It is unusual that a book challenges a strong conventional wisdom and persuasively argues against it, but in Supreme Court Confirmation Hearings and Constitutional Change Paul Collins and Lori Ringhand successfully do just that. The book provides a celebratory view of U.S. Senate confirmation hearings of Supreme Court nominees. This is contrary to conventional portrayals suggesting that nowadays (or at least since Robert Bork) the hearings lack merit because nominees routinely avoid answering substantive questions such that the hearings have become little more than a hollow charade. In contrast, the central premise of Collins and Ringhand’s book is that the confirmation hearings “provide a democratic forum for the discussion and ratification of constitutional change” (p. 2). What is critical to understanding Collins and Ringhand’s argument is that confirmation hearings are not just about the Senate providing “consent” to the President’s nominee. Rather, hearings provide a democratic forum for the American public, through their Senators, to debate and discuss previous Court decisions that are either contested or accepted.
The first part of the book argues that the hearings “provide a mechanism through which public values are conveyed to the Court, and the Court’s decisions are in return engaged by the public” (p. 271). The second part of the book emphasizes a normative point, namely “the role the hearings play in democratically ratifying the constitutional choices made by the Supreme Court” (p. 272). The book argues that this “celebratory” perspective incorporates the public into a theory of constitutional change, whereas previously the public has not figured prominently in theories of constitutional change.
The book is easy to follow. Chapter 1 provides the introductory arguments and motivation for the book, and then provides a roadmap for how each chapter proceeds. In addition, within each chapter, the authors go to great lengths to articulate carefully how their arguments are linked—one of the book’s many strengths.
Chapter 2 provides an outstanding history of the confirmation hearings, supplying rich details about the process that are necessary to fully comprehend the arguments made throughout the book. In particular, it notes many of the changes that have taken place along with the increased attention and focus that modern confirmation hearings are well known for.
The heart of their argument and empirical testing lies in Chapter 3. There, Collins and Ringhand argue that the Senators’ questions are the means through which important issues and public opinion get transmitted to the soon-to-be-justice. It is because of the Senator’s desire for re-election that creates an incentive for Senators to ask about issues important to the public, thus making it a forum for democratic accountability. Moreover, they also argue that the hearings enable the Court to contribute to the debate about the proper interpretation of the Constitution because a substantial portion of the hearings focus on precedents or related issues. To empirically test this, Collins and Ringhand show that their dependent variable, the proportion of an issue’s attention in the hearings (amongst 19 issues), is a function of: the proportion of the public in Gallup polls that mention an issue as the most important problem, the percentage of legislative inquires in a particular area, the percentage of Supreme Court precedents in an issue area, as well as salient precedents.
Drilling deeper, Chapter 4 shows what issues are most frequently discussed and how those issues have evolved. Specifically, they find civil rights have dominated the hearings since the early 1970s, while previous hearings focused on a nominee’s background and other minor issues. Looking within civil rights, they show how subtopics (e.g., racial discrimination, abortion, right to bear arms, etc.) have shifted in close correspondence with the larger political environment.
Chapter 5 explores the role of precedent at the hearings. Specifically, it shows that precedential discussion emerged with Thurgood Marshall’s hearing, and reveals how much discussion is devoted to precedent. Since 1981, it constitutes about 16 percent of hearing dialogue (p. 146), and nominees engage in precedent more than senators. It also identifies Roe, Brown, Griswold, and Miranda as the top four discussed precedents (Table 5.1, p. 148).
Chapter 6 examines the “confirmation conditions” surrounding specific cases to see how Supreme Court decisions evolve from contested constitutional decisions to cases that nominees are expected to accept or reject as a condition of their confirmation. The chapter focuses on several areas, such as Brown, gender discrimination, Lochner and economic rights, and the right to bear arms. The central argument of this chapter is that some cases evolve very slowly from contested to accepted cases (e.g., Brown), while others move along this path very quickly (e.g., D.C. v. Heller).
The “104th Justice” is the focus of Chapter 7. It contrasts the hearings of Robert Bork and his replacement, Anthony Kennedy. The authors argue that Bork’s nomination did not fail because he was too forthcoming; rather, it failed because he gave the wrong answers regarding contested and accepted cases. In contrast, Kennedy gave the correct answers. Chapter 8 “explores the discussion of currently contested cases and issues, like Roe, at the hearings by illuminating what topics senators and nominees treat as open versus settled constitutional questions” (p. 234). It also examines the extent to which nominees claim privilege to not answer questions—the authors do not find an increase over time. Chapter 9 summarizes the main arguments and returns us to the celebrated view of the hearings by reminding us that “we must never forget that it is our Constitution they are expounding” (p. 277).
This book makes a strong contribution to our understanding of confirmation hearings. Previous research on the hearings largely focused on anecdotes or just a few nominees. Collins and Ringhand use systematic data to paint a thorough picture and provide a strong reminder of why confirmation hearings are vital for our democratic government. Importantly, they show that the hearings focus on substantively important issues. The book is well written and footnoted with great detail, and their large data collection is impressive.
I generally agree with the book’s argument and findings, though I offer a few comments in moving forward. This book assumes that Senators are delegates, rather than trustees. Furthermore, it might be difficult to disentangle a Senator’s motivation that is based on short-term reelection considerations compared to one that is concerned with ratifying the constitutional consensus. It is possible that the two may conflict. Another question emerges when Collins and Ringhand argue that public opinion is transmitted to the justices and the Court. In reality, it likely gets transmitted to the one nominee. Effective transmission of public opinion could only reach a substantial portion of the justices when there is a series of quick, successive replacements. The 2005–2010 years would have reached only 4 new justices—not even a majority. What happens to this transmission with long gaps between hearings? Finally, the book should pay more attention to television’s important role in transforming the hearings, specifically in shaping Senators’ behavior. One example, the issue of abortion differed for John Paul Stevens and Sandra Day O’Connor, who had the first televised hearings. When Stevens was confirmed, Roe had been law for almost 3 years, yet Stevens faced no questions involving abortion. However, O’Connor, in 1981, received the largest percentage of abortion related questions to date, and every nominee since has faced questions on it (see Figure 4.6, p. 122).
In summary, this is a great book and a must read for anybody who feels the confirmation hearings lack meaning in our constitutional system of government.
