Bibler provides a distinctive framework for reading mid-twentieth-century southern literature by applying queer theory to the southern plantation narrative. Through his analysis of nine texts from the period from 1936 to 1968, Bibler argues that the eight writers he discusses used same-sex relations as a way to imagine social equality in the South. Reading works ranging from Williams's Cat on a Hot Tin Roof to Hellman's The Little Foxes, Bibler asserts that these works share similar liberal political engagements with the South's plantation past and use the structural plantation hierarchy itself, paradoxically, as a figure for the possibilities for social equality. He reads the plantation networks of social relations as queer because they tolerate homosocial and sometimes homosexual relations and even enable them. Bibler engages with scholarship in southern studies that has examined the historical and ideological articulation of patriarchal paternalism in the South, as a basis for the plantation myth as family myth and the South itself imagined as a family – what Richard H. King calls the “family romance” in southern literature. Noting that this paternalism is rooted in the rhetoric of familial bonds used to undergird social hierarchy, Bibler asks what difference it makes when authors disrupt the patriarchal mythology with non-heteronormative relations. He adapts Leo Bersani's theory of “homo-ness,” bonds based on sexual sameness which establish an egalitarian social bond.
While, in many of the works Bibler examines, the idea of sexual sameness points to relationships that potentially evade or at least complicate the plantation hierarchy, those same bonds also often reinforce the subordination of Others, who are still marginalized based on race or gender categories and power relations. Bibler analyzes themes of homosexual and homoerotic relations between elite white men in Faulkner's Absalom, Absalom! and in Williams. He traces a figurative “southern kitchen romance” between white plantation mistresses and African American women serving as maids in Hellman's Another Part of the Forest, Katherine Anne Porter's The Old Order, Hellman's The Little Foxes, and Walker's Jubilee. Finally, he discusses relationships between black men in Styron's The Confessions of Nat Turner and Bontemps's Black Thunder. While some of Bibler's readings are more persuasive than others (his analysis of Williams more so than that of Styron, for example), his discussion reframes this body of literature and offers a cogent contribution to southern literary studies.
