An emblematic aerial photograph of the Amathus harbor has been used in many books and papers on Cypriot archaeology in recent decades before appearing on the cover of the final excavation reports, much anticipated by the local and international archaeological community. This photograph was taken during the underwater excavation of the site by a team from the French School at Athens, between the years 1984 and 1986, under the direction of J.-Y. Empereur and C. Verlinden. After more than three decades, Amathus remains the only harbor site ever excavated on the island and one of the few to be investigated in the eastern Mediterranean. The long-expected publication of the final report came out in two volumes. Volume 1, Architecture and History, edited by J.-Y. Empereur and T. Koželj, was published in 2017, and Volume 2, Artefacts Found During Excavation, in 2018. Both volumes appear in the series Études Chypriotes of the French School at Athens, and the publication was funded by the Honor Frost Foundation. Volume 1 is divided into two parts, in which two distinctive features are discussed: the remains of the harbor and the wells along the coast. Volume 2 follows the same structure, with one part for the archaeological material found in each area: Part 1 comprises four chapters about the Hellenistic harbor of Amathus and Part 2 six chapters about the Late Roman wells. The catalog of the 43 coins found during the excavation is included in Volume 1 instead of Volume 2. Although the coins’ separation from the rest of the finds seems unorthodox, it may have been dictated by the fact that they were used extensively in the first volume's discussion of the history and date of the site.
Part 1
The book opens with a short introduction, just two pages (9–10), which is enlightening not only about this section but also about the entire volume's style and objectives: this seems to be a brave and honest effort to disseminate to the archaeological community a full excavation report of a 30-year-old project. To illustrate: “Alabe wrote her study in 1995 and, considering that she arrived at the expected results, she did not wish to rework her text” (9). This straightforward statement about the lengthiest chapter of this section (55 pages), and the one that discusses the main body of dating evidence for the site, aptly prepares the reader for what follows. One can follow the biography of the project itself through old and recent reports which are published together, providing as much information on the excavated material as possible: 139 of 218 numbered pages are filled by catalogs (72 pages), illustrations (52 pages), and tables (15 pages).
F. Alabe's highly informative chapter is written in the form of an elaborate report. It begins with a long and convincing section on the issue of the homogeneity of the pottery. A laborious examination of the material revealed that almost half the sherds found along the south mole could be joined to at least one other sherd, even though some of them were found well apart from each other. The methodology is only explained through examples, however, and the reader has to do the math from reports like the following, about the material from the south mole: “75 joins for 185 objects, of which 36 involved sherds from different bags, and among which 12 joins involved sherds from bags more than 20 numbers apart” (12). With no tables or diagrams to help grasp the nature of the data, we are told that the spatial distribution of the joined sherds, both across the site and down through the strata, was similar in all the areas investigated, which led to the conclusion that the material “is that of a fill that can be considered a single layer” (12). This layer brought to light a rather restricted variety of types, mainly bowls and jugs, the vast majority of which (90%) were made of local fabrics. The author very convincingly bases her argument – that there was a “harbor workshop” on the coast – on the high numbers of local fabrics, as well as on the existence of deformed and misfired pieces among them. Building on the homogeneity of the material, the single stratigraphic unit, and the local production, A. wonders whether the kiln waste found all over the basin and as far from the coast as the south mole was used as a deliberate fill of the harbor or if it was the action of the waves that caused the harbor to silt up.
The rest of the chapter is of great value as far as Cypriot pottery is concerned. Although the compositional identification was done only macroscopically, six variants of Amathusian wares are well described, with text and photographs. The main production of the harbor workshop was a well-known type of open vessel with a flared ring foot; these vessels are known as “Persian bowls” in the literature, but A. suggests the name “Palmiped bowls” after a useful review of other names used in the literature. Dating Amathusian production is no easy task because parallels from Egypt and the Levant are dated from the 7th c. to the end of the 4th c. BCE. The imported pottery does not offer much help with a more precise dating, as it ranges from the 5th to the 3rd c. BCE. Although several vessels are dated to the 4th c., it seems that there is no significant cluster dating to the end of the century. There are many “outliers” and, as A. herself admits, “sandy seabeds and shifting coastlines, as at Amathus, are not ideal environments for a fixed archaeological layer” (22). However, the way that A. chooses to approach the question is perplexing: she considers the harbor's construction at the end of the 4th c./beginning of the 3rd c. to be a fact, and she uses this date as a terminus ante quem for the functioning of the harbor workshop (22), whereas Empereur explained in the introduction (9) that the pottery from the harbor is dated to the same period, so it confirms the construction date he suggests.
