Many readers will be familiar with performance artist Diane Torr from her popular twenty-year-old series of “Man for a Day” workshops, an ongoing international performance project in which Torr trains women to impersonate men, then takes them out in public for their own firsthand attempts at gender subterfuge. With Sex, Drag, and Male Roles: Investigating Gender as Performance, a collaboration with critic Steven Bottoms, Torr expands her scope well beyond the drag king workshop. In the book, Torr details three decades’ worth of various examples of her performance work, presenting a detailed and engaging first-person account throughout; Bottoms intersperses Torr's narrative with historical detail to highlight how “[h]er personal artistic evolution, in effect, shadows a cultural evolution in feminist, queer, and transgender activism” (2). Their coauthorship is a fruitful pairing, negotiated rather seamlessly on the page through the use of two different fonts to signify the two authorial voices; in the final chapter, the two voices visually merge into one.
Bottoms's cogent introduction includes a concise overview of the history of “a long-standing, though historically fragmented, tradition of female-to-male theatrical cross-dressing” (9), and a survey of the major theoretical discussions concerning drag king performance. Particularly pointed is his critique of Halberstam's privileging of “butch realness” over a more theatrical and self-consciously imitative art of male impersonation (29), which opens up a necessary space for the appreciation of the social contributions of Torr's distinctive types of drag king practice. Part 1 of the book, “Foundations,” comprises three chapters that each examine a different period in Torr's evolution as a gender-bending artist. The first two, “Becoming Feminine” and “Becoming Androgynous,” look at her relationship to the feminist movements of the 1970s and 1980s and describe in detail a number of her early New York performance art pieces, including her work at P.S. 122 and the WOW Café. Torr's explorations of gender performance off the stage during this period are also discussed, including her use of the martial arts practice of aikido to achieve a more gender-neutral state, as well as her forays into the practice of go-go dancing, described by Torr as a type of “feminine drag” (51). The third chapter, “Becoming Masculine,” continues the chronology. It describes her development, in collaboration with transgender performance artist Johnny Science, of the “Man for a Day” workshop, and also highlights her relationship with Annie Sprinkle, who housed the workshop at her salon in its early years.
The second part of the book, “Applications,” focuses on Torr's wide-ranging exploration of gender impersonation over the two decades that followed, with Bottoms emphasizing the relationship of these explorations to larger social movements. Each of Part 2's four chapters relates the drag king practice to a different theme, considering sexuality, empowerment, cultural memory, and ideas of selfhood, respectively. Chapter 6, “Drag and Memory,” is especially strong and also seems particularly topical given recent scholarly interest in modes of queer temporality. Here, Torr illustrates how, through performance, she has attempted to reconceive aspects of her own “cultural history and heritage by using male character roles to claim a kind of ownership” (169). Torr describes her character Jack Sprat, an anachronistic throwback to the 1960s mod era derived from her own experience as a mod girl. Ready, Aye Ready, another of the revisionist performances she details, is a queering of the work of the eighteenth-century Scottish poet Robert Burns, which turns Burns's delightfully explicit poems, such as “Ode to Spring” and “Nine Inch Will Please a Lady,” into a series of ditties and speeches performed in drag. Lastly, Torr explores drag as a means of coping with loss, detailing her performances as her own brother Donald, who died of AIDS. Her touching account of this practice points to the significant potential of drag performance as a particularly queer mode of remembrance, and illustrates various ways in which drag's cultural significance goes beyond its revelation of essentialized gender norms.
The final part of the book, “Torr Texts,” serves up the complete scripts of four of Torr's performances described in earlier chapters: Happy Jack, Drag Kings and Subjects, BULL!, and Donald Does Dusty. These scripts, along with the nineteen photographs included throughout the book, help the reader gain a more complete appreciation of the range of Torr's characters. The book closes in perhaps the most appropriate way, with “Man for a Day: A Do-It-Yourself-Guide,” which leads the reader step by step through a process of transformation and includes useful tips on breast binding, painting whiskers, and “packing.”
The book concludes with Torr's touching statement that, “One thing I've learned, after decades of involvement with activism and performance, is that we have the potential, at all times, to call change into existence” (221). Sex, Drag, and Male Roles offers a significant contribution as a cultural history of the drag king practice; it may also prove valuable as an inspiration for gender-bending artists and performer-activists for years to come.
