The statement “Vietnam has fifty-four ethnic groups” is regarded as if it were a basic fact. Ito Masako and Nguyen Van Thang, however, offer comprehensive yet critical views that problematize this statement. These two books resonate with one another. Ito's Politics of Ethnic Classification in Vietnam traces the history of ethnic classification policy and raises issues drawn from many small and officially unrecognized ethnic groups, whereas Nguyen's Ambiguity of Identity illustrates similar issues from the perspective of a detailed ethnographic study of a single ethnic group. The two books not only depict how ethnic groups and the state's policy toward ethnic groups in Vietnam evolve, but also broaden theoretical views of ethnic identity and relationships between ethnic groups and the states in Southeast Asian and other global contexts.
Drawing from research conducted between 2004 and 2006, Ito divides her book into four chapters. The first chapter is an overview of the history of ethnology in Vietnam. Ito argues that “Vietnamese ethnology came to be valued only as a part of politics and service to politics” (p. 3). Although the origin of Vietnam's ethnic classification policy can be traced back to the USSR, Ito reveals that Vietnam adopted its ethnic classification criteria from China; they include language, lifestyle and cultural characteristics, and ethnic self-consciousness (p. 32). However, while ethnic consciousness is acknowledged, in practice, “ethnic self-consciousness should be developed under ‘guidance’ of the Party and the state” (p. 40).
The second chapter reviews the impact of the “Đổi Mới” (renovation) policy that, beginning in 1986, adopted a market economy into Vietnam's socialist state. This development program “has had some positive impacts in certain areas, especially in the north” (p. 60). Ito found that the policy overemphasized construction while placing too little emphasis on people's livelihood; at the same time, the policy's implementation faced the problems of inefficiency and unequal distribution of funds.
The third and fourth chapters draw data from Ito's field survey in communities of unrecognized small ethnic groups, for example, the case of the Sán Chay. Ito explains that the “Cao Lan and the Sán Chỉ are combined to form the Sán Chay and are designated as its subgroups” (p. 68). Both ethnic groups live in northeastern Vietnam. Prior to the 1960s, the Cao Lan were considered to be the Dao. Later, the official Vietnamese ethnology classified them as “a distinct group belonging to the Tày language branch of Hán-Tày group. . . . The Sán Chỉ, by contrast, is described as part of the Hán language branch of Hán-Tày group” (p. 70). Ito discovered that the Cao Lan in Bắc Giang “have retained their Tai origin language and many older women still treasure their traditional ‘ethnic costume’” (p. 76). More importantly, the “patrilineal kin group,” in which settlements are family name–based, is probably even more significant to the people in this area than ethnic identity (pp. 77–78). Since 1999, when the government started a new census survey and offered the possibility of revising the official ethnic classifications, thereby acknowledging their existence, their request to revise the classification has never received a response.
In Ambiguity of Identity, Nguyen examines issues of ethnic classification from an ethnic Mieu perspective. Officially, the Mieu are classified as a subgroup of the Hmông. However, the Mieu “identify themselves with the ethnonym Na Mieu (Mieu people)” (p. 1), and hence they are a distinctive ethnic group.
This book is divided into five chapters. The first chapter provides an overall background of ethnic relations in Vietnam, both between ethnic groups and the Vietnamese state and among the ethnic peoples themselves. This chapter lays out Nguyen's theoretical framework, which is “a model that integrated the primordial, instrumental, and constructivist approaches” (p. 29). Henceforth, according to Nguyen, although Mieu identity evolves over time in order to survive in different social and political contexts, it is a negotiated and primordial shared identity as well as a state-constructed identity.
The second chapter illustrates historical and ethnographic details of Mieu culture, ranging from house patterns, food styles, and clothing, to marriage, kinship systems, religion, and folklore. The chapter presents the Mieu lifestyle before and after Vietnam's independence in 1954. For example, a distinctive Mieu cultural feature is reflected in Mieu clan names. The clan name is a cultural practice that differentiates the Mieu from the Hmông. In addition, some Tày, Thái, and Kinh clan names are incorporated into Mieu clan names by a unique system of interethnic marriage. Thus, Nguyen points out, “ethnicity is fluid when people use it as a means to gain practical socioeconomic advantages” (p. 38).
Issues related to ethnonyms are also brought up for discussion in the second chapter. Nguyen asserts that the ethnonym Mieu should have originated from the ethnonym Mu, since he contends that “[u]pon entering Vietnam, Mieu people called themselves Na Ta Mu (literally, Mu people). . . . The Mieu say that although Mieu is a name given by outsiders, when it began to be used officially in the local administrative system (probably prior to the French period), they had to use it instead of the name they gave themselves” (p. 39). While the Vietnamese government avoids using this name due to its derogative meaning, “the Mieu see themselves as a distinct people, different from the Hmông, [and] they continue to refer to themselves using the term Mieu” (p. 40).
