In her detailed book Dancing Communities: Performance, Difference and Connection in the Global City analyzing dance as a laboratory of technique, Judith Hamera leads us to a new understanding of bodily practice and the creation of community. As she proposes, this formation of community through a unique relationship between the use of space and the mastered technique has become one of the marks of new alliances in the global city. Within this innovative understanding of community, dance offers more than simply a “politics of propinquity” (1), reshaping potential intimacy through these “laboratories” in which gender, race, sexuality, class, and urban life are confronted.
In a series of five chapters, Hamera examines techniques in a variety of different spatial environments in and around Los Angeles, including outlying communities such as Pasadena and Long Beach, which is home to many Cambodian immigrants and refugees as well as studios, classrooms, and dance companies. The diverse bodily practices observed include ballet, butoh, Khmer classical dance, Pilates training, and modern–postmodern fusion. In Chapter 1, “Intimacies in Motion,” Hamera asserts that dance amateurs or professionals create their own communities within the global city of Los Angeles through common daily practices. The visibility of shared methods or movements among practitioners and their consumption by others is established as a basis for the creation of dancing communities. Yet it is worth pointing out that technique cannot be separated or produced in complete isolation from its surroundings, including the sociopolitical context of practitioners, imaginations of national identity, and the fluid concepts of ownership of dance practices, framed by the multiculturalism of the global city.
In Chapter 2, “Corporeal Chronotopes: Making Place and Keeping Time in Ballet,” Hamera sees the construction of social landscape as gendered (66), offering a safe space for exposure, competition, and cooperation. Through the example of Erica, a ballerina who is also the daughter of Mexican immigrants, Hamera persuasively explains how the practice of certain dance techniques is able to create a feeling of community through the mutual pursuit of similar concerns. The cohesiveness of this space, built on the practice of ballet, opens new possibilities for the discussion of other personal matters (girls' issues, injuries, etc.) in a nonthreatening environment. However, this particular aspect also shows both the strengths and the fragility of such community construction. Despite, or perhaps because of, Erica's race and class background being unusual in ballet, access to the studio and the technique also enables her to find a space of refuge from her own community and its values and strictures upon her life. Yet in Erica's story, if we explore the notion of longing and desire for a more dominant corporeal engagement, this could be seen as an example of the psychology of attraction to larger, hegemonic structures or narratives of staging the body and class presentation. Although Erica's first encounter with ballet was in the garage of Ms. Baldwin, a Mexican American neighbor from an upper-class background, the moment of leaving for Le Studio was one of realization that to become a “real” ballerina, her technique clearly needed to be practiced in a space seen as authentic, beyond the “domesticated” and familiar surrounds of a neighborhood volunteer. As Hamera states, Le Studio is located in northeast Pasadena, a working-class neighborhood far from the typical setting for a ballet school (62), but its internal layout signifies authenticity: “Rules for corporeal placement in ballet are echoed by maps organizing studio space. Walls and corners are numbered…” (67). For Erica, establishing the proper spatial/geographic construct in practicing and performing ballet provides another text of sacrifice: friendship ties within a neighborhood defined largely by class and ethnicity, and the choice of one (dance) community over another.
Hamera explores Erica's experience in detail, persistently conveying the possibilities of building a ballet studio in a globalized/urban space, drawing members from diverse racial, economic, and class backgrounds as well as sexual orientations. In this context, Erica's narrative becomes a crucial point in Hamera's discussion of agency. Her description of the Le Studio membership, which is mostly uniform in terms of race, gender, and attitude toward sexual orientation, gives us a more realistic idea of the potential for pluralism and diversity within this temporary, technique-based community. We can observe at close range the attempts of children of immigrants to locate their bodily presences, searching within new associations for safer stories while embodied in a fragile citizenship. Acknowledging the great potential of such associations, Hamera reminds us of the tenuous nature of Erica's belonging within the larger, more homogeneous context of ballet, where she is clearly marked by her class and ethnic background (80).
Through introducing different paradigms of technique and their (re-) appearance in everyday life in Chapter 3, “‘Saving’ Khmer Classical Dance in Long Beach,” Hamera raises the question of interrelationships among history, trauma, and truth. Analyzing the differences in understandings of spatial relationships between people and their reflection through body politics when occupying a space, Hamera explores the motivations behind the practice of Khmer classical dance by Cambodian immigrants in Long Beach, and how this is influenced by a sense of national belonging and ideas of ownership of cultural art forms (147). However, Hamera does not extend her analysis in order to explore the intertwining of these concepts with the examination of technique as a tool to create community, especially when it questions the complicated daily spatial occupancy and interaction within immigrant groups. Importantly, Hamera does confess her reluctance to analyze certain types of space (for example, a family household) in relation to discourse on community and the geopolitics of migration in this context. By using an ethnographic approach, she is acknowledging history, trauma, and truth while simultaneously establishing dance technique as a new methodology for the analysis of community construction in global cities. I agree with Hamera's perspective on this, yet I would also question the potential of such discourses to enable us to unfold or read bodily practice as a strategic resistance that is, for example, perhaps carried within one of the Cambodian families she writes about. Here, techniques were not able to create alliances, due to the sociopolitical tensions within the diaspora, inextricably connected to memories of violence and war at home.
Dancing Communities successfully provides a historical and spatial comparison in the reading of technique. Hamera's analyses of bodily practice and its relationship to metaphysical nuances of technique offer revealing narratives of migrant experience in global cities, in contrast to those of exiles or refuge camps. The ability to master technique often provokes the significance of class and race within the frame of new citizenship in a globalized urban space. This implies similarities in the visibility and invisibility of each citizen's longing toward such dance practices and the access they signify, yet the capital value of the spaces they occupy and the making of sustained common understandings of bodily practice—as technique—are different. To uphold this technique as a part of a living, aesthetic form, providing what Hamera terms “dancing communities,” requires continuing support and willingness to break with other matters, such as histories of violence, citizenship, and mapping of class access. This book deserves serious attention from dance and performance scholars. It is likely to influence the formulation of future studies that challenge understandings of the significance of a particular body mastering a technique, and its participation in the creation of new possibilities for living together in a global city.
