The port of Valencia, strategically located in the western Mediterranean and close to Muslim territories, was an important center for the slave trade. The Valencian marketplace dealt in slaves from near and far: Granadan and North African Muslims (or Berbers) captured in land raids, sea battles, or corsair expeditions; Mudejars (local Muslims living under Christian rule) sentenced to penal servitude; Circassians, Greeks, and Russians (usually of the Orthodox Christian faith) purchased mainly from Muslim traders in the eastern Mediterranean; and Canary Islanders sold by Portuguese or Italian traders based in ports along the Atlantic coast. This last category was a harbinger of a new, seemingly inexhaustible source of human merchandise; by the late 15th century black Africans came to represent as much as 40 percent of the slave population in Valencia, the result of the commercial reach of Europeans into sub-Saharan Africa during the age of Vasco da Gama and Christopher Columbus. The appearance of more black Africans on the auction block meant that Valencian slavery functioned to a certain extent as a transition between what is often categorized as Mediterranean-style slavery (urban, domestically oriented, ethnically diverse, and only moderately racialized) and the later Atlantic variant (plantation based, racially justified, and more horrific in scale and cruelty). Blumenthal, however, is commendably restrained in situating Valencian slavery within this commonly used but overly neat model. She emphasizes that “racist practices” do not appear to have been implemented in Valencia “in a consistent or comprehensive fashion” (p. 277), thereby implying that Valencian slavery must be understood on its own terms rather than those of the racialized slavery that became characteristic of Spanish colonies in the New World.
In seven chapters, Blumenthal's book analyzes the nature of slavery in 15th-century Valencian society—that is, how slavery was established, legitimated, and understood; the individual's transition to slave status in the original public sale and subsequent private resales; the role of slaves in the Valencian economy and in particular their participation in assorted economic activities from baking bread and sawing wood to domestic service and agricultural labor; the nature of the master–slave relationship, and especially the role of enslaved men and women in disputes over the “honor” or reputation of the slave owner; and, finally, the slave's possibility for liberation, which was heavily dependent on his or her religion, ethnicity, and gender, not least on the “support networks,” as Blumenthal terms them, to which the slave could turn for assistance. The more locally based and long standing the slave community, as with Mudejars and Berbers, the more assistance the slave could call upon from fellow believers or emancipated compatriots; the more distant and recent the slave community, the more isolated and forsaken the enslaved. Naturally, this served to worsen the plight of Canary Islanders and black Africans, far from home and relative newcomers to Iberian captivity.
Blumenthal bases her discussion on extensive archival sources, such as notarial records, municipal registers, and royal documents. Slaves had recourse to a broad array of legal arguments through which to demand their liberty, and they often sought out the assistance of an urban official with the doleful title of “procurator of the miserable” (procurador dels miserables). The latter's obligation to oversee prison conditions was extended to performing as a sort of court-appointed attorney for the poor and indigent of the city, including slaves who lodged complaints against their masters or protested against their enslavement in the first place. The procurator records provide Blumenthal with dramatic material offering details on the everyday life of slaves. Courts sometimes ruled in favor of slaves, as in the case of a young man named Johan, who maintained he was a Hungarian Christian who had been mistaken for a Muslim Turk and illicitly sold into slavery. Based on the testimony of several Germans who asserted that Johan was a native speaker of Hungarian and that of a Valencian physician who affirmed that Johan had never been circumcised, the court verified the slave's natural-born Christian status and ruled him a free man. Although the procurator's efforts led to Johan's liberation in this case, it is clear that most slaves were not so fortunate; the odds were overwhelmingly against them, evidence was hard to come by, and slave owners were generally given the benefit of the doubt. Slave owners could also subvert the procurator's representation and judgment by spiriting the plaintiff out of the city or beating him or her into submission while the court was considering the case.
This raises the vexed question of “slave agency.” As the case of Johan illustrates, slaves could be historical actors, taking initiative and helping to determine their own fate. But only a relative handful of slaves made it to court, and fewer still achieved success. Although Blumenthal acknowledges the slipperiness of arguments about “slave agency” (p. 192), she is perhaps too eager to assert it. She maintains, for example, that when one Johan Ros accused his slave Margalida—who had declared in court that she gave birth to his child—of employing mala lengua and being a slut “accustomed to hav[ing] many lovers . . . for which reason she became pregnant,” the slave owner recast the slave woman's pregnancy and speech as “acts of rebellion” (p. 176, n. 74)—a phrase that does not appear in the sources. Blumenthal's argument seems to stem from the historian's own wish to recast the ill-fated circumstances of Margalida in positive terms. Sex between masters and female slaves was an everyday affair, as Blumenthal makes clear, but to convert the pregnancy and vocal laments of the captive into “acts of rebellion” is an implausible characterization of sexual exploitation and legal chicanery. At the very least, to take Johan Ros’ supposed assertion about “acts of rebellion” as evidence for an argument about “slave agency” is in effect to adopt the slave owner's own self-serving perspective.
Blumenthal provides a vivid portrait of the lives of slaves in Valencia, but because it is based on court records, and because few slaves went to court, the evidentiary basis of her conclusions is shaky. She has tracked down a total of 511 references to slaves in the notarial registers of Valencia, but she evades estimating how large the slave population was in the city, merely making do with a note that suggests that slaves “likely numbered in the thousands” in an estimated total population of 40,000 (pp. 4, 9). Of those 511 references, Blumenthal has identified ninety-three cases (or 18%) in which slaves sought liberation in the courts. She presents a single table of quantifiable data (“Average Sales Prices for Slaves Purchased in Valencia” from 1420 to 1498) but informs the reader in a note that some of the figures are “drawn not [sic] from actual transactions but from estimates offered by corsairs, traders, and Crown officials of what price that particular captive would sell for” (p. 56). This caveat renders the tabulated data virtually worthless. At the same time, the table shows that the price of slaves declined in the nearly eight decades covered by the sales prices, but Blumenthal does not explain this phenomenon. Perhaps the influx of African slaves was so large that prices were deflated?
Blumenthal's Enemies and Familiars is a valuable and imaginative contribution to the study of Mediterranean slavery. It is filled with poignant, revealing stories that touch on all aspects of the life of slaves in Valencia. The book is well written though perhaps too redolent of a reworked dissertation, with an earnest concern for taking the reader by the hand and conducting him or her through the impending argument. One such excursus entails use of the personal pronoun no less than eight times on one page (p. 47). As any reader of her book will discover, however, Blumenthal is too sophisticated and accomplished a scholar to require such juvenile crutches.
