Certain questions are enduring and central to understanding our own world. The roles of states and markets fall into this category, often hotly contested on ideological grounds. Over time, there has been a seemingly inexorable rise in the ratio of government spending to national income among modern democracies, leading to much debate over the legitimate sphere of state activity (the recent state bailout of international financial markets being a case in point.) Welfare economics sees a state responsible for underpinning property and personal rights, regulating market externalities and abuses of market power, providing public goods, seeking redistributive justice, and maintaining stability. Through public finance and macro policy, the invisible hand of the market is clasped together with the visible hand of the state to achieve social order. Handshaking gives way to arm wrestling in alternative views of the state. These other frames of reference are fearful that states are necessarily captured by vested interests: the socialist charge that the state was the organizing committee of the bourgeoisie, the public choice position that the rational pursuit of self-interest leaves the state held captive by private concerns. From both looms the authoritarian Leviathan, the deep-dwelling threat to real democracy, a thing needing to be tamed and constrained before it distorts and squeezes out more legitimate claimants. While the former resolves the problem by “going large” (through the dictatorship of the whole proletariat), the latter claims small is beautiful.
Martin Daunton offers a measured and informed analytical history of the British state. The focus is mainly Britain, the term is long run, and the approach is a careful and meticulous examination of each facet under consideration. The book is concerned with many of the big questions regarding the role of the state, competing interest groups, the impact of public finance and policy, the crafting of legitimacy and broad-based support, and of the forces shaping the state itself. Daunton offers a grand sweep of history from 1688 and the rise of the first “remarkably successful” British fiscal-military state (p. 1), through war, empire, and industrialization, to the middle of the twentieth century when the aftermath of World War II set the scene for a reconfiguration of the relationships between Britain and the world, and within Britain, between state, markets, and citizens.
This 2008 publication offers twelve chapters, eleven of them reprints from books (five) and journal articles (six) produced by Daunton in the two decades from 1988. Four of the chapters are partially rewritten: “Taxation and Representation in the Victorian City”; “‘Gentlemanly Capitalism’ and British Industry, 1820–1914”; “Britain and Globalization: Creating a Global Order, 1850–1914”; and, in particular, the chapter on housing policy, “Mutuality and State Formation: Britain and the United States, c.1890–1940.” “Acknowledgements” documents the origins and influences of each chapter, and the changes made. There is a useful index, but a consolidated bibliography would have been an asset.
Is there merit in such a collection of reprints? Should other academics think of following suit? For many scholars, the answer is no. The topics of their research are too diverse to warrant bringing them together between one set of covers. In the case of Daunton, the answer is a resounding yes. His work has steadily built upon explorations that follow one from the other, regarding the nature of firms, the conditions conducive to their successful development, the facilitating roles played by public policy, its financing and origins in Britain's remarkably efficient fiscal-military state, the terms upon which groups interact with and shape state formation, and the dynamics inherent in all of these elements. As a collection, these separate works fit together remarkably well, and speak to a coherent research agenda pursued over a successful lifetime.
Of particular note is the integrative and original chapter one. It is thoughtful and full of insight, weaving together the themes of the different chapters into a cogent and interesting account of related aspects of British economic development from the eighteenth- through to the mid-twentieth century. This introduction ends in reflective mood, observing that, “The view of the liberal state that emerges in this collection is that it was an honest broker between interests, the opponent of monopoly, and liberator of the individual and of associational life” (p. 37), a view that Daunton then problematizes. He highlights the ongoing and transformative negotiations between market and state, and opens up further avenues for enquiry.
This is an engaging book which conveniently brings together a very substantial body of work from an important scholar. Many themes resonate today: for example, the relationship between Whitehall and Threadneedle Street (the state and the financial sector); food security; domestic versus international concerns; science funding; private use versus common good; the organization of utilities; employment policy; public health; urbanization; infrastructure provision; levels and forms of welfare and taxation —the list goes on. State and Market in Victorian Britain should appeal to a very wide audience including economic and social historians, political scientists, development economists, and, of course, anyone interested in the contested roles of the state and the marketplace. Its publication in 2008 was really rather prescient.
