In this book Mansoor Moaddel sets out to explain the emergence of Islamic modernist, nationalist, and Islamic fundamentalist discourses in modern Middle Eastern and South Asian history. What factors, Moadell asks, prompted historical actors to formulate these particular discourses? Why have these discourses varied from country to country? Why did Islamic fundamentalism eventually trump other ideologies as the dominant oppositional discourse in the modern Muslim world? In search of answers to these questions, Moaddel develops a sociological model that aims to correlate the relationship of ideas with the social transformations that occurred in Muslim lands in modern times. The task is ambitious and requires that the author paint a large canvas. Chronologically, the book covers the period stretching from the decline of the Muslim empires in the 18th century to the rise of Islamic fundamentalism during the second half of the 20th century. In terms of geographic scope, Moaddel draws upon examples of ideological production from northern India, Syria, Egypt, Algeria, Jordan, and Iran.
Moaddel's explanatory model centers on the heuristic concept of “episode,” which he defines as a period of ideological continuity that is formed within the sociopolitical context of the modern state. According to Moaddel, episodes are marked off from one another by decisive events such as military coups and political, social, and economic upheavals. However, despite the pattern of ideological discontinuity, each episode relates to what came before it insofar as it is shaped by the prevailing conceptual framework. Opposition groups and dissident intellectuals “target” the discourse of the existing social or political order and in the process absorb many of its structural features. Moaddel's model unfolds in the fashion of the Hegelian dialectic, except that rather than reflect a synthesis of ideas, the discourse of each new episode takes pains to distinguish itself discursively from its predecessor.
Within this framework, Moaddel lays out four possibilities. Each depends, first, on whether the prevailing field of meaning is pluralistic or totalistic and, second, whether the target is civil society or the state. Thus, according to Moaddel, Islamic modernism, which emerged in India, Egypt, and Iran in the 19th century, targeted and was shaped by the discursive plurality of traditional Islamic civil society. Likewise, the relative openness of early 20th-century liberal nationalism reflected the pluralism of weak, foreign-dominated monarchies and state elites, as in Egypt, Syria, and Iran.
In contrast, totalistic discourses within civil society tend to be targeted by the monolithic discourses of sectarian groups, for example, the oppositional Babi movement in 19th-century Iran, which challenged the Shiʿi religious establishment, whereas totalistic ideologies characteristic of bureaucratic–authoritarian states generated their mirror image in the monistic discourse of radical fundamentalism. According to Moaddel, the logic of the latter possibility is contained in the challenge to Egypt's republican regime by Sayyid Qutb and his disciples, and in the authoritarian discourse of Algeria's FIS (Islamic Salvation Front), which constituted an uncompromising, Islamicized version of the secular nationalism of the FLN (National Liberation Front). In both cases, fundamentalist challengers attempted to turn the practice and ideology of state sovereignty on its head. Moaddel is mindful of the existence of variations to his model. He points to the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, where a relatively diverse state ideology did not provide the necessary conditions for the rise of extreme fundamentalism, and to the Islamic Republic of Iran where the balance of power among spiritual leader, president, and parliament has mollified totalitarianism and prompted the emergence of a pluralistic oppositional trend represented, most notably, by Abdol Karim Sorush.
In formulating his approach, Moaddel questions the theories of Marx, Weber, and Durkheim, each of whom posited, in different ways, a correspondence between ideology and social structure. Such theories, according to Moaddel, are overly reductionist. The Marxist theory of class, for example, cannot explain why fundamentalism in Egypt was spearheaded by the modernizing middle class and in Iran by the ʿulamaء and bazaaris. However, he also rejects the postmodern approach of Foucault and Edward Said. Although he agrees with Said that religious and cultural texts are poor indicators of Muslim social behavior, he does not believe as Said that discourse is shaped primarily by power. Rather, Moaddel draws inspiration from the works of Robert Wuthnow and Randall Collins in his contention that ideologies are produced within specific historical environments. This approach frees him to consider the myriad resources, intellectual influences, economic structures, and sociopolitical encounters that provide each of his episodes with historical specificity. It is an approach that might be fruitfully adopted to investigate other ideological shifts in the region. One wonders how it might be applied, for example, to understanding the emergence of the Islamic fundamentalist globalism recently investigated by Olivier Roy.
Moaddel is explicit about his methodology, but the bulk of his book consists of case studies, which are fleshed out in detail. He references the important secondary works in the field, as well as many primary sources. Teachers and advanced students of Middle East history will appreciate and benefit from the care with which he has assembled his narrative of change and revolution in the heartlands of the Islamic world. In these middle chapters of the book Moaddel provides historical legitimacy to his central claim that “the greater the state's intervention in culture, the higher the likelihood of the rise of political ideologies; and the lower the state's intervention in culture, the higher the likelihood of the rise of social ideologies” (p. 17). Mansoor Moaddel has produced a work of comparative historical sociology that supplies a cogent paradigm for the evolution of modern Muslim ideologies.
