Using Massachusetts as a case study, Johann Neem argues in this important book that the rise of civic associations in the antebellum era was far from an inevitable development. Instead, Neem contends, the nation of joiners de Tocqeville observed in the 1830s resulted from political struggles that began at the end of the eighteenth century, and from deliberate organizational efforts at the beginning of the nineteenth century. Neem shows that republican theory deemed voluntary associations a threat to the public good because they stood between the state and the people and represented a kind of government within a government. Accordingly, Neem reports, in the immediate post-revolutionary period, Massachusetts leaders used laws of incorporation and the chartering process to control which organizations could form and what those organizations could do. At the beginning of the nineteenth century, however, the rise of the party system helped convince Republicans and Federalists alike to recognize a sphere of civil society apart from the state. During the same period, evangelical ministers promoted and defended grassroots organizing around Protestant values in charitable, moral, and educational associations. As a result of a loosening of restrictions at the top and systematic organizing at the bottom, by the late 1820s civic associations of all sorts flourished.
In presenting this account, Neem draws upon many of the sources of earlier studies of civil society, including the impact of Shays's Rebellion on republican thinking, criticisms of the hereditary Society of the Cincinnati, George Washington's condemnation of “all combinations and associations” in his farewell address, the Supreme Court's 1819 holding in favor of Dartmouth College's charter, and the checkered history of the Masons. Neem offers new details about some of these familiar incidents, and supplements them with other evidence, including an intriguing account of the role of Harvard University in the Commonwealth's design. In so doing, Neem offers a rich and often original history of civic organizing, a phenomenon many modern observers have taken for granted. In a less successful concluding chapter, Neem jumps wide historical gulfs to compare antebellum organizing with reform efforts during the Gilded Age and the Progressive Era, and ends the book with a condemnation of modern interest groups because they “fundamentally demean civic activity.” (179)
At times, Neem overstates the shifts that occurred between the last two decades of the eighteenth century and the first two decades of the nineteenth century. For example, Neem makes much of the fact that the 1780 Massachusetts Constitution protected a right of assembly but not of association. However, like the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, the Massachusetts Constitution protected a right to petition government and many early petitions were the work of individuals organized together. So, too, Neem emphasizes the stifling effect of the provision of the Massachusetts Constitution barring individuals and associations from “title to obtain advantages, or particular and exclusive privileges distinct from those of the community” except for “services rendered to the public.” But Neem downplays the separate provision that made it the duty of state government to “encourage private societies and public institutions … for the promotion of agriculture, arts, sciences, commerce, trades, manufactures, and a natural history of the country.” Neem also mostly takes rhetoric about civic associations at face value. For example, in presenting Federalist opposition to the democratic societies of the 1790s as an impossible “imperium in imperio,” Neem does not pause to consider how that critique squared with federalism itself or, indeed, with the colonists' own defenses beginning in the 1760s, of divided lawmaking power. Additionally, while Neem's focus on a single state allows for in-depth analysis, at times Neem misses opportunities for breadth. Many of the civic associations Neem discusses were localized creations tied to the changing politics of the Commonwealth but many others were part of vast national networks that receive relatively little attention in Neem's account.
These criticisms aside, Neem's book makes a significant contribution to the history of civil society in the United States. Despite the book's title, it would be wrong to assume that a history of civic organizing in Massachusetts, the home of town hall democracy, also reflects developments throughout the nation particularly beyond New England. How Americans in other states became joiners will require future studies. Neem has provided a good template for such efforts.
