What do toadstools, mustard seeds, and fox testicles have in common? According to early modern medical authors, all three items stimulated sexual desire. Some aphrodisiacs from the 1600s and 1700s, including oysters and Spanish fly, are today still thought to provoke lust. But as Jennifer Evans shows in her new interesting book, there were very different frameworks for explaining the effects of these products on libidos in early modern England. Aphrodisiacs were believed to stimulate sexual desire by heating, nourishing, and increasing the amount of blood in the body, all of which encouraged the production of seed. Some products were believed to work because their external characteristics resembled the body parts they purportedly treated. (This was the explanation for the efficacy of toadstools, which were thought to resemble male testicles.) Because medical texts taught that sexual pleasure was necessary for conception, aphrodisiacs also served as treatments for infertility. This inexorable link between sexual desire and fertility is the central argument of Evans's book.
Aphrodisiacs, Infertility, and Medicine examines the connection between pleasure and procreation in medical texts spanning the 1600s and 1700s. The longevity of these beliefs, Evans argues, questions Thomas Laqueur's claim that sexual desire was no longer considered central to reproduction by the late eighteenth century. Evans's primary examples, however, were published in the early to mid-1700s, which does not wholly undermine Laqueur's argument about change by the end of the century. She draws on ballads, recipes, and popular literature, but the bulk of her sources are published medical treatises. As such, the book centers on theoretical discussions of aphrodisiacs rather than lived experiences of sexuality and infertility. Much of what we know about the topic, Evans explains, has focused on men or on literary sources. A focus on medicine offers welcome insight into the history of aphrodisiacs.
The book opens with a discussion of how people in the period recorded, shared, and consumed ideas about sexual health. A combination of medical writing and popular literature suggests that beliefs about the link between stimulation and conception were fairly prevalent in early modern England. The remainder of the book concentrates on how medical authors understood infertility and the bodily effects of aphrodisiacs. Ideas about sex and reproduction transformed over the course of the period, and some older beliefs resurfaced as authors plucked and plagiarized concepts from earlier texts. There was a growing tendency, for instance, to view men's and women's bodies as incommensurably different. Evans traces this shift in the changing language of infertility, which became increasingly gendered over time. Whereas medical authors once used the same terms to talk about men's and women's infertility, they came to use sex-specific labels by the eighteenth century. Despite such transformations, medical authors continued to imagine men's and women's infertility in similar ways. Evans shows this continuity by closely examining medical explanations of the causes of infertility and how the same products were thought to work as stimulants in the bodies of both sexes. Aphrodisiacs included herbs and foods that heated the body, as well as “windy meats” that caused flatulence, such as beans and peas. These products did not simply enable men and women to engage in sexual acts. Rather, they improved the body's ability to produce high-quality seed and, by extension, experience pleasure.
In the book's final chapter, Evans shows the presence of aphrodisiacs in recipes and remedies for inducing menstruation, which provoked miscarriage. Menstruation was key to early modern women's reproductive abilities, and so triggering it was also thought to benefit the reproductive system. By highlighting the similarities between drugs meant to induce menstruation and promote fertility, Evans suggests that aphrodisiacs served multiple purposes for early modern women. What historians previously viewed as abortifacients were, in some instances, fertility drugs. Perhaps most importantly, these findings suggest that historians take a more comprehensive view of sexual health in the period, one that does not separate the history of contraception from the history of fertility.
This book is aimed at specialists rather than general readers, though anyone interested in the history of medicine and reproduction will find intriguing details. Evans might have devoted even more space to explaining how her wonderful study alters what we know about sex, gender, and medical practice in the period. Her book reveals that aphrodisiacs were more significant to early modern sexual health practices than historians have realized, which has important ramifications for the history of reproduction and medicine.
