Conflicted Antiquities presents an exhaustively researched and sharply written account of how Egyptian Pharaonic monuments, the sites and buildings that house them, and the personnel who have worked to uncover and care for them have acquired and changed meaning over the course of the 19th and 20th centuries. In a style similar to that of Marilyn Booth, Elliott Colla weaves historical research, literary analysis, and theory to paint a portrait of “modernizing Egypt,” against which he places Egyptian artifacts, the growing science of Egyptology, and an increasingly widening circle of enthusiasts for the Egyptian past, or “Egyptomania.” Unlike other accounts of contemporary Egyptology and its practitioners, such as Don Reid's Whose Pharaohs? (which is about European and Egyptian Egyptologists) or Stephanie Moser's Wondrous Curiosities: Ancient Egypt at the British Museum (which concerns itself with British Egyptologists and the British National Museum), Colla focuses wholly on Egyptian readings of the ancient past. The result of his investigations into medieval and modern Arabic literature, European travel accounts, the history of archeology, and historical accounts of modern museum science is an engaging and articulate account of the ever-changing face of “Egyptian ancient” and of how the ancient continues to shape and define “Egyptian modern.” Conflicted Antiquities is also an insightful portrayal of how “modernity” (or, to be more precise, various versions of it) has been mobilized by Egyptian elites to shape various nationalist ideologies and to construct platforms through which to control the Egyptian rural population. The book is a nice complement to recently published works on contemporary Egypt such as Omnia El Shakry's The Great Social Laboratory: Subjects of Knowledge in Colonial and Postcolonial Egypt (2007), and Michael Gasper's The Power of Representation: Publics, Peasants and Islam in Contemporary Egypt (2008), both of which examine the fields of knowledge associated with the peasantry and with ancient Egypt and their application to modern modes of governance.
Colla presents Conflicted Antiquities in five chapters, each of which ends with his reading of a piece of literature or iconography associated with the ancients. Chapter 1, “The Artifaction of the Memnon Head,” concerns itself with what Colla calls the biography of objects, or the processes by which antiquities were taken from Egypt, received at their destinations, and transformed from objects into artifacts. An artifact, he argues, is best defined “not in terms of its intrinsic qualities, but rather by way of the tensions and contradictions which permeate and link it to intense political, social and cultural conflicts” (p. 60). The removal of Memnon's bust from Upper Egypt and its ensconcing in the British National Museum in 1832, the focus of this chapter, sets up Colla's arguments about the parallel processes of increased curiosity about the Egyptian past and the rising encroachment of a colonial rule informed, in no small measure, by archeological discoveries, the practices surrounding them, and the meanings attributed to them.
Chapter 2, “Conflicted Antiquities: Islam's Pharaoh and the Emergent Egyptology,” charts the emergence of ideas about governing Egypt that were made possible by artifacts discourses and the portending confrontation between (pejorative) Islamic tradition surrounding Pharaonic antiquity and emerging European discourses about the ancients. Here Colla illustrates how Europeans used archeology to legitimate intervention (the Egyptians had slipped from their past greatness, they claimed) and to shape their understanding of modern Egyptians as a people disinterested in and unappreciative of their own glorious past and, therefore, explicitly incapable of preserving it.
In Chapter 3, Colla turns his attention to the role of Egyptology in shaping modern Egyptian identity. He illustrates how various Egyptian intellectuals, beginning with Rifaʾa al-Tahtawi in the mid-19th century, began to blend the new European sciences with old literary and historiographical traditions, creating “a new connection between the ancient Egyptian past and the Egyptian present or, more precisely, Egyptian modernity” (p. 124). By the 1920s, personnel of a growing state school system and a new body of Egyptian literati urged Egyptians to know and embrace the ancient past so that they could be more authentically “Egyptian.”
The mobilization of Egyptian authenticity into nationalist platforms is the subject of Chapter 4, “The Discovery of Tutankhamen's Tomb: Archeology, Politics, Literature.” The discovery of the tomb in 1922 placed the appreciation of the ancients “squarely in the center of modern Egyptian political and expressive culture” (p. 175) and resulted in harnessing the Pharaonic past to construct several forms of individual and collective selfhoods. In addition, Colla shows us how the struggle to control the tomb's contents shoved Egyptology to the forefront of political consciousness, making the struggle for sovereignty over the past as critical as the one that Egyptian nationalists were waging over the present.
Finally, in Chapter 5, “Pharaonism after Pharaonism: Mahfouz and Qutb,” Colla demonstrates the limits of Pharaonic discourse as it had become pitted against Islamist discourse by the late 1940s. To be specific, after having lauded Naguib Mahfouz's 1930s corpus, in which the novelist writes extensively about Pharaonic history, and having claimed that every Egyptian child should read Mahfouz's Kifah Tiba (The Struggle of Thebes), Sayyid Qutb did an about face in his enthusiasm for the Pharaohs. As he attempted to read the Qurʾan allegorically—using the present to shape his reading of the text and the text to shape his understanding of the present—the Pharaohs became objectionable, tyrannical, and oppressive to him. If mid-19th-century Egyptians had been disinterested in the Pharaonic past, those under Qutb's sway a century later were asked to renounce it all together.
Colla concludes by suggesting that we should not miss the ironies inherent to a process wherein “the same group of cultural artifacts, narratives and images [comes] to mean such different things to different actors” (p. 273). His suggestion will resonate for anyone who works to chart the chimera of 20th-century Egyptian national identity. It might also serve as an object lesson for those who seek to understand the relationship between contemporary Islamists and objects from pasts they seek to distance themselves from or to destroy. In any case, anyone who picks up Conflicting Antiquities will come away from its reading with a more complete understanding of the relationship between science and colonialism, of the politics inherent to modern tourism, and of the power of the ancients to shape the governing practices of the present. In every case, readers will be delighted by Colla's prose, impressed with his erudition, and engaged by the connections he forges between the appropriated past and the contested present.
