On Tuesday 28 July 1903, the regular sitting of the Oxford City Police Court was enlivened by an exceptionally numerous and unusually respectable body of defendants. Instead of the familiar weekly sprinkling of petty thieves, recalcitrant tramps and habitual drunkards, the magistrates were faced by some thirty prominent citizens, including most of Oxford's leading Free Church ministers. All were answering summonses for failing to pay the district rate.Footnote 1 This court appearance was a local manifestation of ‘passive resistance’ to the Education Act of 1902, part of a nationwide phenomenon which, by the end of 1905, saw 53,863 summonses and the imprisonment of 189 people for steadfast refusal to pay rates for the support of denominational schools.Footnote 2 Civil disobedience on such a significant scale took the government by surprise, and although it failed to secure the amendment or repeal of the act, passive resistance contributed to the political changes which brought the Liberals to power in 1906.Footnote 3 It also reflected the position and outlook of the Free Churches in the first decade of the twentieth century: a combination of optimism and insecurity, respectability and militancy.Footnote 4
The historiography of the genesis and reception of the act is extensive. As well as brief treatments in general histories of religion and education in the period by Benjamin Sacks, Marjorie Cruickshank and James Murphy,Footnote 5 the interplay of political and denominational loyalties in the education debates of the 1890s and early 1900s have been analysed by J. R. Fairhurst in a thesis of 1974,Footnote 6 Stephen Koss in Nonconformity in Modern British Politics (1975), David Bebbington in The Nonconformist Conscience: Chapel and Politics 1870 –1914 (1982) and Ian Machin in Politics and the Churches in Great Britain, 1869 to 1921 (1987). D. R. Pugh has explored the debate from the perspectives of Nonconformity, Wesleyan Methodism and those in several denominations who were eager for compromise.Footnote 7 James Munson's chapter on ‘Passive Resistance and Nonconformist Power’ in his The Nonconformists (1991) draws on his doctoral thesis of 1973, which gave close attention to the passive resistance campaign. These studies have approached passive resistance from the standpoint of national politics; the present article drills down into a local context, and offers a textured exploration of Nonconformity in an unlikely setting.
Munson concludes that the majority of cases of passive resistance occurred in smaller towns and cities, with a population of less than one hundred thousand, and there was a correlation between the strength of passive resistance and the strength of Nonconformity.Footnote 8 In size, Oxford, a city of some fifty-eight thousand people,Footnote 9 was typical of the centres of passive resistance; as a cathedral and university city, and the birthplace of Tractarianism, it was distinctive. This article will argue that Nonconformity was a growing and vocal presence, even in Oxford, and that the Free Churches’ ability to muster and articulate significant opposition to the Education Act demonstrated the movement's strength and self-confidence. Going beyond public meetings to passive resistance, although only an option for a minority, carried symbolic weight as an indicator of dissent, recasting the debate over education policy into the rhetoric of martyrdom.
The Education Act of 1902 emerged from more than a decade of debate and failed legislation seeking to address a cluster of issues around primary and secondary education in England and Wales.Footnote 10 Before 1870, elementary education was provided by a network of ‘voluntary’ schools, largely funded and controlled by religious bodies, principally the National Society (Church of England), the British and Foreign Schools Society (non-denominational, but largely Nonconformist in support), the Roman Catholics and the Wesleyan Methodists. W. E. Forster's Education Act of 1870 acknowledged that the voluntary system was failing to keep pace with an increasing population as well as with rising costs and expectations, and so permitted the establishment of local school boards where existing educational provision was deemed inadequate. The boards, elected triennially, were empowered to levy a rate to build and then manage new schools. Consequently the act created a dual system of elementary education, setting the rate-funded board schools alongside the voluntary schools, funded by supporters’ subscriptions, pupils’ fees and government grants. Most voluntary schools operated on an explicitly denominational basis, but in the board schools religious education, where offered, was required to be non-denominational, under William Cowper-Temple's amendment to the act.Footnote 11
