Writing a textbook on the economic history of a particular country involves treading a fine line between what will be analytically respectable to students who know some economics (and to oneself as an economist) and what will be comprehensible to the probably much larger number of potential readers interested in the country's history in general—having many years ago attempted a textbook with the same title (and the same publisher) as this one, I speak from experience. I tried to solve the problem by avoiding a chronological structure and using what I thought might be quite accessible issues and theories from development studies as the basis for the book's structure; David Flath's excellent topic-based textbook on the contemporary economy, on the other hand, achieves its rigor and clarity by assuming an economic readership from the start and abandoning the uninitiated altogether. Carl Mosk's solution here is to work with a conventional chronological structure, but to introduce at the beginning a selection of economic theories and models, presented as useful in analysis of the Japanese case, for the non-economic reader to learn. Especially given that Mosk is by no means the clearest of writers, it is easy to question whether it really is necessary for nonspecialist readers to wrestle with his accounts of IS/LM curves and the Swann-Solow growth model in order to learn something useful about Japanese economic history, and the author himself seems to have some doubts, when he suggests that generalist students might in fact skip these sections. However, for all its faults (see below), the key merit of this book, compared with others that attempt to tell the same story, is that it never loses sight of the fact that Japan's economy, like all others, can only be understood properly by means of the tools of economic analysis.
Part 2 of the book proceeds to put this into practice through a chronological account of Japan's prewar economic history from the Tokugawa period onwards. This reveals the author's bias towards particular fields—especially demography—and elsewhere is not always based on the most topical or relevant material: the role of the rural sector in Japanese industrialization, for example, is still being explained in terms of the Fei-Ranis surplus labor model, with no mention of more recent—and much more exciting—approaches, such as Hayami Akira's “industrious revolution” or Sugihara Kaoru's “labor-intensive path of development.” Long sections of potted political and international history tend to distract from interesting and unusual economic presentations of, for example, electrification or the interwar expansion of cities. The no-doubt commendable aim of presenting alternative interpretations of Japanese phenomena is somewhat undermined by the fact that these interpretations tend to be old hat, and even if students are inspired to try to form their own judgments, with only sporadic sourcing and no help with further reading, it is difficult to see how they are to do this.
However, by part 3, when the book reaches the postwar period, IS/LM curves have largely been forgotten and readers are presented with a straightforward, in-depth and well-informed analysis of the economic miracle and its aftermath. There is still perhaps some imbalance—a great deal on demographic ageing, for example, but neglect, perhaps because of the admirable down-playing of the role of exports in Japanese growth, of some of the other international dimensions of the economy, such as overseas investment. Nonetheless, in general, the up-to-date and comprehensive coverage of the topics the author clearly finds most interesting compensates for this. There has long been a need for a serious chronological account of the postwar Japanese economy, informed by both economic theory and knowledge of Japan but still accessible to a reasonably wide readership, and the second half of this book goes a long way towards meeting this need.
This being so, it is a real pity that more thought was not put into the structure, organization, and presentation of the book as a whole. At times, it reads like a collection of assorted pieces (written-up lecture notes?) dealing with whatever the author happened to be interested in at that moment. The chapter on the bubble economy of the later 1980s, for example, includes not obviously relevant discussion of van Wolferen's “Japanese System” and the important Aoki-Koike J-firm model, as well as boxes on the career of Tanaka Kakuei (prime minister in the early 1970s) and European speculative bubbles of the long distant past, but just a quick run through the causes of the rise in asset prices and nothing at all on why the bubble burst, so that the reader is thrust into the next chapter on the stagnation of the 1990s with no idea of how the economy got there. Students using the book can learn much about the ways in which serious economic analysis can illuminate Japan's past, but they will need help in building up a macro-narrative, filling in the gaps, utilizing the statistical tables in the appendix, and reading further. In addition, the editing and proofreading are so poor that numerous sentences have to be read over and over again before it becomes clear which missing word or punctuation mark is needed to make them intelligible. Those recommending this book—as they should, given its undoubted merits in comparison with its competition—will need to issue their students with the strictest warning that they should copy Mosk's exemplary application of economic thinking to Japan, but not his literary technique.
