In his new book, Eitan Alimi discusses the first Palestinian intifada, which began in 1987 and wound down in 1990 as world attention shifted toward the first Gulf War and the ensuing Madrid talks. Considering the turbulence of the 1990s, which led to the second intifada in 2000, and in light of the events of 9/11 and subsquent American foreign policy in the Middle East (Palestine included), this book's focus might seem out of date. However, Alimi's inquiry serves as a reminder of the first intifada's relevance for understanding later events in Israel and Palestine during the 1990s and beyond. The author forces his readers to examine the dynamics of the first intifada to see what can be learned from it today.
The book consists of six chapters and a postscript. The second chapter, “Constructing Political Opportunities,” lays out the analytical framework of the book. Guided by Erving Goffman's concept of “frame” as an analytical tool, the author employs social-movement theory. However, unlike Goffman, who was interested in the micromoments of what makes social life meaningful to social agents, Alimi is interested in more macroissues, including “the relationship between various groups within a movement and the overall internal dynamics of the movement” (p. 13), the cognitive aspect of the agents’ understanding of the conflict as well as the historic conditions triggering it, how agents as a collective cope with the reaction to their resistance, and what links exist between tactic and strategy (p. 13).
Alimi draws on the work of William Gamson (who wrote the foreword to the book) in theorizing the linkage between the collective and individual framing of an event such as the first intifada and the question of what leads groups to mobilize in order to challenge the political status quo. Influenced by Goffman, Gamson developed the concept of micromobilization, “the study of how face-to-face encounters affect long-term efforts to bring about social change through the mobilization of resources for collective action” (p. 20). In other words, Alimi focuses on the framing of a power struggle between the state of Israel and the Palestinian population in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. To that end, he interviewed many people from the occupied territories on how they make sense of their resistance to occupation. He also closely followed the Palestinian press during the intifada to see how it framed the event. Chapters 2, 3, and 4 answer the question of “why,” “how,” and “when” regarding the first intifada; in other words, they investigate the macro–micro, or the collective–individual linkage through these three questions.
One of Alimi's major findings is that the Palestinians generally followed the Israeli press and internal conflicts within Israel closely during the intifada. According to the author, the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982 and the public uproar against it (exemplified by the emergence of the Israeli peace movement) allowed the Palestinians he interviewed to think of active resistance as a feasible action that could lead to the end of the occupation. Central to the interviewees’ mobilization was the sense that they, and not the Palestinian leadership in exile, were the ones most able to act, because they experienced the occupation firsthand on a daily basis and had no illusions about what could and could not be achieved in relation to the Israeli state. Nevertheless, during this time the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip as a collective remained loyal to the Palestine Liberation Organization and its claim to represent all Palestinians.
Finally, Alimi identifies his book as part of a personal decision to “make the pursuit of peaceful compromise central to my life and scholarly work rather than seeking vengeance” (p. xiv). In doing so, he dares to ask whether peace is possible in light of the further development of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict after the year 2000. The book is a reminder that the conflict must always be studied in a historical light; agency on both sides must be examined while keeping in mind the influence of external interventions in the perpetuation of the conflict. Unfortunately, Alimi's analysis pays little attention to these outside forces. Nevertheless, I recommend reading this book. It is well written and employs an underutilized focus on social movements. It also sets today's events in an analytical context.