Forster's act was a compromise, both between the rival advocates of unashamedly denominational and wholly secular education and between supporters of voluntary provision and those urging a state-funded and regulated national system. These debates about fundamental principles continued in the ensuing decades, and were sharpened by increasing concerns about many aspects of the nation's educational structure.Footnote 12 Under the dual system, voluntary schools provided the majority of school places and pupil attendances (56 per cent and 52 per cent respectively in 1901)Footnote 13 but struggled to make ends meet. Education department figures for 1900, for instance, showed that more than half of the voluntary schools were financially ‘under water’; in the same year Randall Davidson warned Archbishop Temple that legislation was needed to ‘avert catastrophe’.Footnote 14 The board schools had access to rate funding and could pay better salaries to teachers, but they faced complaints of extravagance and inefficiency. Anglicans and Roman Catholics denounced the non-denominational Bible teaching of the board schools as ‘godless’ or as ‘a new denominationalism’ masquerading as tolerance,Footnote 15 while Free Church leaders and Radical MPs lost no opportunity to complain of ‘sectarian’ teaching and Anglican proselytizing in those single-school districts where Nonconformist families had no choice but to send their children to Church of England schools. The dual system, bedevilled by this ‘religious warfare’,Footnote 16 seemed ill equipped to deliver consistent and effective elementary education, let alone to address the need for proper secondary education and professional teacher training. Through the late 1880s and 1890s, options were debated in the heavyweight periodicals and explored by royal commissions. Meanwhile reforms in local government, which brought the creation of county and county borough councils in 1888, suggested the possibility of a more comprehensive and less contentious system for managing the nation's schools.Footnote 17
Between 1896 and 1901, the Unionist government brought forward a series of abortive measures to reform education. Finally, towards the end of 1901, A. J. Balfour and the duke of Devonshire took the lead in crafting new and comprehensive legislation. Introduced in the House of Commons on 24 March 1902, the Education Act received the royal assent on 18 December and came into force in England and Wales in March 1903.Footnote 18 Balfour's act abolished the school boards, transferring their assets and responsibilities to county and county-borough councils as Local Education Authorities (LEAs). Voluntary schools remained in being, but could opt to be ‘maintained’ by the LEA. Under this arrangement, the LEA would appoint two of the school's six managers, pay the teachers’ salaries and provide textbooks and teaching materials, while the denomination paid for the upkeep of the school building.Footnote 19
From the outset the Education Bill faced strong opposition from the Free Churches. By 1902 the Free Church denominations (the Congregationalists, Baptists and Methodists) felt confident in their numerical strength, financial resources and popular appeal. Statistics suggested that over half the active membership of all non-Roman Catholic churches in England and Wales was Nonconformist; in the wider Anglo-Saxon world, Nonconformists outnumbered Anglicans by six to one.Footnote 20 In the National Council of the Evangelical Free Churches, formed in 1896 and co-ordinating a nationwide network of seven hundred local councils and thirty-six federations,Footnote 21 the cluster of denominations had a mechanism for joint action, including political lobbying. The gradual repeal of civil disabilities during the nineteenth century had given Nonconformists access to the franchise, to public office and to the universities, but had left memories of battles against injustice and continuing resentment at the privileges of the established church. This resentment was exacerbated by antipathy and fear as the Church of England seemed to be moving closer to Rome under the influence of Anglo-Catholicism.Footnote 22 Free Church confidence and Nonconformist grievances could be mobilized in defence of religious liberty, civil equality and Evangelical Protestantism, and in opposition to privilege and popery. Education, which had been a neuralgic issue between the Church of England and the Nonconformists since the 1830s, was guaranteed to raise Free Church anxieties, reopen old wounds and galvanize opposition. Moreover, after several years of division over the morality of the South African War, the Free Churches needed a cause around which to unite, and education offered an ideal campaign to arouse the Nonconformist conscience.Footnote 23 Critical contemporaries were quick to see this, and to level accusations of political opportunism.Footnote 24 In their defence, however, it should be said that the Free Churches had consistently supported the school boards and had equally consistently opposed additional state aid to denominational schools. Through the 1890s the annual assemblies of the Baptists, Congregationalists and Primitive Methodists, and the National Council of the Evangelical Free Churches, had called for the establishment of unsectarian Christian schools in every district, demanded the abolition of religious tests for teachers, advocated a national system of teacher training colleges and opposed rate funding for schools giving denominational religious instruction.Footnote 25 Balfour's bill cut across all these objectives, and it therefore provoked angry reactions. The exception to this uniformity of Free Church opposition came from the Wesleyan Methodists, because the Wesleyans, with more than four hundred and fifty schools of their own, had a historical commitment to denominational education and also stood to benefit financially from the new system. Wesleyan opinion, therefore, was sharply divided.Footnote 26
