Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T09:16:38.292Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Satire, Empire and Chromaticism in Dargomyzhsky’s Orchestral Fantasias

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 November 2020

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

In 1863, Alexander Dargomyzhsky hatched plans for a gallery of humorous fantasias that would depict nationalities residing on the western border of the Russian Empire, including Baltic Germans, Poles, Ukrainians and Finns. On the one hand, this gallery of satirical portraits was an effective way of capturing the attention of domestic audiences, since the western borderlands were at the forefront of Russian popular attention in the wake of the Polish uprising. On the other hand, Dargomyzhsky repeatedly reiterated his intention that the fantasias should function as a means of achieving international recognition, and a year later he actually set off on a promotional tour across Europe. Together, the imperial implications of the three resulting fantasias, Dargomyzhsky’s attempts to market them abroad and the compositional inventiveness of the final fantasia, the Chukhon Fantasy, locate Dargomyzhsky’s orchestral oeuvre as a crucial node in the convoluted aesthetic and cultural negotiations of Russian nineteenth-century music.

Information

Type
Article
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Royal Musical Association
Figure 0

Figure 1Formal outline of Baba-Yaga.

Figure 1

Figure 2Comparison of slow openings of Kamarinskaya and Baba-Yaga.

Figure 2

Example 1Dargomyzhsky, Baba-Yaga, second section, witch theme, bars 115–18.

Figure 3

Example 2Dargomyzhsky, Baba-Yaga, third section: (a) bars 280–7; (b) bars 429–36.

Figure 4

Example 3Dargomyzhsky, Baba-Yaga, third section, German theme, bars 183–98.

Figure 5

Figure 3Locations of Dargomyzhsky’s four projected fantasias, represented on Samuel Augustus Mitchell’s map of European geopolitical divisions in 1860. From Mitchell’s New General Atlas, Containing Maps of the Various Countries of the World, Plans of Cities, etc. Embraced in Forty-Seven Quarto Maps, Forming a Series of Seventy-Six Maps and Plans, together with Valuable Statistical Tables (Philadelphia, PA: S. A. Mitchell, Jr, 1860), available at <https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:1860_Mitchell_Map_of_Europe_-_Geographicus_-_Europe-m-63.jpg>.

Figure 6

Example 4Dargomyzhsky,Little-Russian Kazachok: (a) bars 32–51; (b) bars 72–6 (adapted from Tchaikovsky’s piano transcription); (c) bars 161–76 (adapted from Tchaikovsky’s piano transcription).

Figure 7

Figure 4Cover of the first edition of the Little-Russian Kazachok (Moscow: P. Jurgenson, 1867).

Figure 8

Figure 5Formal outline of the Little-Russian Kazachok. Solid boxes represent variational statements where the original melody is largely preserved, whereas boxes with a dotted outline represent looser variational and developmental treatment of the melody.

Figure 9

Figure 6Peter von Köppen’s ethnographic map of St Petersburg and its environs from 1849 (edited excerpt). Coloured patches indicated major populations of various Finnic peoples. Murino, the village where Dargomyzhsky obtained the fast theme for the Chukhon Fantasy, is circled. Peter von Köppen, Ethnographische Karte des St. Petersburgischen Gouvernements (St Petersburg: K. Akademie der Wissenschaften zu St. Petersburg, 1849).

Figure 10

Example 5Dargomyzhsky, Chukhon Fantasy: (a) primary theme, bars 15–26; (b) secondary theme, bars 107–21; (c) coda theme, bars 303–8.

Figure 11

Figure 7Formal outline of the Chukhon Fantasy. For an alternative representation that foregrounds the role of augmented triads as structural sonorities, see Example 7.

Figure 12

Example 6Dargomyzhsky, Chukhon Fantasy, introduction: (a) bars 1–15; (b) bars 1–15, harmonic reduction.

Figure 13

Figure 8Weitzmann’s representation of the four possible augmented triads and their related major and minor triads. Weitzmann, Der übermässige Dreiklang, 24.

Figure 14

Figure 9Chukhon Fantasy, introduction, bars 1–15, Weitzmann-inspired representation. The two regions separated by the vertical line depict the C and C♯ augmented triads along with their semitone-related consonant triads. Arrows indicate the fantasia’s trajectory through this harmonic space starting with F♯ minor in the bottom right corner.

Figure 15

Example 7Dargomyzhsky, Chukhon Fantasy, tonal layout, emphasizing the role of the augmented triad. Accordingly, only augmented triads are designated in the development, even though it is predominantly diatonic.

Figure 16

Example 8Dargomyzhsky, Chukhon Fantasy: (a) bars 39–43; (b) bars 68–91; (c) bars 107–17.

Figure 17

Example 9Rimsky-Korsakov, Antar, bars 1–11, harmonic reduction.

Figure 18

Figure 10Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov’s Antar, bars 1–11, Weitzmann-inspired representation.