The reader interested in quantification will find the provided data to be of little help. The numbers of collected sherds are high (“5,000 or so”) and “just over 1,000” diagnostic sherds are discussed, but it is not clear how the 96 entries of the catalog relate to them. The catalog contains important new information, however. In particular, the series of tablewares of local production, both fine and coarse, can become a standard reference for local and regional pottery studies. The descriptions could benefit from some introductory text, especially of the three “Palmiped bowl” sub-types that comprise the first 40 catalogued vessels and that are among the highlights of the book. They are named after their characteristic features: “slight ribbing”, “ribbing”, and “flared ring-feet”, but the reader has to consult the drawings to comprehend the typological division. Moreover, for every catalog entry, an excavation inventory number is provided that includes the year and bag number but not the findspot or the trench, probably because homogeneity was assumed. As a result, however, it is not possible to know whether a vessel was found at the interior, exterior, or entrance of the harbor. This is especially unfortunate for very interesting finds, such as the cooking pot with decomposed lead in its interior (A32, p. 30). But, if the original bag numbers have not been completely lost, the two tables at the end of the section will be very useful as an easy reference for any scholar who wishes to revisit the pottery discussed in the article (or for storeroom curators, for that matter); the finds are sorted by their catalog numbers (table 1) and their excavation inventory numbers (table 2).
The short chapter by C. Harlaut that follows (only six pages, including references) contextualizes the “Persian” (or “Palmiped”) bowls within the current state of research. H. explains the importance of publishing the harbor workshop and makes a good point that it has escaped the attention of other scholars who have studied and published on this type of shallow bowl with flaring foot, so widespread in the eastern Mediterranean and beyond. Again, one cannot help noticing that the date of Amathusian production at the end of the 4th c. BCE, and not earlier, is taken for granted, although the evidence itself calls for a more tentative approach. The very insightful remark by H. that the Amathusian bowls exported to Egypt have been found at Herakleion–Thonis but not “in the ceramic material in the oldest levels of Alexandria, which are datable to the last quarter of the 4th century B.C.” (70) points toward an earlier date of the material than the one suggested by Alabe.
A total of 12,000 recovered sherds, two-thirds of the total, belonged to transport amphorae. According to Empereur, who authored the fourth chapter of the book, they were mostly body fragments and were macroscopically separated into local (Amathusian) and possibly Aegean wares; oddly, no Levantine imports are reported. Despite the predominance of amphorae in the harbor material, their presentation is uneven by comparison with that of the tableware: only 23 diagnostic pieces, belonging to six amphora types, are discussed in a five-page chapter (including illustrations). The great majority of them (16 out of 23) belonged to a Cypriot transport container with upraised horizontal handles, known in the literature as a “basket-handle” amphora. According to E., they were all of local (Amathusian) fabric, which adds an important piece to the puzzle of their provenance. Although we still lack an overview, different fabrics have been reported from Cypriot sites such as Panayia Ematousa and Pyla-Koutsopetria.Footnote 1 There are at least four or five subtypes dated to the Early Archaic to Hellenistic period, and only two of them could be dated as late as the end of the 4th c. BCE. Even if the illustrated part of a handle is attributed to the Hellenistic subtypes, in the current state of research it is very hard (if not impossible) to date a fragment as precisely as the last quarter of the 4th c. based solely on typology. And, as was the case with the coarse pottery of the previous chapter, the rest of the amphorae, imported or local, cannot all cluster convincingly in the second half of the 4th c. BCE. Be that as it may, a possible combination of tableware and transport containers at the harbor workshop(s) is of particular interest, if one considers that these two types (the Persian/Palmiped bowls and the basket-handle amphorae) have been found together in different contexts, such as the layers dated to the 5th and early 4th c. BCE at Tell-el-Herr in the north Sinai in Egypt,Footnote 2 and the Archaic shipwreck at Kekova Adası in Turkey.Footnote 3
Part 1 ends with a catalog of 110 metallic artifacts, by M. Michael. One golden palmette, 1 lead wreath, 2 weapons, 23 pieces of fishing gear, 3 rings, 26 nails, and 3 cylindrical rods are listed, accompanied by no typological or other discussion. The three concordance tables at the end of the chapter are repetitive but useful for anyone who wishes to revisit the material. It is remarkable that every metallic find is described, regardless of its type or state of preservation. For example, an arrow that has not been cleaned is accompanied by a detailed drawing that depicts the size and sections of its encrustations rather than the object itself. There are 17 amorphous pieces named “metallic masses” (96–99), presented in 17 almost identical entries, describing a “small mass of bronze, of unknown function.” In fact, because of the standardized structure of the entries, the “usage” field was filled with too many repetitive comments, such as “function unknown” or “see above”. This material is, of course, hard to interpret because of its nature, and the lack of context in the unstratified trenches excavated at Amathus did not help. Nonetheless, the characterization of 11 out of 26 nails as “fasteners in ship construction” is problematic (86–91). The author repeatedly explains that “nails used to fasten planking to frames normally had shanks 8–12 cm long” but this is not accurate. Nail sizes vary, of course, not only from ship to ship but also among the different parts of the same ship, but the nails belonging to medium-size merchantmen of this period were certainly longer: the clenched nails found at the Ma'agan Mikhael shipwreck were 17–30 cm long (averaging 25 cm) and those at Tektaş Burnu were 12–22 cm.Footnote 4 Most importantly, it is unclear why nails that are not clenched or bent, and that are found in unstratified layers of a harbor, i.e., not a shipwreck, are characterized as fasteners.
