“There is at present in the material world,” according to Kelvin's second law of dynamics, “a universal tendency to the dissipation of mechanical energy.” Richard Samuelson's essay in this present volume quotes from Adams's letter to Gaskell in 1909: “Kelvin was a great man, and I am sorry I did not know enough of mathematics to follow him instead of Darwin who led us all wrong” (166). I would speculate that the subtext here has had something to do with a persistent scepticism on Adams's part towards an unquestioning idea of progress that might be derived from a Darwinian model in favour of an acceptance of the world's multiplicity. But Adams would be sceptical also about the ease of such separations, proclaiming himself, within a single sentence, both “conservative” and “anarchist.”
The general editor of the Political Companions to Great American Authors series, Patrick J. Deneen, proclaims in his foreword, “Perhaps more than any other nation's literary tradition, American literature is ineluctably political – shaped by democracy as much as it has in turn shaped democracy” (vii); and it is through Adams's diverse output (novelist, historian, political commentator, biographer and “autobiographer”) that we may recognize the truth of this claim, particularly in terms of Natalie Fuehrer Taylor's wise definition: “For Adams, the political life entailed a consideration of how human beings ought to live and what form of government would best promote human flourishing” (1).
As Taylor notes, the only full-length treatment of Adams by a political scientist remains James P. Young, Henry Adams: The Historian as Political Theorist (2001), a lengthy extract from which is included here, so the present collection is needed, certainly. Of its ten essays, five have been published previously (and in places that are not obscure), and so our interests should be directed to what is new here. Taylor's Introduction makes an eloquent case for his literary statesmanship, and her own essay on Esther (which includes a telling comparison with Hawthorne's “Old Esther Dudley”) concerns the anxiety of “how American self-governance will be preserved as the reign of science replaces the reign of religion” (115), with the attendant loss of seriousness in human behaviour as self-assertion becomes a new threat to democracy. Adams's other novel, Democracy, is read by Denise Dutton as “a tribute to the creative nature of democracy” (106), where the capacity for reform is to be found in qualities of common sense, generous sympathy and humility, detectable in quite ordinary actions. Richard Samuelson focusses on Adams's presidential address to the American Historical Association to explore his concerns over history as a scientific discipline, and finds it incomplete as such, while Wilson Carey McWilliams is represented by what looks like an afterthought from his The Idea of Fraternity in America (1973).
The most lively essay in the collection is Deneen's consideration of Mont-Saint-Michel and Chartres, which presents a robust challenge to the prevailing view that it marks a descent from unity to multiplicity. Rather, it is to be seen as an ascent, “an exploration of how unity derived from a multiplicity of views in the Middle Ages, and – by contrast – how a multiplicity of experience arose from a unity of scientific understanding in the modern age” (174–75). This is an astute rethinking of two of the most important terms we associate with Adams: medieval thought is attractive “because it achieves unity not through the demolition of actual multiplicity … but in the preservation of multiplicity through which a greater or higher unity was achieved,” and it is in such preservation that there is “more possibility for human liberty and true human diversity” (187). Here, Deneen recognizes the extent of Adams's radicalism: “Against the grain of his age, he defended the liberty of a pluralistic unity against the enforcement of modern unity that demolished diversity and sowed meaninglessness and uncertainty in its wake” (188).
In one way or another, it is Adams's sense of a polity and a culture increasingly dominated by industrial and, particularly, scientific advance that colours many of the essays here. I am surprised, therefore, that none of them picks up on Karl Pearsons's The Grammar of Science (first published in 1892; Adams read the second edition of 1900) which provides the title for chapter 31 of the Education. By this time, the principal subject of thought is the notion of “force” and its various manifestations where the problem increasingly becomes one not of recognition but of description, or, within his self-appointed role as “scientific” historian, one of measurement. A knowledge of mere data is insufficient – factual incidents in themselves yield no sense of historical location or of their relationships with each other. Adams understands that when science no longer pretends to offer an explanation but rather a description it becomes a kind of metalanguage – given that it faces a world whose characteristics are multiplicity and chaos, it recognizes the futility of intolerant explanation and so intervenes with describing reactions. The liberations offered by this version of scientific discourse occasion possibilities for a revitalizing historical procedure. What is most challenging for Adams, picking up on Kelvin's law, is the waste of energy, the lack of economy in its use, and here the economizing nature of scientific description is again a lesson well learned from Pearson, as he acknowledges “such progress as the world made consisted in economics of energy rather than in its development” (Riverside edition of the Education (1974), 476).