Ten days after the introduction of the bill in the House of Commons, Joseph Parker, chairman of the Congregational Union and president-designate of the Free Church Council, wrote to The Times calling for ‘quiet, resolute, and uncompromising resistance’ to the proposals.Footnote 27 Through the spring and summer of 1902, the regular denominational assemblies and conferences, and specially convened gatherings, focused opposition to the bill. A. M. Fairbairn, principal of Mansfield College, Oxford, led a delegation of church leaders to meet Balfour in June, setting out the Free Churches’ objections, and concluding: ‘We will not submit.’Footnote 28
Alongside this rallying of opposition and lobbying the government, Free Church spokesmen raised the possibility of ‘passive resistance’ to the education measure. George White, a Baptist MP, seems to have been the first to suggest that opponents of ‘sectarian’ schools might refuse to pay the education rate, and the notion was picked up by Robertson Nicoll, the influential editor of the British Weekly.Footnote 29 Nicoll coined the phrase ‘passive resistance’, and by the autumn of 1902 the National Free Church Council was asking its local affiliates to consider creating a register of those pledged to refuse the rate. A national Passive Resistance Committee was formed in December 1902, with John Clifford, a doughty veteran of many educational battles, as president.Footnote 30 Momentum built up during the first half of 1903, between the passing of the act and the issuing of the first rate demands under the new legislation. Amidst an avalanche of propaganda from the National Council and the press, local Free Church Councils were urged to coordinate resistance directly, or to set up Passive Resistance or Citizens’ Education Leagues to do so. The press's resources included a new journal, The Crusader, dedicated to the cause. The campaign was pursued with vigour until the Liberal landslide in the general election of 1906. Thereafter, as the Liberal government's attempts to redeem its pledge to amend the 1902 act were frustrated by the House of Lords, passive resistance continued. Most of the active opposition ended with the First World War, but Clifford persisted in refusing the rate until his death in 1923 and a passive resistance case was recorded in Bakewell as late as 1926.Footnote 31
This, then, was the national backdrop to the court appearance of Oxford Free Church leaders in July 1903. What was the local context for passive resistance? And how did the campaign play out in Oxford?
In 1903 Oxford had a full range of voluntary schools: nineteen Anglican, two Roman Catholic and one Wesleyan;Footnote 32 three British or independent schools, two in the city centre and one in East Oxford, had been handed over to the school board in 1898.Footnote 33 The city's school board, established in 1871 in the teeth of Anglican opposition, only began to build its own schools in the late 1890s; hitherto, strenuous fundraising by the denominations (mostly Anglicans) met the need for schools in the growing suburbs and kept the board at bay.Footnote 34 The board reflected the religious and political complexion of the city, including among its members in 1902 the city's senior Baptist minister, James Dann, and Isaac Alden, one of his deacons, as well as the Conservative Alderman Hugh Hall and Commander W. H. Maunsell, a staunch supporter of the voluntary schools and the National Society.Footnote 35 The city council, where the Conservatives enjoyed a comfortable majority over the Liberals,Footnote 36 quickly brought forward a scheme to set up an education committee, and the process of implementation rolled forward in the spring of 1903, as managers were nominated for the ‘maintained’ schools and the additional costs were incorporated into the district rates. At the same time, Free Church leaders signalled their opposition to the act and their determination to resist the rate.
By the beginning of the twentieth century there was a strong Free Church constituency in the city of Oxford and its rural hinterland. A correspondent writing to the Conservative-leaning Oxford Times in October 1903 suggested that there were five thousand Nonconformists in the city.Footnote 37 Baptists, Congregationalists and three separate Methodist denominations were well represented, and Mansfield College, opened in 1886, brought a distinguished faculty and a body of ministerial students to strengthen the Free Church cause.Footnote 38 Already linked informally, the denominations came together in the Oxford Nonconformist Council (later the Free Church Council) in 1895. The Free Churches were also active in the commercial life of the city and in municipal politics. Although a minority in a city dominated by a Conservative and Anglican establishment, Oxford's Free Churches celebrated their growing numbers and were alert to perceived infringements of their civil and religious liberties.
