in the Valley's pre-World War II farmer movements.
By the time of the Great Depression, however, farming in the Nanticoke Valley had changed. Rural landowners became stratified into two groups. On the one hand were specialized, capital-intensive, market-oriented commercial farms and on the other were small diversified farms that combined small-scale production for home use or local markets with wage earning. Small diversified farms maintained their commitment to their traditional values of mutuality and flexible gender roles by adding wage labor to the mix of the family economy. Sometimes men took the off-farm job while women worked the land with the help of older children, while at other times it was women who sought off-farm employment, but always the priority was maintaining family control of the land. Small farmers continued to rely on labor exchanges with networks of kin and neighbors. After World War II, however, small-scale diversified farming collapsed as small producers lost access to markets and the increasing incidence of wage labor among rural families led to the collapse of mutual-aid networks.
During the same period, however, on commercial farms an influx of cash sowed the seeds that undermined the male–female partnerships and mutual-aid networks that had been core values for earlier generations. The work of farm wives and daughters became less essential as it became easier to hire wage laborers to replace them. The cooperatives and farmer organizations formed in the early part of the century became male-dominated bureaucracies, and women found their work marginalized here as well.
By the middle of the twentieth century, most rural women in the Nanticoke Valley found themselves increasingly drawn into an urban/suburban ethos whose values of independence and separate spheres they had long rejected. The culture of mutuality that had served them well for over a century could not survive the forces of agricultural transformation. This work demonstrates how and why the development of commercial agriculture in the United States marginalized the work and the power of rural women.
Osterud's gracefully written book is a masterful contribution to rural and agricultural history. While her findings largely confirm her earlier conclusions, offering only a few new insights, her sensitive and careful use of oral history narratives to illustrate and illuminate the patterns in Nanticoke Valley rural life is a model for the use of personal narratives to reconstruct the lives of ordinary people. Putting the Barn before the House is an exemplary work for historians in any specialty that explores rural and urban social and labor history.
