The appearance of this book owes a great deal to the commitment of Judith Koren, an information specialist, who brought to its final form the thesis laid down by archaeologist Yehuda D. Nevo, whose death of cancer in 1992 left the project unfinished. The book joins the revisionist historiography of early Islam, attempting to accomplish a feat that seemed beyond the reach of the revisionist approach thus far. Not content with rejecting the traditional narrative, the authors reconstruct the rise of Islam with virtually no use of traditional Islamic sources.
Typical of the revisionist approach, the authors discard all Islamic sources as unreliable, including classical histories, sīra, and the Qur

an, all of which are regarded to be later inventions. Nevo's work, which forms the basis of this book, highlights material remains, and the authors flatly assert the superiority of archaeological and numismatic evidence above all kinds of textual evidence. (Yet, they freely make use of textual evidence whenever it supports their thesis—notably from Byzantine and church sources.)
The thesis set forth in the book is quite bold. There were no Islamic conquests into Syria; Byzantium had already abandoned its Eastern provinces, and Arab tribes began to move in. The Arabs at that time (corresponding in the traditional narrative to the Rashidi and early Umayyad periods) were largely pagans, not Muslims. Islamic descriptions of pagan life derive from cult practices in the Negev, not Hijaz. The elites of the new Arab populations in Syria, still clients of Byzantium, adopted an indeterminate form of monotheism that had its basis in Judeo-Christian trends in Syria, not Arabia. Muhammad is not a historical figure, nor are any of the early caliphs. Mu

awiya is in effect the first caliph, having won an inner-Arab struggle to form a unified national leadership. Still, Mu

awiya's religion was indeterminate monotheism, and the first verifiable physical references to Muhammad do not occur until the reign of

Abd al-Malik, around 692. Even then, the authors argue that those references are not to a historical person. Rather, “Muhammad” was used as an adjective, referring to an idea of a desired, chosen prophet. At a later stage, when the Arabs realized their lack of pedigree among the more established civilizations they came to rule and the need of their new state for an official religion, they felt the need for a unifying, glorious national myth. Hence, the later composition of the sīra, the traditional narrative, and the Qur

an.
Typical of the revisionist historians, Nevo and Koren see their approach as scientific, hard-nosed, and source critical, accepting only what can be proved beyond any doubt. Also typical of the same school, they freely interpret any source in order to arrive at a foregone conclusion. The authors here go a step further in this supposed positivism, yet their focus on material remains fails to support their thesis, and in some cases their evidence seems to validate the traditional narrative. For example, Mu

awiya's dam inscription near Ta

if, dated to 677, is classified as an example of indeterminate monotheism rather than Islam, even though, while the inscription does not contain the word “Muhammad,” it is self-dated according to an obviously hijra calendar. Similarly, little other than readers' sheer goodwill may compel them to accept the tortuous logic explaining why physical references to Muhammad from the early 690s must be read as adjectives rather than nouns. Likewise is the case with their (quick, convenient, unexplained) dismissal of the reference to Muhammad in the 7th century account of Sebeos as a later insertion by a copyist. (They uncritically accept all else in that rather textual evidence.)
The authors' method of classifying their rock inscription (pp. 301–5, 365–425) does not readily support their thesis because many clearly Islamic inscriptions are classified as “undated.” Even archaeology itself as a primary source appears suspect, because in fact many of the crucial sites, notably in Mecca and Medina, are off the excavation list, and the entire archaeological evidence is too scant for any major theory. The authors themselves acknowledge this in a passing statement that, methodologically remarkable as it is, apparently leaves them untroubled: “But even the little information discovered so far cannot be reconciled with the traditional Muslim account” (p. 67, emphasis added).
Apart from that, treating rock inscriptions (in the desert no less, and mostly in the Negev) as illustrations of “popular beliefs” is hardly persuasive. Neither does the existence of a desert pagan cult presume governmental tolerance (p. 202). It may just as well, and in fact more likely, signify governmental intolerance, especially if no comparable and contemporaneous urban cult centers have been found. More generally, the analysis of Bedouin roles and relations with sedentary peoples would have benefited from better grounding in the sociology of Bedouin life, and such unfortunate references as “predatory Muslim hordes” (p. 108) do not help. The authors prefer to rely for their sociological description of Bedouin life on mere guesses, buttressed only by discredited Zionist fabrications of social life in 18th century Palestine (pp. 95–96).
It is of little help that the massive voids in this reconstruction are filled in not by any evidence but rather by conspiracy theories and wild guesses. This is most clearly illustrated in the authors' account of why and how the Byzantine empire decided to abandon its Eastern provinces, thereby setting off a dynamic that unwittingly resulted in Islam. With no evidence (strangely for science), the authors assert that it was Byzantine policy to foster heresy in Syria because that would make it easier for the empire to abandon responsibility for the Christian population there. Just for the same reason, it harshly persecuted heresy in Egypt because it could thereby harden local opposition such that it would be easier to transfer local power to Arab tribes (pp. 51–65). Similarly, because some construction projects continued after the Arab takeover, the empire must have continued to make secret payments to its new clients, the Arab rulers—even though the authors confess that because these were secret, no evidence could be found (p. 96). Are there no better explanations?
In this book, there is evidence of immense erudition. There is also evidence that it unfortunately does not protect against single mindedness.
