This is an edited collection of sixteen chapters written by some of the leading commentators in the field of international investment law. The book evaluates the protection accorded to foreign investors in key regions of the world such as the European Union (chapters 6 and 13), NAFTA (chapters 5 and 14), ASEAN (chapter 8), and Latin America (chapter 7). In addition to the focus on these key regions, the book also discusses certain facets of treaty-based protection for foreign investment in individual countries such as China (chapter 9) and Australia (chapters 12 and 15).
Apart from these region- and country-specific chapters, the book also contains non-region-specific chapters on international investment law ranging from examining the nature of foreign investment (chapter 1) and the history of foreign investment (chapter 2) to exploring the role of the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) in settling disputes between foreign investors and host states (chapter 10). Although excellent and insightful readings in their own right, chapter 3 by Picker—a legal cultural analysis of international investment law—and chapter 16, by Sornarajah—questioning the foundations of international investment law—do not appear to be well connected to the debate on regionalism in international investment law.
The individual chapters of the book are excellent examples of cutting-edge scholarship in the area of international investment law. The book is of immense value to anyone who would like to gain insights about key developments in investment treaty practice and investment protection in different regions of the world, and in individual countries such as China and Australia. Some individual chapters, such as that by Picker, provide an exceptional theoretical analysis.
However, the book as a whole lacks a common and coherent perspective that unites its heterogeneous chapters. In an edited collection, readers generally expect an introductory chapter that explains the consistent theme or research question that the book aims to explore. The current book would have benefitted immensely from having a detailed introductory chapter that explained the debate on regionalism in international investment law. This explanation could have included different perspectives on this debate, such as whether regionalism challenges the existing investment treaty regime by adding more complexity or whether regionalism represents an opportunity to bring about some degree of uniformity in an otherwise scattered regime.Footnote 4
The structure of the book would have benefitted if the chapters were divided into three parts: regional case-studies, country case-studies, and non-region-/country-specific chapters. The regional case-studies are valuable, although Africa, a very important region, is missing. There are also significant gaps in terms of assessment of international law for the protection of foreign investment in individual countries: India, Russia, and South Africa do not figure. A final critique of the book is the absence of a concluding chapter summarizing the key findings and arguments of individual chapters and thus presenting a unifying theme to the readers. Instead, the book concludes with an appendix, containing a debate between Sornarajah and Trakman on the liberalization of foreign investment, which though very fascinating, is not directly related to the topic of regionalism in international investment law.
In short, this book is a useful contribution to the growing literature on international investment law but it would have benefitted from having a consistent and coherent theme.
