This is the latest volume in the Routledge ‘Advances in South Asian Studies’. If rather heavy handed in style and argument the author has in fact written a devastating critique of current economic planning in India. In many ways we need a description with such authoritative analysis to validate what might otherwise seem the strident opposition of Arundhati Roy to Indian capitalism today. It provides a very disturbing insight into the cost of globalisation. So many of the brave development projects launched by Nehru, with a particular faith in dams as promising a way to the most rapid advance in irrigation and electricity, now have the characteristics of a serious tragedy for the tribal communities of the sub-continent. The author's theme is of capitalist accumulation by dispossession. How are the tribal communities to resist this subversion of their traditional way of life? In large parts of eastern and central India their plight has been taken up by a Maoist movement ready to resort to violence to counter this development thus presenting the current government with a massive challenge to law and order. The protest against the dams of the Narmada river were inspired, however, by non-violent Gandhian values and anyone concerned for the future of Indian democracy should look hard and long at the outcome of this struggle.
The beginnings of the Sardar Sarovar project as we are told the largest multi-purpose river valley development to date in India with some 3,000 dams, goes back to 5 April 1961 when Nehru laid the foundation stone of the main dam which became a 1,200 metre long ‘concrete mastodon’, 138 metres high, with 75,000 kilometres of canals. In fact it took till 1979 for the three states along the river, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra and Gujarat to sort out their differences and for the scheme to go ahead. In crude terms, following Nilsen's account, the main beneficiaries of the dam are the agro-industrial elites, above all the rich peasant castes, of Central and South Gujarat, with the prospect of its irrigating the dry areas of Kutch and Saurashtra. The victims are the villagers living on the mountain sides overlooking the river, with 193 villages at risk in Madhya Pradesh, 33 in Maharashtra, 19 in Gujarat. Likewise affected are all those communities, fishermen, shopkeepers, artisans, dependent on the dam-affected villages. Not all are tribal; the petty commodity farmers of the Nirmad district of Madhya Pradesh are caste-Hindu. I think the sense of outrage at this devastating project lies as much in cultural factors as in economic: why, the protesters wonder, are people not even more shocked than they were by the vandalism of the Babri Masjid mosque in 1992 at the prospect of so many actively-used temples and an entire sacred landscape being engulfed? As with Tibet here is an endangered culture.
The story of resistance brings the subalternist history project into the present-day. It was above all, as Nilsen shows, a story of oppressed communities overcoming “everyday tyranny” and ceasing to fear. It was as a hangover from colonial forestry laws that tribal communities, who had wrenched, admittedly illegally, a subsistence living for themselves from the forests, and as a result were subjected to endless harassment from forest rangers, police officers and revenue officials. It took the intervention of urban intellectuals and activists to make them realise that within a democratic India they did not lack citizens’ rights. A breakthrough came with the setting up of the Peasants and Workers Consciousness Union in 1982, centred on Alirajpur in Madhya Pradesh. Much of the credit for bringing the union and like protest movements in the valley into the Narmad Bachao Andolan (Save the Narmada Movement) must go to Medha Patkar. And there were striking successes. Following protest within Congress in America and the adverse report of its Morse Commission, the World Bank in 1993 withdrew funding. Non-violent protest inspired by the Andolan took extraordinary forms, none more dramatic than the Monsoon satyagrahas when protesters exposed themselves to the rising waters of the river, ‘jal samparan, sacrifice in water’. Yet just at the moment of triumph, but always implicit in any Gandhian satyagraha, the Andolan —and it had always struggled for this outcome through its counter-expertise on the costs and limitations of the whole project—accepted a review process by the Supreme Court, reopening a dialogues with the State and thus putting its faith in ‘jury politics’. But at this juncture many of the rank and file of the Andolan sensed they had lost and made what they could of the wholly inadequate R and R (resettlement and rehabilitation) on offer; the Gujarat protest group, ARHC Vahini, had anyway always favoured this approach. As the author comments: “the tragedy of tribals shifting to city slums after having lost their land is of course the story of the proletarianisation in contemporary India in a nutshell”. (p 104)
In the climate of neo-liberal restructuring heralded by Narasimha Rao's Congress government in 1993 the Andolan protest was doomed. On 18 October 2000 the Supreme Court legislated that the scheme should be completed: “it becomes necessary to harvest the river for the larger good”. (p. 141)
But not all was lost. In a separate, though connected struggle against the Maheshwar Hydroelectric scheme in Madhya Pradesh, 11 January 1998, 25,000 villagers stormed the dam site and six activists embarked on a fast unto death. It worked. Transnational corporations behind the scheme, that is to say global capital, halted the project in 2001. On 28 September 1989 there had been a mass rally against Destructive Development at Harsud in Madhya Pradesh. Another significant landmark was a monsoon satyagraha in Domkhed, Maharashtra and also villages in Madhya Pradesh on 15 August 2000. The case was made for an entirely different mode of development, one that preserved the tribal culture and favoured small-scale Gandhian technology. Here was a programme based on participatory democracy, environmental sustainability, social justice. The role of women was crucial, though the author favours an economic explanation over a feminist argument — women had the most to lose in terms of employment as their's was a special bonding with the earth. This local campaign connected with an all India one, the NAPM, the National Alliance of Peoples Movements, set up in 1996. It went on a two month yatra (march) from Kerala to Ayodha. Here was significant protest against the whole post-colonial model of development.
It is not entirely clear what overall conclusions the author draws in terms of the strategy of resistance. He turns hyper-rhetorical at the end. But he seems to favour a flexible relationship with the state. However embattled the protest, there should be a readiness to take advantage of what the state might yet offer. One wonders if the Maoists share this attitude.
I have one request to make of the editor of the series. Please set aside a page decoding acronyms. Sometimes these can be discovered from the index, otherwise one has to trawl back through the text to find their first use and this can be frustrating.