The third chapter presents a historical account of relations between the Mieu, the Tày, the Kinh, and the state. According to Nguyen, “Throughout Vietnam's history the Tày and the Thái—like other non-Kinh minorities—were viewed by the central states as backward in comparison to the Kinh. However, the Tày occupy the largest and most fertile mountain valleys. . . . The Mieu, on the other hand, as well as most of the other non-Tày peoples of the area, are located in remote areas at high elevation, and their live depends mainly upon shifting agriculture” (pp. 82–83). Given that, the Tày were connecting with the lowland Kinh, and Tày chiefs were appointed by Kinh dynasties to rule the northeast. Even so, the Tày had little influence on the Mieu. Aside from paying tax and corvée, non-Tày were relatively independent. Under the French colonial state, the French used the former political structure to rule highlanders. “French influences on the uplands and its population was light, and varied across territories and populations. . . . The Mieu still lived in the mountainous gorges, separate from the Tày,” says Nguyen (p. 97).
A period of tremendous change occurred when the Mieu and the entire region of northeastern Vietnam were integrated into the Vietnamese nation-state after the French were overthrown in 1954. Along with two other zones, the Northeast Autonomous Zone was established in 1956. The zone is divided into administrative units of provinces, districts, communes, and villages. These units are ruled by administrative committees, people's councils, and party organizations at each level. Though called “the autonomous zone,” the zone's autonomy is limited and subject to the central government's and the Party's regulations.
The cultural assimilation policy, where ethnic peoples' cultural practices were subject to alteration, began in this period. “The Kinh majority was considered to have reached the highest degree of development. . . . Non-Kinh lifestyles and cultures should be modernized in the Kinh way,” says Nguyen (p. 105). Major influential cultural policies included national education, a cultural campaign to eliminate superstitions and backward customs, and a fixed cultivation and settlement policy. Of these policies, Nguyen emphasizes the impact of the sedentary policy, which began in 1968. This was the major condition that caused the Mieu to move to live closer to and become more assimilated with the Tày. Another major change that led the Mieu to interact with and be influenced by the Kinh was the Đổi Mới policy, which started in 1986. New agricultural technologies for the improvement of wet-rice cultivation, combined with other agricultural innovations, gradually benefited the Mieu livelihood (pp. 118–19). The higher the economic return, the more the Mieu and Kinh interactions increased, which in turn accelerated Mieu acculturation to the Kinh lifestyle.
The fourth chapter draws data from previous chapters to discuss the major theme of the book, the ambiguity of identity. At first, Nguyen elaborates on the issue of the ethnonym Mieu by tracking its ethnic origin and locale back to southern China, where various groups of ethnic Hmông and ethnic Hmu lived. Since 1954, the Mieu have sought to preserve their ethnic identity and culture through oral history. The strong impacts of the Tày and the Kinh started in 1968, when shifting cultivation was banned and the Mieu began to settle down with wet-rice cultivation in the areas inhabited by the Tày and the Kinh. Amidst the fluctuations of identity and culture, the Mieu still preserve their ethnic identity and culture.
The fifth chapter extends the case of ethnic Mieu to other ethnic groups in Vietnam and compares ethnic policies in Vietnam to ethnic policies in China and Thailand under the framework of “technologies of power” (p. 7). Similarly to what Ito points out in reference to Vietnam, many ethnic groups ask for official government recognition. However, even though the state opens opportunities for ethnic peoples to assert their demands, it still hesitates to accept these reclassifications. The same problems, with different details, can be found in China and Thailand. In both of these countries, ethnic minorities are ranked as inferior to the ethnic majority. In addition, the ethnic classification policies are designed to serve the state's national integration goals rather than to respond to ethnic peoples' demands.
Although issues of ethnic classification in Vietnam and Southeast Asia have been discussed elsewhere, these two books are outstanding by virtue of their combinations of ethnographic and historical research. Since receiving permission to access ethnic communities in Vietnam is almost impossible, these books will be very useful to scholars of Vietnamese studies and Southeast Asian studies. The fact that the two books focus only on highlanders in northern Vietnam does not reduce the possibility of using them as a basis for expanding their methods and analyses to study the Central Highlands and other lowland ethnic groups in southern Vietnam. Ito's and Nguyen's discussions linking these Vietnamese cases to China, the USSR, and Thailand provide a jumping-off point for further comparative study regionally and globally.
