This is a welcome contribution to studies of re-use and renovation in the Roman and late antique periods. The volume opens with an excellent introduction which is impressively populated with examples and context, thus setting the standard for the papers that follow. Ng and Swetnam-Burland deftly deal with the traditional views of re-use without labouring the issues and signal some of the more detailed discussions that run throughout many of the subsequent papers, for example, how the focus on damnatio memoriae has rather eclipsed more prosaic discussions of economic recycling and indeed viewer perceptions. This anticipates the other contributors’ emphases on agency and decision-making processes behind re-purposing. With these foci, the more positive elements of re-use, which is often considered in negative terms, are drawn out; the stress is on the importance of the object/inscription and what it stands for in its re-purposed form, rather than the loss of what it had been.
Context is clearly fundamental to each paper and the contributors pay full attention to spatial, historical and chronological environments as well as the changing circumstances of the material in question. While the main focus is on the Imperial period, key contributions to the late antique period (Ogus, Kalas and Bonde, chs 6–8) are particularly welcome, and there is some good attention to earlier material from the Classical period (Keesling, ch. 3). It is also notable that some contributors provide even more context with introductions that note more recent despoliation (Laird on Ostia, ch. 2) and how modern processions (Japan and Spain) can inform theories on manipulation of space through such performances (Ossi, ch. 4). The geographical range is such that papers deal with material from Athens (Keesling), Antioch and Eleusis (Ossi), Aphrodisias (Ogus) and Tarragona (Bonde), but with a central focus on Italy (Longfellow, Laird, Keesling, Dumser, Kalas). Within this temporal and geographic range, there is plenty of scope for thematic variety, as well as having enough commonality to make individual arguments resonate with each other. Topics such as memory and message, patrons and viewer, artist and subject are covered. Additionally, pertinent discussions of deliberate appropriation, re-cycling, and re-use as a bridge are threads that run throughout the volume. Furthermore, tricky questions are tackled such as how modern conceptions of worth/value impact on our ability to judge the intentions of re-use (Laird) and how modern art-historical approaches can skew perceptions (Keesling).
Through the eight papers, a significant range of reasons for re-purposing is discussed. The material in question includes names of Greek sculptors (Keesling), wide-scale urban transformations (Dumser and Ogus), honorific statues (Longfellow and Laird) and architectural complexes (Ossi, Kalas and Bonde). Common to many of the papers is the deliberate appropriation of earlier images/material to provide symbolic connections. For example, Margaret L. Laird (ch. 2) discusses the re-purposing of a Lucius Verus base for Septimius Severus, the adopted son of Marcus Aurelius. The appropriation of the Lucius Verus base in the set of six imperial portraits in the Caserma dei Vigili would have emphasised the connection with the Antonines and thereby promoted the message of stability into the next generation. There are further layers of re-purposing, in that the original bases may have been altars in their earlier use. And as Laird notes, even if they were not altars, they were made to look like altars and so the significance is the same. In his work on arches, Adrian J. Ossi (ch. 4) notes how elements were physically re-used (Pisidian Antioch) or copied (Eleusis) to provide symbolic connections with the past and a familiarity to ease the possible tensions that may have occurred in a changing use of space. Ossi emphasises the importance of the articulation of the arches as liminal spaces, particularly through processions, and how this can be used to help incorporate political changes.
The careful attestation of context enables the entangled histories of the material to be appreciated, and this is complemented in many cases by the attention given to the role of the multiple patrons involved in the lives of the material (Kalas and Bonde). Gregor Kalas (ch. 7) notes the transfer of esteem from one patron to another, even if the latest patron only undertook repairs to the object. Similarly, according to Catherine M. Keesling (ch. 3), the value of a sculptor's signature could last through the different lives of a sculpture. She notes that the Roman habit of adding a sculptor's name to an original Greek statue was a sign of an assurance of quality rather than a deception. As in other examples, the past life of the object was as valuable or perhaps even more valuable in its more recent incarnation.
In three case studies from late Imperial Rome (the Audience Hall on the Sacra Via, the Maxentian Templum Romae and the Arch of Constantine), Elisha Ann Dumser (ch. 5) addresses the pertinent point of whether viewers would have understood the intended message, or whether it might have been enough to know that there had been re-use. She notes that meaning is conveyed through the physical material of the object, the act of appropriation and the reference to the original context, with the implication that there can be a lack of clarity in the intended message should any of these three elements be missing. Esen Ogus (ch. 6), through her examination of the transformation of Aphrodisias, uses four examples of late antique engagement with existing monuments to highlight different levels of intentional re-use. She outlines the tensions between the respect for the glorious past of the city with the need for material or change in religious focus. In her examples (the city walls, the temple of Aphrodite, the Sebasteion and the South Agora Gate and ‘Gaudin's Fountain’) she highlights the individuality of treatment of different spaces through intentionality and strategic re-use in practical and sacred contexts.
One of the great merits of this collection is that the individual papers make no fixed assumptions: instead the material and context is explored and the rationale behind choices made to re-use are questioned. A good example of this is Brenda Longfellow's carefully presented detail on the re-purposing of a statue of Octavian/Augustus into Constantine (ch. 1). She questions whether the appropriation was one of practical value (due to the likeness of the hair), but counters this with the fact that the hair had also been re-carved. This enables good consideration of the reasons for appropriation, ranging from practical (e.g. economic or resource-driven) to ideological (intentional appropriation to draw on the objects’ past meanings).
Throughout, the volume is impressively well illustrated. It is wide ranging, informative, challenging and thought provoking. It is one of the best edited volumes I have read for some time. While each paper has a specific aim, sight of the bigger picture and wider context is never lost. Moreover, the fact that the papers communicate with each other throughout the volume is indicative of both careful editing and collaborative participation by the contributors in the overall process. The success of this volume means that there is good scope to broaden the contributions to include extra-urban regions and more provinces in future endeavours.