Opposition to Balfour's education proposals was to be expected from the Oxford Free Churches. From its inception, education was a regular item on the agenda of the council and its executive committee. Moreover, from 1896 the council's president was John Massie, a tutor at Mansfield College and a member of the Bryce Commission on Secondary Education. Massie was an early and persistent passive resister, a member of the national Passive Resistance Committee and an indefatigable campaigner, to the extent that he resigned from his post at Mansfield in summer 1903 in order to ‘devote himself to public work, and more especially to the cause of Religious Equality’. Massie was subsequently elected Liberal MP for the Cricklade division of Wiltshire in 1906.Footnote 39
The Oxford Free Church Council began to coordinate opposition to the bill in the spring of 1902. A ‘thoroughly representative’ meeting assembled at the Free Methodist chapel on 8 May, and passed a series of resolutions condemning the bill on both educational and Free Church principles.Footnote 40 Thereafter the progress of the legislation through parliament was tracked by the Free Church Magazine, with its stages punctuated by public meetings, critical resolutions and denunciations from the pulpit. On 27 July 1902, for example, James Robertson told his congregation at George Street Congregational Church that the bill was ‘a contradiction and negation of the very principles which make us Free Churchmen’.Footnote 41 Following the successful passage of the bill, Massie warned the readers of the Free Church Magazine that ‘the day of compromise is past’.Footnote 42 Three months later R. W. Perks, the most high-profile lay Wesleyan of his generation, Liberal MP for Louth, inveterate lobbyist and founder of the Nonconformist Parliamentary Council, was the star speaker at a public meeting in Oxford, describing the bill, to tumultuous applause, as ‘one of the most reactionary measures which had ever disgraced the Statute Book of this country’.Footnote 43
As well as pulpit and platform rhetoric, letters to the local press and plans to make the education issue a test question at the municipal elections,Footnote 44 the Free Churches took up the possibility of passive resistance. In September 1902 the National Free Church Council asked local councils to consider enrolling the names of potential resisters, and to decide whether to do so before or after the reassembling of parliament in October. The Oxford Free Church Council voted in principle for enrolment, opting to wait until parliament gathered. It also suggested a petition to the king to withhold the royal assent from the bill, if passed by parliament, pending a general election, and urged county councils likewise to refuse to implement the legislation. The council argued that the bill was being forced through parliament by undemocratic and unconstitutional means; that the government, re-elected in 1900 to end the South African War, had no mandate for such sweeping and contentious domestic legislation; and that the evidence of by-elections was that the country opposed the measure.Footnote 45
In March 1903 the council's executive agreed to organize a meeting to discuss ‘the procedure of forming a Citizens’ League’.Footnote 46 At the beginning of May, the Liberal-leaning Oxford Chronicle carried ‘An Apologia for Passive Resistance’, setting out the case for refusing the education rate. The ‘Apologia’ was unsigned, but Massie's influence was detected in the text.Footnote 47 The authors expressed an obligation to explain to their fellow citizens why they were taking the ‘unusual course’ of refusing the rate. The political and democratic arguments made in October 1902 were repeated and amplified, but the principal reason justifying passive resistance was that the resisters regarded the rate as ‘an outrage upon conscience’. Ratepayers of all denominations were being required to fund the teaching of one denomination; citizens were being asked to pay for ‘a sectarian teaching in which they do not believe and which they regard besides as, in certain respects, pernicious in itself and injurious to the well-being of the State’; parents were effectively supporting the proselytizing of their own children; and teachers were under pressure to sacrifice their beliefs for the sake of professional advancement. The ‘Apologia’ continued that the act represented a ‘bargain’ between the government and the Church of England and so violated the principle that the state should be impartial between denominations, and it broke the principle that publicly funded bodies should be under public management. Quiet resistance to ‘an unjust measure, so unjustifiably imposed’ was a ‘bounden duty’, undertaken ‘with a solemn and deliberate sense of responsibility’ by people who ‘have unfailingly honoured and obeyed the law’ but who believed that ‘there must be limits to civil obedience’.Footnote 48
At the beginning of June twenty ratepayers, headed by Massie, Robertson and Dann, presented a memorial to the city council affirming their intention of ‘leaving the law to take its course for the collection of that part of the Education Rate which is levied for the support of sectarian schools’. The signatories emphasized their willingness to pay the rest of the general district and education rate, and expressed ‘our sincere regret’ that the corporation's collectors had refused to accept part payment, as had happened elsewhere.Footnote 49 Two days later the Free Church Council resolved to form a Citizens’ Education League in Oxford, comprising ‘those who individually feel constrained to refuse payment of the rate for sectarian schools’ and sympathizers unable to refuse the rate ‘for one reason or another’ but nonetheless pledged to support the amendment or repeal of the act. The officers and committee of the league corresponded closely with the Free Church Council executive, with the same president (Massie), secretary (Robertson) and treasurer (James Nix, a Wesleyan).Footnote 50
By July 1903, when the first resisters appeared in court, the number had grown to twenty-nine, and a further five summonses were heard in early September. ‘Watcher’, writing in the Oxford Chronicle, claimed that the authorities wanted to deal with all the cases together, and that distraints for non-payment would soon follow.Footnote 51 On 25 September, the Chronicle reported that the city police had spent two days visiting the homes of thirty resisters, distraining a range of goods, including a plated spirit kettle and stand and an omelette dish from Massie's home, a barometer from the Revd A. S. Welch (Summertown's Congregational minister), a marble clock from Robertson, two candlesticks from Vernon Bartlet, another Mansfield tutor, and a brass coal scoop from Mrs Hazel. Clocks, teapots, candlesticks and cutlery were popular items, carefully wrapped, labelled and removed by the police in a rubber-tyred brougham.Footnote 52 A week later, when the goods were auctioned at the town hall, an agent bought the items back on behalf of the original owners, paying £5 or £6 more than the outstanding rates.
