There are some explanations for migration that many scholars take for granted. It is generally assumed, for example, that rural-to-urban migration occurs because of a decline in the socioeconomic conditions of rural areas or that violent conflict encourages labor migrants to return to their home countries. John Chalcraft's contribution is a brilliant corrective to this conventional thinking and represents a thoughtful challenge to scholars to rethink how we understand labor migration in general and from Syria to Lebanon in particular. Chalcraft's departure from traditional labor-migration frameworks centers on the notion of hegemonic incorporation, which sees labor migrants as enmeshed “within objectifying structures of accumulation by combinations of coercion and consent, repression and choice” (p. 3). In this framework, the structure–agent relationship is not deterministic but is shaped by multiple forms of agency and control. Migrant subjectivity is thus not entirely determined by structures but, nevertheless, reinforces them through the microlevel decisions that migrants take. It does so through the unintended consequences generated by “elective affinities,” a term used to refer to how individual choices forge long-term affinities.
The book relies on ethnographic and social-history methods to highlight the dialectic between subjectivity and structure. These methods provide the space to traverse multiple and intersecting relationships at particular historical moments. As such, the chapters are organized chronologically, beginning with outmigration before 1939 and extending to the present day. The transition to a cash economy was formative in the incorporation of Syria and Lebanon into the global capitalist economy in the early 1900s. Shifts wrought by the cash economy were simultaneously subject to the structural changes generated by the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, the colonization of the region, and transnational capital accumulation. In the late 1800s and early 1900s, Syrian migration was predominantly to the Americas. Migration occurred in response to deteriorating material conditions, as migrants wanted to acquire resources to regain economic independence back home. This discussion highlights transnational linkages between migrants and home-country economies, thus demonstrating that migrants are not always dispossessed and landless. By the 1930s, global economic depression had reduced incentives for transnational migration, and by the 1950s, Lebanon's growing economy had turned the country into a migrant destination.
This transformation contributed to the rise in Syrian migration to Lebanon after the 1950s. By the 1970s, there were approximately two Lebanese workers for every Syrian worker in Lebanon. Initially from border regions, these workers increasingly came from the eastern parts of Syria. Transformations in land ownership were important, as the Baʿthist redistribution of land led to a form of migration whereby sons and fathers migrated to try and earn cash to buy more land, tools, machines, and seed stock. These migrations paralleled other changes in the socioeconomic lives of Syrians: the development of new consumption patterns, new aspirations (such as education), and debts and obligations tied to land ownership. Other factors that contributed to migration included higher wages in Lebanon, the proximity of the two countries, and social networks that migrants could draw on in Lebanon. The most important determinants, however, were open borders between the countries and an elite consensus on the benefits of Syrian labor in Lebanon.
The political-economy conditions and elite consensus that had sustained Syrian migration to Lebanon had declined by the 1980s. By then, Syrian workers were increasingly seen—mostly by Lebanese Christians—as an “enemy” because of their perceived association with the Syrian military presence. Civil war and economic crisis disrupted the lives of many migrants but did not force them to leave in droves, though many were pushed out of Christian areas and subsequently found employment in other parts of Lebanon or in the Gulf. Socioeconomic conditions in Syria corresponded with changes in rural life, including the electrification of rural areas and the distribution of piped water. Such changes shifted the gender dynamics of rural labor and contributed to significant female outmigration for the first time. The emerging politics of the civil war, as well as the establishment in Lebanon of the League of Syrian Workers in 1977, a union representing Syrian workers, also shaped migrant agency. But by the early 1980s, the political landscape had made labor advocacy nearly impossible, and the League began to slowly lose its focus on social and labor rights.
The chapter on Pax Syriana, a period stretching from the end of the civil war in 1990 to Syria's military withdrawal from Lebanon in 2005, highlights the contemporary geopolitical, political-economy, and cultural conditions shaping Syrian migration. Chalcraft demonstrates through his interlocutors how Syrian migration was subject to different pressures: Syrian–Lebanese relations, labor-market patterns, competition with Lebanese labor, and so on. Because the workers’ experiences were constrained and shaped by Pax Syriana, its collapse in 2005 ushered in a period of instability and exile, the theme of the final chapter. Although Syrian migrants began to return after an initial large-scale withdrawal, they continued to experience feelings of isolation, exile, and exclusion due to the vitriol directed against them, conditions of the emerging political economy, social and cultural dislocation, and estrangement from home.
Chalcraft is extremely successful at fulfilling his own stated purpose, to understand “migrant circulation and menial labor in terms of hegemonic economic control” (p. 222). His conceptualization of the broader structural forces shaping migrant subjectivity is excellent, and the arguments are clear throughout the different time periods. Lebanon and Syria are unique border states because of their historical connections, and Chalcraft is very careful not to reify this relationship, instead treating it with sensitivity and complexity. His excellent use of ethnographic methods and the effective weaving of the narratives of his interlocutors into the book allow him to do so. His eschewing of reductive analysis, such as attributing outcomes merely to Pax Syriana, in favor of a method that intermixes political-economy, geopolitical, and cultural factors, is what makes this contribution so strong.
Chalcraft does, however, have a tendency to make erroneous assumptions about conditions of the political economy in Syria. He claims, for example, that the “slum planet” has not appeared in Syria (p. 207). However, around 40 percent of Syrians currently live in some sort of slum. Clearly this highlights the problems of Syria's rural and agricultural policies, another major structural factor that Chalcraft does not sufficiently address. Notwithstanding these oversights, this is an excellent contribution that appeals to a wide audience. The book will undoubtedly prove to be helpful in framing key processes, whether South–South migration or Syrian–Lebanese relations, that are so relevant to Middle East studies courses.