Part 2
Part 2 is a coherent section that concerns the material excavated from three Late Roman wells on the coast, which were discussed in detail in Part 2 of Volume 1. Industrial activities such as pottery production and trade, fishing, water-management activities, and dietary habits all provide valuable material with which to paint a vivid picture of an urban coastal landscape. Another short but informative introduction by Empereur stresses the importance of the pottery, which is local and dated to the Late Roman period, especially the 6th and 7th c. CE. In other words, this excavation has documented a second period of pottery production in Amathus, one previously suggested by E., who discovered remains of kilns on the slopes of the acropolis. In this introduction we also learn about a second lengthy chapter in this book that was written long before this publication. Because of the war in Syria, M. Touma could not revise her study, which “dates back to the 1990s,” but the editor has wisely chosen to include it in this volume.
In more than 50 pages, Touma discusses the 661 best-preserved fragments of the 1,000 recovered in total. Only 50 of them were “non Late Roman” but it is not specified if they were later or earlier, or where they fit into the wells’ stratigraphy. The four tables of “statistics” included in the chapter are illuminating and provide a clear picture of the spatial distribution of the pottery types and fabric groups, as well as quantitative analyses per type and per well. Three main fabric groups are distinguished. Category A seems to be the common local coarse ware, identified in jugs, basins, lids, and water-wheel pots;Footnote 5 Category B comprises mainly cooking pots; and Category C is red ware, which only constitutes 5.9% of the assemblage but includes diagnostic and well-dated forms of fine pottery, lamps, and tiles. The analysis is thorough, clearly presented, and very much to the point. The conclusions are meaningful and reflect a deep knowledge of the Late Roman pottery of Cyprus and the eastern Mediterranean. The bibliography is unavoidably outdated and it is a real pity that all the important work of the last 25 years, especially on cooking pots, could not be incorporated into this study.
Late Roman amphorae are discussed in a separate chapter by Empereur. They are handled as one collection, with no indication of the stratigraphy or their distribution per well. There is a very useful table, however, in which the material is quantified by type. This shows clearly that local amphorae comprise 90% of the total amphora material excavated from these three wells. The types (three variants of LR1 and LR13 amphorae) are well contextualized and their apt descriptions are complemented with insightful remarks on aspects of their manufacturing, which are very helpful for their typological identification. The catalog of imported amphorae, mostly from the Levant, is not accompanied by comments or any other discussion.
The faunal remains from the wells are analyzed by A. Hadjikoumis in a well-written chapter which, by the way, includes the book's only map of Cyprus that depicts Amathus (198). The limitations of the material are clearly explained alongside its potential to provide insights into the dietary habits and the “human–animal” relationships in Late Roman Cyprus. The quantified results of 220 MinAU (Minimum Anatomical Units) confirm the picture painted by earlier assemblages elsewhere on the island, with a predominance of sheep and goat, and the presence of draft animals and dogs. H. argues that the assemblage is indicative of a domestic economy, although he admits that it is not representative of the city, or even of the site itself, since the material was recovered without sifting.