Three themes emerge from the process of summons, distraint and sale. First, there was a good deal of common ground, sometimes even collusion, between the resisters and the authorities. This was most marked in the appearance before the city magistrates at the end of July. The resisters were not placed in the dock; their solicitor was given ample opportunity to make a speech against the act; and the bench overruled the city solicitor's plea that part-payment of the rate was contrary to administrative practice and perhaps to law. This ‘magisterial compromise’ was unsurprising, given the composition of the bench, which included several staunch Free Churchmen, one of whom, the Liberal alderman Robert Buckell, spoke at a Citizens’ League meeting later on the same day. When the authorities came to distrain goods later in the summer, the proceedings were described as ‘good-humoured’ and ‘amicable’: the resisters were given notice of the police visit, and had generally identified a suitable and portable item for removal, sometimes leaving it with a maid to hand over to the officers.
Secondly, there was a noticeable concern to avoid public disorder. The police served the warrants for distraint with ‘the greatest secrecy’ in order ‘to prevent any interference or attempts at demonstration on the part of the less considerate of the population’. Evidently this was seen not as depriving the resisters of desirable publicity, but as a courtesy to the respectable citizens whose homes were being raided. In a leading article on 31 July, the Oxford Chronicle commented that ‘It is not at all likely that [the sales] will be marked in Oxford by the ebullitions of feeling that have broken out in many other towns.’ ‘Rowdy scenes’ would be ‘strongly discountenanced by those concerned in the Oxford cases’. In fact the first sale did witness ‘noisy demonstrations’ and ‘lively incidents’, but this was attributed to idlers and opponents of the cause.Footnote 53
Thirdly, there was an element of theatricality in the process. Appearing in court in July, Massie attempted to pay the uncontested portion of the rate to the city solicitor, who, pushing the money away, declared: ‘I refuse to take it.’ Mr Clark, of Polstead Road, initially refused to admit the distraining officers to his house, negotiating with them through the letter-box. Mr Couldrey, of Abbey Road, invited them to stay for tea and a short prayer meeting, suggesting that it ‘would do them all a lot of good’.Footnote 54
Theatre of a different kind came into play with the Primitive Methodist minister John Leach. Across the country, Primitive Methodists were among the most determined resisters, and most willing to face imprisonment.Footnote 55 Leach, an ‘uncompromising Radical’ and ‘valiant champion of religious equality’, was not satisfied with the polite and decorous process of distraint. Like Clifford and other militant resisters, he sought to divest himself of distrainable goods in order to force the authorities to send him to prison. This took some time: in September 1903 the police distrained some pictures from his home; in March 1904, when Leach claimed that the contents of the manse belonged either to his wife or to the circuit, the officers politely asked for documentary proof, and left the house with a ‘handsome but incomplete Indian tea service’ and two vases. By October 1904 Leach was better prepared, and had his documents in place, with the result that he served seven days’ imprisonment in Oxford Castle, emerging with the cry ‘Hallelujah! I am still a Passive Resister!’ The following summer Leach's appointment in the Oxford Circuit ended, but his commitment to passive resistance continued, leading to a further term of imprisonment, this time in Reading.Footnote 56 By the time of his death, in May 1912, Leach had been to gaol six times for passive resistance.Footnote 57
