Forty years after his death and the end of the Cultural Revolution, Mao Zedong and his final most extensive mass campaign continue to fascinate China-watchers as well as many Chinese. As Professor Dikӧtter reminds readers, when, in 1981, the then leaders of the Chinese Communist Party issued their Resolution on the party's history much of which dealt with the Cultural Revolution, they hoped to discourage discussion of such sensitive topics, at least within China. Nevertheless, since then numerous memoirs by Chinese of their experiences during the campaign have been published in mainland China, in Hong Kong and in the West, while some substantial studies of the period by western scholars have appeared.
Professor Dikӧtter's is the latest of these. It complements the major work on the Cultural Revolution by Roderick MacFarquhar and Michael Schoenhals published in 2006Footnote 1 by using information that has become available since then. Dikӧtter observes that the experiences of ordinary people have often been missing from earlier studies of the Maoist era and says that his book “brings together the broad historical sweep with the stories of men and women at the centre of this human drama”. Remarkably, he was able to gain access to the official archives of several Chinese provinces and municipalities for this work, as he did for his earlier studies of the first years of communist rule and of the famine years from 1958.Footnote 2 These archives, together with the recently published memoirs by Chinese, are the main source for his accounts of ordinary people's experiences. He also draws on reports by British diplomats who were in Beijing and Shanghai during the Cultural Revolution, which are now in the UK National Archives and on information in the Hong Kong Public Record Office.
From all these sources, Dikӧtter has produced an account of the campaign which covers the experiences of the general population as well as the manoeuvring and infighting among leaders. The violence of the campaign, including persecution and torture of perceived opponents of Mao, even extending to cannibalism in some places, is well known. Reliable figures for the number of killings are unavailable, but Dikӧtter estimates the total to be between 1½ and 2 millions.
While adding data on the campaign's impact in provinces, towns and villages, Dikӧtter's account in other respects agrees on most points with the best previous studies of the Cultural Revolution. His analysis leads to the conclusion that the army, after it was ordered to restore order in 1967, used brutal methods involving many killings of Red Guards and worker rebels. There were probably also many casualties among the soldiers, as the American journalist Edgar Snow was told when he visited Beijing in 1970. The book includes a useful summary of the Sino-Soviet border clashes in 1969, concurring with those experts, including Chinese ones, who say that the Chinese were responsible for instigating the incidents and indicate that the first of them was planned by Mao.Footnote 3
As the extensive bibliography demonstrates, a huge amount has been published about the Cultural Revolution. Professor Dikӧtter's book is a major addition to this body of work. Because the campaign was so wide-ranging, even more information on it will doubtless appear in future. There are still a few strands within the campaign which offer scope for further research, for example the controversy over educational reform from 1971 and the debates over Marxist theory which surfaced in the Shanghai journal Studies and Criticism in 1973.
