Since the opening in 2006 of Mexico City's Museo de Arte Popular (MAP), scholars, artists and tourists have delighted in the museum's modern style, professional presentation and beautiful exhibits. Visitors impressed by this slick staging of Mexico's popular arts would be surprised to learn of the museum's place in a long line of failed institutions intended to present the artistic creations that are a widely acknowledged centrepiece of Mexico's cultural patrimony. It is perhaps fitting that the art deco former fire hall which houses the collection dates to the period in which the symbols of Mexican national identity became established. These fraught institutional and intellectual histories are the subject of Rick A. López's Crafting Mexico: Intellectuals, Artisans, and the State after the Revolution. Bridging several literatures, places and periods, this volume is an excellent contribution to the scholarship on state formation and the construction of national identity. Readers may be familiar with López's work on the India Bonita contest of 1926 and the Noche Mexicana and Exhibition of Popular Arts of 1921, but here he expands his analysis beyond the 1920s and into new territory. Olinalá, the town in the mountains of Guerrero which produces one of the country's most recognisable and beloved artesanías – the lacquered gourds and trays that grace Fonart shops, the MAP, fair-trade boutiques and handicraft markets throughout Mexico – provides one location for López's analysis of aesthetic mexicanidad. López demonstrates that the local negotiation of power surrounding artistic production and marketing that took place in Olinalá (and towns across the country that originated other popular forms) influenced the construction of the canon of national identity that is now taken for granted in cultural institutions such as the MAP.
López adds to our understanding of the artistic florescence that followed the Revolution of 1910 through his examination of the transnational sources of national identity formation, the investigation of new archival sources, and an extended periodisation. Foreign–Mexican collaboration in the collection and marketing of handicrafts between 1920 and 1940 is the focus of the third chapter, but an attention to the transnational suffuses the entire work. The ideas and preferences of international collectors and boosters like Frances Toor and René d'Harnoncourt interacted with those of nationalist intellectuals such as Manuel Gamio and Moisés Sáenz, as well as local experts such as Víctor Fosado, the working-class employee of Frederick Davis' shop who did the bulk of the collecting in Olinalá, but never received the recognition he deserved. In addition, López's discovery of the records of the Departamento de Monumentos Artísticos, Arqueológicos e Históricos (1930–9) enables him to provide an institutional history of this central organisation and its one-time dependency, the original Museo de Artes Populares (1929–48). What emerges is a more nuanced understanding of commercial, institutional and intellectual participation in the construction of mexicanidad. Rather than portray this identity as fixed, López joins a small but expanding group of scholars who have begun to bring serious historical inquiry to the period after 1940. He argues that the tendency to approach Mexican history in sexenios obscures the importance of major shifts that do not conform to this chronology, as well as the slow, gradual changes that took place in cultural politics from President Lázaro Cárdenas' final years in office through to the end of the ‘Mexican Miracle’. He anchors his examination of this later period in a discussion of the marketing of handicrafts, culminating in an analysis of the 1974 creation of the Fondo Nacional para el Fomento de las Artesanías (National Fund for the Promotion of the Arts, Fonart).
The second part of López's book shows how these national processes articulated with the politics of lacquer production in Olinalá, Guerrero. In his re-examination of artistic production from the local level, the protagonists and even the periodisation of the story change. For example, whereas a national-level analysis of the handicraft suggests that d'Harnoncourt revived lacquer production in Olinalá in the 1920s, López's local sources and informants make it clear that the devastation and loss of the 1910s caused artisans to revive production as a mechanism for coping during a period of crisis. And whereas national policies regarding the sale of handicrafts had long put the artisans of Olinalá at the mercy of the middlemen who controlled them through crushing credit practices, unintended opportunities for agency could also result. In particular, the conciliatory policies of President Luis Echeverría enabled the lacquer workers to achieve a major victory, against the objections of jefes politicos: a road connecting local producers to the market. More generally, though, López demonstrates how the local negotiation of state formation influenced nation formation through Olinaltecos' participation in the ‘ethnicisation’ of Mexican identity.
López's microhistoria of Olinalá is an excellent contribution to the growing literature on Guerrero. The picture he paints of local politics appears so distant at times from the intellectuals and politicians who populate the first part of the book that it seems another project entirely. Indeed, it could have been another book, but to have published it separately would have undermined López's intellectual project of linking the local, national and transnational sources of Mexico's national identity.
López states that ‘the strength of Mexico's cultural bond’ is ‘born of the dynamic relation that emerged between transnational flows, the elite nationalist project, and local experience in such places as Olinalá’ (p. 20). Like the sources of this ethnicised identity, the multiple layers of López's investigation are not unlike lacquer work themselves. Each skilfully applied coat contributes something new to the final product. Crafting Mexico certainly deserves a place on the shelves and syllabi of scholars of Latin American history. Perhaps copies of Crafting Mexico should also be made available for purchase at the MAP gift shop.