John Leach laid the blame for his imprisonment on the archbishop of Canterbury, Cardinal Vaughan and the Wesleyan Conference.Footnote 58 This was unfair in all respects, but it did highlight differences between the Free Churches over passive resistance, particularly divisions within the Wesleyan Connexion. When Robert Perks addressed the Free Church Council in April 1903, he praised Oxford's Wesleyans as ahead of their fellows in opposition to the act, and Wesleyan lay leaders such as J. H. Salter and James Nix spoke out strongly against it.Footnote 59 Nix was an early passive resister, but he paid the rate before distraint proceedings began, and the same seems to have happened with the small number of Wesleyan resisters in 1904.Footnote 60 The Wesleyan ministers, meanwhile, were conspicuously absent from passive resistance gatherings.Footnote 61 Compounding the confusion, the Wesleyan Boys’ School became a ‘maintained’ school under the act, and Salter and Nix remained on the governing body; the two managers appointed by the city council were the sympathetic Nonconformists James Dann and H. S. Kingerlee.Footnote 62
Who, then, were Oxford's passive resisters? In 1903–4, forty-four citizens were involved in passive resistance, as signatories to the memorial to the city council, in answering a rate summons, or as subjects of a distraint.Footnote 63 Since ratepayers were householders, and therefore predominantly male, it is not surprising that forty-two of the resisters were men; the two female resisters were Mrs Emma Hazel, of Beechcroft Road, and Miss Emma Barnett, of Park Crescent, both in the affluent northern suburbs. Eleven of the resisters were ministers, or members of staff at Mansfield College, and two others were laymen in church-related employment. Denominational affiliation, where it can be established, indicates a majority of Baptists (13), a significant number of Congregationalists (12) and a smaller number of Methodists (9, across three denominations).Footnote 64 The size of the sample makes drawing conclusions difficult, but it may be noted that the Oxford data broadly supports James Munson's analysis that Baptists and Congregationalists were active resisters, but shows a much smaller proportion of Primitive Methodists and a much higher proportion of ministers than across the country as a whole.Footnote 65
The response to the passive resistance campaign largely reflected predictable political and denominational affiliations. The Oxford Chronicle supported the resisters, praising their action as ‘a question of conscience’ and denying any connection between the movement and the Liberal Party.Footnote 66 The Conservative-leaning newspapers, the Oxford Times and Jackson's Oxford Journal, on the other hand, deplored the campaign as ‘simply ludicrous’ and ‘painless martyrdom at the risk of a little personal inconvenience’.Footnote 67 For the Conservatives, passive resistance was unjustified and unconstitutional, setting a dangerous example of law-breaking.Footnote 68 The controversy played some part in the 1903 municipal elections, when Norman Smith, bursar of Mansfield College, was a candidate in the city's North ward. Conservative posters proclaimed that Smith, a resister, stood for ‘the destruction of Church Schools’, and he was placed at the bottom of the poll.Footnote 69 It may be suggested that the education issue strengthened loyalties and inflamed rhetoric on both sides, but therefore did not significantly affect the balance of power in the city.
Passive resistance continued in Oxford at least until the outbreak of the First World War: James Dann was the spokesman for a group of twenty-five resisters, many of them veterans of 1903, who appeared before the magistrates on 13 July 1914 to record a protest against the ‘unjust and invidious’ Education Act.Footnote 70 The city solicitor observed that over 14,000 citizens had paid their rates; he might have added that the great majority of Free Church people had not become passive resisters, that the Liberal government's attempts to amend Balfour's act had proved unavailing, and that both the Liberal party and the Free Churches had turned their attention to other issues. The campaign lent credence to accusations of ‘political Nonconformity’ from Conservative and Anglican critics of the movement, while there were those within the Free Church ranks who felt that the ‘Nonconformist conscience’ had been hijacked for militant or party political ends and thereby discredited.Footnote 71 For the resisters, however, refusal to pay the education rate was a moral imperative. Even if ineffective in the short term (and the significance of the education debate in rallying support for the Liberals in 1906 and 1910 should not be under-estimated), passive resistance was a declaration of faith in the ultimate triumph of justice and truth. This confidence inspired some of Oxford's most respectable citizens to persevere over more than a decade in quiet defiance of the law.
