Rafael Trujillo's brutal and corrupt authoritarian regime in the Dominican Republic (1930–61) was one of the longest and most pervasive dictatorships in Latin American history. For decades, the charismatic dictator has been the subject of numerous historical studies and novels. While acknowledging the excessive state ceremony of Trujillo's rule, most scholars and novelists have paid scant attention to the way in which public ritual played a significant part in establishing a new civic identity and facilitated the entrenchment of the dictatorial regime in the Dominican Republic. In The Dictator's Seduction, Lauren Derby presents a cultural history of the Era of Trujillo that focuses on public culture and daily life. Downplaying the impact of events such as the 1949 and 1959 exile invasions, the 1956 Galíndez–Murphy affair and the murders of the Mirabal sisters in 1960, Derby emphasises the impact that the 1930 hurricane, the 1937 carnival and the 1955 international fair had on legitimising the regime. Derby, an associate professor of history at the University of California, Los Angeles, who received her PhD in Latin American history from the University of Chicago in 1998, interprets symbolic patronage and exchange through the popular idioms of ethnicity, gender, honour, intimidation, patronage, prestige, race, religion and state-sponsored violence.
Derby's research is a finely honed combination of archival investigation blended with oral history that has its roots in her graduate studies during the 1990s. Acknowledging that the Trujillo regime's excessive use of force has led historians to portray Dominicans as either victims or supporters of the dictatorship, Derby contends that most Dominicans during the Era of Trujillo ‘lived in a space of ambivalence and complicity, of passive action in the subjunctive mood’ (p. ix). Her study, therefore, presents a culture of consent that has its origin in the symbolic patronage encouraged by the dictatorship. Especially revealing is Derby's assertion that gift giving on the part of the dictatorship created an unequal relationship between the government and the public that resulted in an ‘illusory bond’ between the general public and the dictator that ‘masked a relation of domination’ (p. 260). Throughout the dictatorship, the national government granted thousands of gifts to the masses. These gifts, which included Christmas bonuses and greeting cards, were viewed as tokens of official recognition. Significantly, Derby explains that the most extravagant gifts, public works projects, were ‘framed as personal presentations’ from Trujillo (p. 261). As such, the phenomenon of gift giving helps to explain how Trujillo was able to remain in power for so long.
Unlike previous Dominican leaders who relied on the support of the Dominican elite, Trujillo, who harboured an intense hatred of the elites, relied on the peasants, the military and friendly relations with the United States to keep himself in power. Recognising the scholarly contribution of individuals such as Richard Turits and Eric Paul Roorda in defining and understanding the Trujillo dictatorship, Derby takes the study of the regime to a new level. Her analysis examines the ‘everyday forms of domination’ of the Trujillo regime and details how ‘the combination of patronage and fear created a culture of compliance’ (p. 7). Unlike previous studies that emphasise Trujillo's omnipresent role in the dictatorship, Derby concentrates on the way in which ‘state practices helped produce the idea that Trujillo was completely in control’ (p. 8). Especially revealing is her understanding that state-sponsored patronage was not merely a means of co-opting the masses. It was an important method of state control, ‘a form of “embedding” the state in the private domain, as well as a technique for coercing consent to the regime’ (p. 21).
Prior to 1930, an excessive degree of foreign intervention coupled with inept elite rule created an environment in the Dominican Republic that was receptive to a strong nationalistic regime. According to Derby, ‘Trujillo camouflaged a flagrantly nepotistic regime via a mask of national development’ (p. 65). In the wake of Hurricane San Zenón, which destroyed the Dominican capital in 1930, Trujillo claimed that he was responsible for rebuilding Santo Domingo; however, the rebuilding of the city was designed to serve his political agenda. Derby explains that the massive Jaragua Hotel was ‘designed primarily as a stage for Trujillista official events’ (p. 102). The 1955 Free World's Fair of Peace and Confraternity was a ‘national extravaganza [that] surpassed all other events of the regime in its excesses of magisterial pomp and spending’ (p. 109). Designed to highlight the success of the Era of Trujillo, the fair was not merely an example of Trujillo's megalomania; it was, Derby argues, ‘an essential part of making the carnivalesque excess of the Era of Trujillo believable’ (p. 134).
Derby's cultural history of the Era of Trujillo is a valuable contribution to the study of the regime. Her research, which is enhanced by her use of anthropological tools, should serve as a guide to historians as they re-evaluate other twentieth-century Latin American dictatorships. An engaging and well-written study, The Dictator's Seduction will benefit scholars and students of Dominican history.
