Lennart Schön's book chronicles the past two hundred years in Sweden's economic history, covering the transition from an agrarian society over the industrial economy up until today's post-industrial era. It is difficult to imagine anyone more competent to write this book than Schön, a central character in Swedish economic history research over the past four decades. Among his most important contributions is that he, with collaborators, has pioneered the work on Swedish historical national accounts. It is fair to say that most of what is known about the country's historical growth and development trajectories emanates from that project.
The book's structure is chronological, offering a systematic description of main institutional changes as well as in-depth treatments of, e.g., specific sectors, population sub-groups, and various technological advances. Schön's introductory chapter outlines a model of structural transformation that frames the entire book. This conceptual framework ideas come from the Swedish economist Erik Dahmén as well as Joseph Schumpeter and Nikolai Kondratiev. Briefly, Schön proposes that new key innovations generate not only increased productivity within their own sector but also spurs activity in other sectors that are complementary to the original innovation. Taken together these activities create a so-called “development block” where sectoral complementarities in an expansionary phase give rise to scale economies and higher growth. Eventually, however, diminishing returns and political-economic forces resisting continuing development give rise to stagnation and ultimately a structural crisis, which is resolved only by a new set of innovations followed by a new development block. Schön stipulates, referring mainly to historical evidence that the expansionary and stagnant phases take about 20–25 years each and thus implies that the economy runs into a structural crisis every 40–50 years.
After this introduction, Schön presents a rich exposé of the historical developments arranged into five historical phases, In the first phase, agriculture and early industrialization 1790–1850, commercialization of agriculture and waterborne infrastructure created a development block which eventually spurred private consumption growth and a of rise of liberal values. Although Schön observes a slow-down of investment activity that could indicate a structural crisis, the second phase, railway construction and expanded industrialization 1850–1890, rather came due to the entry of numerous foreign industrial innovations. These set off a hectic transformation process and an archetypical “upstream industrialization.” The phase ended with increased global competition pressing down prices and the international crisis following the crash of the Baring's Bank.
The third phase in Sweden's economic history is called the breakthrough of industrial society 1890–1930. Schön depicts how the second industrial revolution penetrates the Swedish economy, with development blocks surrounding the major innovations in the area of motors and power engineering. We learn how these industries spread throughout the country, how they affected the working population through rising real wages, the rise of modern urban structures, and financial sophistication. The role of World War I boom and subsequent crisis, which other Swedish historians have described as an important structural shock, is downplayed by Schön as being temporary blips with no lasting importance. The phase ends with the international debt and structural crisis that hit the entire western world.
A fourth phase called the peak of industrial society 1930–1975 begins with Sweden fairly quickly escaping the Great Depression. Many historians ascribe this to the expansionary fiscal policy inspired by Keynes but designed by the Stockholm School economists led by Erik Lindahl, Gunnar Myrdal, and Bertil Ohlin. Schön, however, argues that the recovery instead was due to the rise of the domestic car industry and the electrification of the country side. Sweden managed to stay out of World War II and experienced historically high postwar growth rates, but nonetheless ran into stagnation in the 1970s. Once again, Schön takes issue with the majority of Swedish economists and historians who argue that political failures, malfunctioning labor markets, and excessive regulation were main determinants of the crisis of the 1970s. Schön relies instead on his model, arguing that the downturn was due to stagnation of industrial production.
In the fifth phase, Third Industrial Revolution and the service economy, which begins in 1975 and ends about today, the upturn of the Swedish industry came with the development blocks surrounding innovations in electronics and, of course, information and communication technology. Sweden experienced a profound economic and financial crisis in the early 1990s, which had lasting effect on society. According to Schön this crisis marks the end of the expansionary phase of the development block and the beginning of a stagnant phase. The book is not excessively detailed about the recent years, but it is interesting to note that the current economic problems plaguing both Sweden and many other Western economies comes about 45 years after the structural crisis of the 1970s, just in accordance with Schön's cyclical model.
There are not many things in this solid and well-written book with which to take issue. Schön masters the topics covered, presents an amazing mass of facts and references to historical data and previous research, which results in a highly sensible and informed treatment of the main themes in Sweden's modern economic history.
Having said this, there are a few things that at least I would have liked to see in the book. First, I miss a close and active attachment to the international research that exists on virtually every single topic the book covers. Just to take one example: when assessing the Swedish recovery from the 1930s crisis Schön does not make a single reference to what research on other countries’ recovery processes from the Great Depression has to say about the relative importance of economic policy or industrial transformation.
Another remark, perhaps all too expected, concerns Schön's emphasis on long-term transformation cycles in the economy. This highly mechanical view of the forces governing society has a lot of merit; it helps us perceive and understand patterns and to distinguish transitory noise from permanent shifts. Admittedly, the timing of Schön's cycles and crisis are also remarkably tight with respect to the actual course of events. However, his reliance on this model tends to become a straightjacket when it comes to understanding complex phenomena such as the role of changing political and economic institutions, but perhaps even more importantly the fact that Sweden as a small, open economy imports virtually all of its cyclical behavior from abroad. Schön does indeed discuss these issues, but as his model is not formulated as a null hypothesis that can be rejected the reader is left with a feeling that there is still something missing here.
An Economic History of Modern Sweden is an impressive achievement in providing both a comprehensive set of statistical evidence and insightful analyses of the evolution of the Swedish economy over the past two hundred years. It will be standard reading among everyone interested in how a small, open, late-industrializing economy coped with institutional and technological changes and arrived at one of the most egalitarian welfare states in the world.
