Last year the China Internet Network Information Center, the official body assigned the task of monitoring Internet security in the People's Republic of China (PRC), announced that the number of Internet users in China had eclipsed the half billion mark.Footnote 1 Over that same period, Chinese state media published several articles comparing Google to the British East India Company; microblogs, in particular Sina's popular Weibo service, were used to spread information and outrage in the wake of a horrific train crash and botched cover-up in July 2011; and more recently a spirited online debate forced the Beijing municipal government to begin releasing detailed reports on that city's epic air quality problems.
It is not surprising then that international coverage of Chinese netizens has focused on the Internet as a space for confrontation and negotiation between state and society, but this is far from being the only—much less the entire—story of the explosive growth of Internet usage in the PRC.Footnote 2 Fengshu Liu's study of the online activities of urban youth in an unnamed city in North China seeks to understand the myriad ways China's young people interact with the Internet, exploring “how urban youth, members of the only-child generation, appropriate the Internet in negotiating meaning making within the socio-cultural context of a Chinese society experiencing spectacular transformation” (p. 2).
Chinese urban youth and young adults do go online to express themselves, sometimes politically, but Liu argues that the excessive focus on “censorship and crackdowns disregards the much wider societal implications of the Internet” (p. 47). Instead, she wants us to understand the relationship between users' online and offline lives, and how they perceive the Internet as a means to achieve aspirational goals, to connect with a wider community, and, perhaps most of all, “to play,” which here has a wide range of meanings, including online gaming, accessing entertainment, as well as creating and deploying new identities and roles. Indeed, identity is an important theme in Liu's research, whether as a group defined through connections made in online spaces such as BBSs and chatrooms—as in the case of several sites catering to the post-1980 generation—or the individual, who can be transformed and transported through the creation of new online personas.
Although most of Liu's respondents were aware of issues of government censorship, very few reported being affected by these controls. As Liu notes, part of this is the insular nature of China's Internet. Who needs Twitter, Facebook, or YouTube when you have access to sites such as Sina Weibo, Renren, or Youku, sites with Chinese-language interfaces that were designed specifically for the Chinese market? That many of these sites are subject to government- and self-censorship is regarded as an annoyance, but hardly a deal-breaker when Chinese young people principally view the Internet as a tool for online communication, gaming, entertainment, and, increasingly, shopping. In this way, China's online youth culture continues to confound international activists who put a great deal of faith in the power of the Internet to undermine repressive regimes.
Even so, the Internet, and in particular online youth, remains a concern for both the government and mainstream society in the PRC. Liu looks at the stigma surrounding the dark, cavernous “wangbas,” Internet cafes, usually portrayed as dens of truant teens lured away from the path of educational and social advancement. This anxiety feeds a national obsession over “Internet addiction,” where parents' fears of arrested upward social mobility intersect with anxieties about the kind of information or enticements available given unregulated access to the Internet. Then there is the issue of online nationalists, who are one of the most visible groups in the Chinese online ecosystem, but who are, as Liu and others have demonstrated, viewed quite warily by a government concerned that their enthusiasm could prove disruptive or be channeled in unsuitable directions.
Liu does an excellent job of showing how the online and offline lives and identities of China's young people intersect as they try to navigate the awesome changes happening to their lives during this period of rapid economic development and social transformation. There will be those who wonder if the sampling of interviews, most of which were conducted with friends or friends of friends in Liu's hometown, provide sufficient support for some of the rather general conclusions attempted in this study, and on a theoretical level the comparisons with a rather undifferentiated “West” versus “China” regarding the Internet could be refined further. There are almost as many differences between the attitudes of American young people and those of Norway, where Liu works as a researcher, as there are between the United States and China. Nevertheless, those interested in understanding the shifts in China's urban youth culture—perhaps one of the most kinetically powerful forces in the world today—will find this a useful resource and a necessary corrective to the sometimes simplistic dualities presented in international media reports of China's surging online population.
