The visual form of a scientific image is no less important than the object it depicts. Hence images in the sciences do not merely mediate – representing scientific results passively – but have their own modes of coining and communicating scientific knowledge. Formal features of scientific images have an independent ability to influence the manner of research, and can easily spark an intellectual fire. These images are therefore not solely ‘illustrations’ but self-contained epistemological elements of the sciences, which need to be taken extremely seriously in their own right.
Such is the central supposition, strongly and clearly defined in the editors' preface, of the volume under review. Das Technische Bild. Kompendium einer Stilgeschichte wissenschaftlicher Bilder is one of the main outcomes of a German research group known for editing the semi-annual journal Bildwelten des Wissens. The group – aptly titled Das Technische Bild (The Technical Image), and with strong links to the history of science – is directed by the art historian Horst Bredekamp within the Helmholtz-Zentrum für Kulturtechnik at Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin. Their work began in the year 2000, when the idea of extending the long-standing art-historical tradition of analysing images beyond the fine arts (in the tradition of, for example, Aby Warburg) to images from the sciences was still fairly novel and unexplored. The term technisch – in the sense of téchne and in accordance with crucial key texts of the history of science – refers to the technical and media-based conditionality of knowledge. In the new compendium, project members present their research results from recent years, at the same time articulating a very convincing general approach useful to anyone who wants to tackle the task of analysing scientific images.
The compendium consists of two sections, the first comprising four methodological essays, the second containing ten case studies. Additional short encyclopedic entries offer methodological and terminological guidelines for specific sorts of analysis – on, for instance, methods of comparison, observation techniques, visual arrangements, objectivity and the popularization of science. At the end is a useful bibliography for further reading. Coloured references on the edge of the page and in brackets connect all the elements of the book with each other, although it must be said that other aspects of the volume's ambitious design can be slightly distracting, and the integrative and introductory purposes would have been better served had each of the case studies ended with more general arguments and project-relevant conclusions. That said, the variety of the case studies embracing images from the sciences (in the wider sense of Wissenschaft) from the sixteenth century up to today is highly impressive and shows how the approach suggested here can be applied to diverse materials. Here we move from suggestive drawings of natural history, through groundbreaking telescopic and microscopic images, to the visualization of the invisible via X-ray photography and scanning-tunnelling microscopy, to the modern computer screen. The method is inductive and based on a specific methodological self-concept of Bildwissenschaft – an interdisciplinary and increasingly institutionalized ‘discipline’ dealing with visual phenomena, though by no means a clearly defined field with a common methodology.
Understandably, given the project's origins and mission, most of the fifteen authors are art historians. (Those who are not have backgrounds in other branches of the humanities, in psychology and in the graphic arts; regrettably, only one comes from the more conventional natural sciences.) In all the essays the detailed formal description of images – an approach which seeks to overcome biased hermeneutics via an unprejudiced inventorying as a first step – is a crucial part of the analysis. Though this putatively impartial starting point might appear out of tune with a concern for historical context, the overall argument in this volume is convincing, and leads to surprising conclusions about the ambivalent character of the visual in the sciences. The essays show that images that seem to depict the represented object in the most ‘natural’ way are ironically the ones that went through the most highly constructive history of production. Not only is the objectivity of scientific images thus challenged, but the accounts here of technical histories, evaluation practices, iconographical traditions and modes of perception make even clearer the constructive character of the images. For all that such images are expected to be self-evident and to follow rules of repetition and verifiability, like experiments, it is nevertheless – or, even better, therefore – the case that manipulated images often generate better scientific results in the eyes of the scientists.
Despite Bredekamp's noteworthy definition of Stil (not equivalent with the English ‘style’) as movens – roughly the subjective, formative embodiment of an act of thinking – the prospect of writing a history of the Stil (as in Stilgeschichte, from the volume's subtitle) of scientific images has here been inconsistently accomplished. But it is a testament to the earnest ambition of the project that the possibility of controversy is raised explicitly in a critical interview with project members. And though too little is said about the mostly paradoxical interplay of text and image which dominates scientific publications, the message comes through clearly as to how rewarding the closer inspection of visual materials can be. Certainly the volume deserves to be treated as an indispensable research tool. Equally desirable is that more scholars with backgrounds in both science and history should take an interest in scientific images, thus forging the link, now missing, to the producers of scientific images. Such combined backgrounds are especially common in the Anglo-Saxon tradition of the history of science. Critical engagement with the significant impetus of Bredekamp's research group could be a further step towards a welcome dialogue between the two cultures and against visual illiteracy.