The last chapter of the book is a short contribution by B. Lorenzen and S. Manning on the C-14 analysis of the wood remains recovered from Well 3. The analysis confirms the date of the last use of the well in the 7th c., which agrees with the dates suggested by the pottery. The date range given by the analysis is between 620 and 668 CE. The authors provide an instructive account of how to understand C-14 dates, and they seem to take into account the advice given by Empereur in the introduction of Part 2, namely, that activity at the well cannot be dated after 649 CE, i.e., after the first Arab invasion of the island. But archaeological and textual evidence has demonstrated that life continued on Cyprus during the second half of the 7th c. CE, so there is no reason to consider problematic any use of the wells after 649 CE.Footnote 6
General comments
Harbors are sites of idiosyncratic character, challenging to excavate and interpret – this is the reason why I chose the Greek song quoted in the title of this review. Their constructional and functional attributes are directly related to the natural environment, and their stratigraphy is often disturbed owing to coastal dynamics, while the intensity and nature of their periods of use often vary considerably. It was surely challenging for Empereur to interpret the Amathus harbor material, 34 years after a meticulously recorded excavation. The size of the moles, the systematic, single-phase construction, and the narrowness of the entrance (20 m) are the main arguments discussed in Volume 1 to support the interpretation of the site as a naval base. The assumption that it had a short life was based on the unfinished lifting-bosses on the blocks of the moles, but it was up to the pottery to place the construction phase in its proper chronological context. The turbulent period that followed the death of Alexander the Great between 323 and 294 BCE provided a very tempting and convincing historical context, as indicated by the “chronological table” at the end of Volume 1. Volume 2 was published one year later, but it cannot stand as an independent work; it is in absolute accordance with a hypothesis articulated before it appeared. And this is where I found it to be weakest.
A sentence in the first paragraph of this book's introduction summarizes the discussion of Chapter 3 in Volume 1 (“History of the Hellenistic Harbour”): “the authority behind the construction of this monument was Antigonus Monophthalmus and his son Demetrius Poliorcetes” (9). This rather strong interpretive statement, tempting as it may be, could have been made with a bit more caution, given the fact that the site was only partially excavated and the material was essentially unstratified. In Volume 1, the attribution of the harbor's construction to Demetrius is based on rather thin evidence: six bronze Cypriot coins that were found at its entrance, three of Demetrius Poliorcetes and three with a Macedonian shield and helmet, possibly associated with his father, Antigonus. The remaining 37 coins provide a much wider context for the site, one that leaves the discussion open for other interpretations. In Volume 2, the date of the harbor is not called into question nor even discussed. And while I find the association of the harbor with military operations and the attribution of its construction to Demetrius Poliorcetes an intriguing and interesting hypothesis, I remain unconvinced that most (if not all) the groups of pottery discussed in Part 1 of this book date more or less to the end of the 4th c. BCE. As I have already indicated, very few of the catalogued fragments can actually be placed within this limited horizon with confidence. The typology of the “Persian/Palmiped bowls” is far from established; many of the “Hellenistic” amphorae seem to be Classical; and the imported pottery, both finewares and transport amphorae, as well as the coins, indicate a much broader chronological scope, one that ranges before and after the end of the 4th c. BCE.
But this does not necessarily contradict E.'s interpretive hypothesis or the different scenarios of the harbor's abandonment discussed in Volume 1. Local pottery production could have been active well before the harbor's construction, and it could indeed have been interrupted by it. In either case, it remains uncertain whether pottery waste was dispersed all along the basin, either during or after the abandonment of the harbor, by natural causes or by human intervention. After all, the harbor was built in front of a flourishing city, one that had been exporting its pottery all over the eastern Mediterranean for centuries and one that certainly continued to be active after the harbor ceased serving as a naval base. In this respect, the presence of finds that date to the Classical or Late Hellenistic and Roman periods should not be considered problematic; even if another site nearby was used as the city's port throughout the Hellenistic and Roman periods, some minor activity must have taken place at this harbor as well.
There is little to criticize about the production of this volume. It is very easy to read and any pottery specialist would recognize that the excellent illustrations, line drawings, and color photographs are among the book's greatest strengths. The foldout site plans inside the front and back covers provide the necessary orientation to the site. The only quibble concerning the pottery is a lack of editorial cohesion, which is understandable, however, given that two of the chapters were written long ago. For instance, Touma's use of A. Cailleux's Code des couleurs des sols in her catalog of Late Roman pottery is vexing but could not be changed. Still, a reader can compare those wares neither with the local fabrics described by Alabe, which are not accompanied by color chart references at all, nor with the ones of Empereur, who uses a Munsell color chart. Some errors of English usage should also be noted, e.g., “useful” instead of “diagnostic” sherds, and “isolation” instead of “unique” number.
In conclusion, this is a comprehensive publication that will have a lasting impact. It forms an essential reference for anyone interested in the archaeology of Classical and Hellenistic Cyprus and touches on an array of subjects such as harbor archaeology, the maritime cultural landscape, and pottery studies. Most importantly, it opens the path to further research on this unique material, which may reveal more secrets about a monumental but most enigmatic harbor.
Acknowledgments
The title of this review is the title of a Greek song from 1963, by Giorgos Katsaros and Pythagoras Papastamatiou (original title: Κάθϵ λιμάνι και καημός).
