Brazil's changing role in the world economy has received increasing attention in the media and academia and among global decision-makers (both state and corporate). A spate of recently published books examines variations on this theme, and this volume is one of the best amongst them. As an edited volume, it takes good advantage of its contributors' specialist knowledge to discuss the question of whether Brazil has made it into the ranks of the economic superpowers. To do so, its nine chapters discuss the features and foundations of Brazil's changing status in the global economy.
The analysis focuses on five main economic areas: agribusiness, energy, trade, big business and social investment. It examines how Brazil finally appears to have constructively combined rich resource endowment, knowledge/technological advantage and entrepreneurship with a pragmatic approach to policy to enhance its global reach and influence. The events that the chapters analyse are not only stories of unmitigated success, however; they also note obstacles hindering further development, including issues related to inadequate infrastructure, shortfalls in education, investment and technological capacity, weaknesses in the legal and regulatory framework (e.g. rural land ownership, genetically modified agricultural production, energy sector regulation, sometimes ‘incoherent trade policies’), legacies of the old-fashioned, inwardly oriented mentality among businesses and policy-makers alike, social inequality and lack of adequate social safety nets. The data and analysis presented in Neri's chapter on income policies and income distribution, with a specific focus on Bolsa Familia, does a very good job in presenting the wider socio-economic context within which Brazil is seeking ‘economic superpower’ status.
One of the most compelling features of the analysis is that rather than sell the Brazilian case as one of exclusively market-oriented capitalist success, it places the state and public policies at the centre of the story. Each chapter shows the costs and sometimes counterproductive nature of state intervention as well as the paradoxically positive longer-run consequences of such intervention. In the introduction, Brainard and Martinez-Diaz sum up their contributors' analyses, showing how state intervention and developmentalist policies laid the foundations of Brazil's current economic success, allowing political and business leaders to ‘translate this policy legacy into competitive advantages in global markets’ (p. 6). They also note the irony of how policies meant to develop self-sufficiency and autonomy ended up creating technological capacities and competitiveness in new sectors that would later ease Brazil's integration into the global economy.
All the authors do very well in providing an excellent mix of historical and comparative context, empirical data and thoughtful analysis on the prospects for their sector and its contribution to making Brazil an ‘economic superpower’. In the chapter on energy, for example, Sennes and Narciso present information on oil and gas regulatory regimes, the Latin American and Brazilian domestic energy matrix, evolving technological capacity and recent oil finds. Similarly, Nassar's chapter on agriculture and agro-energy presents information on Brazil's place among global agriculture exporters, compares biofuel indicators, and examines production and productivity in a number of agricultural commodities, while the Barros chapter analyses the performance of agribusiness and the challenges facing Brazil in becoming an agricultural superpower. Amann's chapter shows how the accumulation of technological capacity and its interplay with public policy created a number of very successful Brazilian multinational enterprises, and presents useful comparative data on developing country and Brazilian multinationals. Schneider's chapter focuses on how Brazilian big business leveraged natural endowments and state support to capture international markets, and discusses the evolution and strategies of some of the main large Brazilian firms.
Although well structured and coherently argued, the volume would have benefited from one additional chapter on the growing influence of Brazil in international and multilateral economic fora (although both Motta Veiga's and Mesquita Morreira's chapters on trade policy deal excellently with some of the relevant issues). Given the editors' definition of an economic superpower as ‘a country that can exert significant influence in the global economy – one that is a significant force as a rule maker, not just a rule taker’ (p. 12), a chapter devoted to and evaluating this aspect would have added weight to their case.
