Much of the scholarship that has been dedicated to the question of the precise nature of meat consumption and distribution in Graeco-Roman antiquity has tended to focus upon the ideological concerns that underpinned such consumption, particularly within the context of Greek thought. Scholars such as Vernant and Burkert have looked at how ancient texts have frequently presented meat consumption not merely as the end result of a religious ritual (that of animal sacrifice), a continuing renewal of the covenant between man and the divine, but as a stratagem both for establishing man's proper place within the framework of existence (making concrete the hierarchical triptych of god-man-animal), and as a means of ensuring group cohesion for communities. What has been ignored largely is the problem of whether the status of meat remained static: in the aftermath of ritual slaughter, did it retain its sacred status, or did it become ‘profane’ at the point that it entered into the commercial and domestic sphere? It is also a matter of debate as to the standing of the meat that was derived from animals that had been killed outside the ritual of sacrifice: beasts killed by hunting or in the arena, or those that perished from natural causes (or, indeed, that were felt to have fallen outside the canon of acceptable animals to be sacrificed, or to been eaten). Those scholars interested in these issues have also tended to focus upon the ideological ambiguities and contradictions, and have ignored the practical aspects of animal butchery and meat distribution in antiquity. In the modern West, abattoirs are often places of marginal status, vital for the processing of meat, yet, at the same time, performing activities that many frequently find unsettling or distressing. The central location of these establishments in ancient urban settlements, yet seemingly staffed overwhelmingly by those of low status, seems to indicate that the Romans too experienced some tension between slaughterhouse form and function in butchery. This collection of papers, the result of a conference held in Paris in December 2007, attempts to address these practical issues, with particular reference to Roman culture. The volume contains eleven articles, all in French, apart from the contribution from Gunnel Ekroth, which is in English.
The majority of the papers concentrate on the archaeological and epigraphical evidence for butchery in the Roman world, looking at sites in Rome and Pompeii, but also in Gaul and Switzerland. This, of course, may provide evidence for practice in the western provinces, but it will be difficult to extrapolate from Gaulish and Italian norms what may have occurred in an Egyptian or Jewish context. However, such a focus does not necessarily diminish the value of this collection. At the heart of the investigations undertaken here is the evidence provided by the excavation of ancient utensils that were probably used for animal dismemberment, as well as by bone deposits (the marks left on such bones, and the location of their discovery, providing valuable clues as to Roman techniques of butchery). The pivotal, but often ambiguous role of the macellum and its development from what appears to be an establishment that initially handled multiple foodstuffs (particularly fowl and fish) into one that dealt almost exclusively in meat products are discussed. Also considered is the evidence furnished by reliefs found on funerary monuments, although these are often open to interpretation, and frequently fail to clarify the status of butchers in Roman society (as these papers often point out, the handling of meat may straddle the sacred and the profane, being the preserve of the priest or the slave, depending upon the context).
The cohesive thematic nature of this volume is slightly disrupted by the inclusion of Ekroth's article, which looks beyond the Roman context to examine the ideology and practice of meat consumption in the Greek world. Although a commendable paper in itself, it sits uneasily within this collection, in that it does not seek to establish links with Roman practice (either as a precursor to it or as a different entity), and its inclusion here feels rather tokenistic. Nonetheless, this collection is a valuable contribution to our knowledge of the status of meat in the Roman world, and perhaps would be of interest not merely to classicists working in this field, but also to food historians who are interested in the technical aspects of ancient butchery and its place within the social and religious framework of Roman society.
