Andrew McClellan offers a much needed examination of how the treatment of corpses varies across imperial Latin epic. As M. rightly points out, amid the abundant studies of corporeal violence in Roman epic, less attention has been paid to the mistreatment of bodies once they are dead — corpse abuse. As a natural extension, M. also analyses distorted funerary practice in imperial epic. M.'s skilful engagement with the complex web of intertexts at play in such poetry is impressive. He consistently incorporates Homer and Vergil while also making use of Ovidian intertexts. His argument also focuses throughout on the contemporary socio-political realities related to corpse abuse and distorted funerary practice.
In ch. 1, M. assesses a certain sense of decorum regarding the mistreatment of corpses in Homer's Iliad, observing that violence done to corpses, while often threatened in the Iliad, is rarely realised. Vergil's Aeneid responds to Homer by eliding the violence done to the corpses of Mezentius and Priam, whose abused corpses are only visible after the abuse. Vergil goes beyond Homer's threats by narrating the violence, while still exhibiting an allegiance to Homeric ‘decorum’ (65) by avoiding the staging of corpse abuse.
M. uses ch. 2 to offer sample scenes of corpse abuse (decapitation specifically) which frame the poetics of Lucan, Statius and Silius, each of whom later receives a full chapter to himself. M. points out that the death scene of Lucan's Pompey is extended and repeated through fragmented narrative and syntax, while Pompey's intertextual nod to Vergil's Priam features corpse abuse in a manner elided by Vergil. As elsewhere, M. offers an innovative perspective on an often-noted aspect of Lucan's text, namely Lucan's inversion of Vergilian models. Analysis then focuses on how Statius extends Tydeus’ death and mutilation of Melanippus’ corpse, spreading the nefas from this scene throughout the Thebaid. At the same time, Silius’ handling of the decapitations of Asbyte and Theron (Punica 2) bring the staging of Vergilian silence around corpse abuse to a ‘gruesome’ conclusion’ (97) through abundant modelling on both Vergilian and Homeric characters.
Lucan's Bellum civile and its ‘distorted death rites’ (115) are the focus of ch. 3. M. presents Pompey's funeral as a distortion of traditional Roman rites (especially the half-burnt nature of his corpse). What is more, Pompey's death and accompanying ‘rites’ are intratextually repeated, allowing him to haunt the text until the poem's final line. Caesar's lack of concern for funerary rites throughout the poem (especially during his crossing of the Adriatic, after the Battle of Pharsalus, at Troy and at Alexander's tomb) remind the reader of the historical realities of Caesarism. M.'s analysis of Erictho focuses on the corpse-soldier and on aspects of this scene which distort actual funerary practice. The corpse itself, revivified, is intertextually and intratextually linked to Lucan's Pompey, presenting both as macabre symbols which reinforce the endlessness of civil war.
Ch. 4 focuses on Valerius’ Argonautica, arguing that it avoids Lucan's emphatic presentation of goriness while still featuring critical instances of corpse abuse. However, even in Valerius’ gruesome account of Amycus, the staging of corpse mistreatment is largely avoided, thus obeying Vergilian aesthetics in a way which Lucan shunned. Ultimately, this characteristic of Valerius’ work represents an attempt to shade his audience from the lived abuses of civil war.
The focal point of ch. 5 is Statius’ Thebaid. M. analyses interment of bodies by bodies (such as Polynices covered by Eteocles) or other warped burials (such as Amphiaraus’ katabasis) in the Thebaid. Analysis of such burials, coupled with insightful readings of Hypsipyle's staging of a mock funeral for her father and of Polynices’ and Eteocles’ funerary rites, contribute to the limitless enmity of Statius’ text. M. uses funerary practice to engage with the question of political dissent in the Thebaid, noting that the poet provides a type of laudatio funebris for Maeon in book 3. Statius’ version of Lucan (Silvae 2.7), read in tandem with Maeon, exhibits a type of Statian dissent ‘refracted through other more pronounced dissent’ (240).
Silius’ Punica and Hannibal specifically are treated in ch. 6. M. points out that Hannibal's attention to proper burial for Romans, in particular Paulus, is only done for the ensuing fame. M. also provides analysis of book 17 — both Hannibal's flight and his imago paraded through Rome — reading the latter as a type of funeral. Hannibal's wounding of the Republic (described corporeally at various points in the Punica) reveals the roadmap for future Caesars in Roman history. By bringing the burning of the Capitol into the discussion, M. notes that only Romans, not Hannibal, ever succeed in destroying the Republic.
This book provides a much needed analysis of a neglected aspect of imperial epic. Indeed, the individual studies of these authors (Lucan, Valerius, Statius and Silius) provide fresh perspectives on their poetics. This book enlivens these violent poems, often noted for their corpses, and revivifies imperial Latin epic.
