The Ottoman learned class, the ulema, has often been described in the historiography of the modern Middle East as a homogeneous crowd that stood for backwardness and reactionism. This characterization drew on flimsy historical evidence, yet it was rarely questioned. The image of the ulema as a group of zealots standing in the way of progress served the Kemalist cause in the 20th century well, and it was therefore advanced in public and academic discourses in the Turkish Republic. This negative image was ubiquitous in Western historiography as well. The association of the ulema with “tradition” placed them on the wrong side of the modernist binary (modern/traditional, secular/religious, Western/Eastern) that dominated the historiography of the modern Middle East until two or three decades ago. Amit Bein's Ottoman Ulema is an important contribution to the field not only because it sheds light on an understudied yet extremely significant component of late Ottoman and early Turkish society but also because it refutes the simplistic image mentioned previously, offering in its stead a subtle historical analysis.
Ideological disputes and political divisions among the ulema during the late Ottoman and early Republican period form the axis of Bein's discussion. His emphasis on schisms and diversity of opinion among leading ulema allows an analysis that counters the common wisdom about the ulema referred to previously. The brisk and often breathtaking changes of the period, from the Young Turk Revolution and World War I to the collapse of the empire and the rise of Kemalism, had serious implications for the place of the “men of the turban” in the state apparatus and in the wider society. The multiplicity of opinions among the ulema on burning issues such as the role of Islamic institutions in the state, or the nature of the state in general, must lead to the conclusion that there was nothing self-evident or predetermined in the reactions of leading ulema to these changes.
The first chapter provides a critical overview of the historical writing on the ulema and presents the key objective of the study, namely, to discuss “how, despite many shared concerns, the ulema were divided on key issues regarding the future of the state in general and the roles and functions of Islamic institutions in the state in particular” (p. 10). The author does not offer a discussion about the book's methodological choices, yet one gathers from subsequent chapters that the book is a political and intellectual history of the top echelons of the ulema, mainly in Istanbul. The author's tendency to treat the sources (both archival and published) as transparent texts also becomes apparent; the book's methodological choices should have been explained at the outset, given the growing reflexivity and methodological awareness in the field. An explanation of the meaning of key categories used in the book would have been equally helpful. The author treats the category “ulema” as a self-explanatory one, often interchangeable with “the religious establishment.” Bein does state that he focuses on the ulema of the imperial capital, but this statement perpetuates rather than resolves the general fuzziness of this category, which in reality obviously included much more than the portion of the ulema elite studied in the book. Similarly, the author asserts that “the lines of demarcation of the ulema could be quite soft in reality, but in the hegemonic discourse and public imagination they were real enough, for better or worse, to merit common allusions to the ulema as a collective with shared traits” (p. 8). While this was true to the imperial capital, the meaning of “ulema” may have been much more fluid in the provinces, where many office holders in the judiciary and the bureaucracy were of ulema background. These individuals were not necessarily perceived as representatives of the “religious establishment” as such but rather as representatives of “the authorities” par excellence.
In the following chapters, the author discusses the crawling erosion in the public image of the ulema, the mounting threats on their power within the political field of the empire-turning-republic, and the various responses to these challenges in the years that followed. According to the author, the majority of the leading ulema had identified this erosion in the late 19th century and especially under the Young Turks, but opinions on the matter and strategies for containing it varied at any given time and depending on circumstances. In the last decades of the empire, there was a plethora of opinions on reforms of the religious institution and religious practices, translation of religious texts, and the crucial sphere of religious education. The author shows that behind the large-scale split between reform-minded ulema and conservatives, there was a wide spectrum of positions. Just as diverse were the views of ulema in response to the secularizing policies of the Kemalist government of the early republic, ranging from full support to firm resistance. Similarly, there was no consensus on the question of whether or not the ulema should be politically active when such a path became an option after 1908.
The author's treatment of political alignments and actions in the political hub of Istanbul is an achievement of this book. For instance, Bein brings out the political drama that followed the Young Turk Revolution, when rival factions among the ulema were “engaged in a relentless battle over the control of the religious establishment” (p. 36), or when some reformist ulema shifted their loyalties to Kemalism during the early decades of the republic. Studies of this frantic period often fail to capture the contingency of events, describing political and social transformations, such as secularization, as long-term linear processes. Bein's nuanced unfolding of opinions, events, and political maneuvers is an effective demonstration of the unexpected twists and turns that marked the political circumstances. This is illustrated, for instance, in the political career of Mustafa Sabri Efendi, the leader of the conservative camp, who, following the collapse of Unionist rule in 1918, gathered support and was appointed Sheikh ul-Islam. During his term in office, Mustafa Sabri Efendi, an enthusiastic advocate of ulema's political activism, managed to reverse some of the ulema-related policies of the preceding regime, such as the removal of the Shariʿa courts from the jurisdiction of the Sheikh ul-Islam. However, his political bloom was proven short lived, as his antinationalist stance alienated the ulema who had constituted his power base in early 1919. In 1922, a year before the foundation of the republic, he was forced to escape Istanbul, fearing for his life.
In the concluding chapter, the author addresses the persistence of what he defines as “Ottoman legacies” in discussions about the relations between religion and state, a debate that has gained a new level of intensity in the present era of the Justice and Development Party (AKP). Especially controversial is the status of the Diyanet İşleri Başkanlığı (Presidency of Religious Affairs), the state agency that was established in 1924 as a replacement to the Ottoman Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Religious Endowments. Bein offers a sober interpretation of the AKP's intent to allow this body greater autonomy, arguing that it does not suggest any deviation from the preceding tendency to view the religious administration as a “state-friendly disseminator of moderate and enlightened interpretations of Islam” (p. 160).
In recent years, our knowledge of the ulema during the late Ottoman period has expanded considerably thanks to quite a few studies carried out within the fields of social and sociolegal history. Highly relevant to the book under review are recent publications in English and Turkish that address the roles and status of the ulema in the reforming legal system. This revisionist scholarship refutes earlier perceptions of the ulema as an impediment to change and innovation in the legal sphere, suggesting not only that the majority of Ottoman ulema did not oppose far-reaching reforms—including those that ushered in French legal codes—but also that many of them actually participated in the design and application of these reforms. Given the fact that the courts of law and related institutions were perhaps the most important sphere of ulema activity across the Ottoman Empire, the author's disregard of this scholarship is a major weakness of the book. Notice of these studies could have added depth and accuracy to terms such as “the religious establishment,” which consisted of the ulema who served in the provincial judiciary and the central judicial administration, and perhaps compensated for this book's tendency to view the history of the immense body of ulema across the empire through the positions of a prominent yet small number of individuals mainly from Istanbul.
With the caveat mentioned previously, this book is a timely addition to the historiography of the modern Middle East, providing scholars and students of Ottoman and Turkish history with a worthwhile read.
