Urban Violence in the Middle East deals with different forms of violence that erupted in urban spheres of the Middle East at the time of transition from the Ottoman and Qajar empires to emerging nation-states. The editors, Ulrike Freitag, Nelida Fuccaro, Claudia Ghrawi, and Nora Lafi, contend that the studies presented in this book challenge the stereotypical and monocausal explanations of violence in the region, by presenting more nuanced accounts that place special importance on spatial, intergroup, and gender-related questions.
The book is divided into four parts. The first, “Managing and Employing Violence,” focuses on the role of the Ottoman state and state administrators. The three chapters in this section cover urban resistance to Napoleon's second suppression of revolts in Cairo in 1800, the challenge of suppressing and investigating crimes that led to intragroup violence in late Ottoman Istanbul, and the gendered aspects of negotiating sexual assault and misdemeanors in interwar Cairo.
The second part of the book, “Symbolic Politics of Violence,” analyzes the changing cityscapes of Iran through transformed sectarian divisions, as well as the symbolic dimensions of clashes concerning Jeddah's port economy in Ottoman times. The third part investigates “Communal Violence and Its Discontents” by scrutinizing cases such as the 1850 uprisings in Aleppo, the massacres of Armenians in Istanbul (1895–96), and the Nebi Musa riots in Jerusalem in 1920. Lastly, the fourth part, “Oil Cities: Spatiality and Violence,” addresses labor unrests in oil cities of the Middle East in late- and postcolonial times, challenging simple dichotomized explanations of conflicts as pitting foreign oil companies against local labor forces.
Although the book is divided into different sections, each labeled to explore different dimensions of violence, those dimensions reappear in other parts of the book as well, rendering the structure of the book at times somewhat artificial. Yet the fact that many chapters in the book analyze intersectional dimensions of violence (thereby precisely resisting monocausal or thematic explanations) is what makes the overall contribution of the book so strong and unique.
Three dominant levels of analysis add value to the volume. The first concerns an analysis of various scales of violence within the city, placing emphasis on both spatiality and symbolism in the explanation of why specific places became major sites for the negotiation of violence. This focus is most visible in chapter 1, where Lafi argues that Cairo's Ezbekiyye Square became the site where both the French and the Ottomans struggled for control of the city. In chapter 5, the suppression of local violence against imperial powers in Jeddah, as Freitag shows, was staged at places both visible from the sea and from the land, or places that symbolized the centralization of imperial powers. Place, however, is not only analyzed in a geographic sense; in chapter 4, Masoudi-Nejad shows how the annual Muharram processions in an Iranian town opened up a place from which to renegotiate received forms of sectarian separations in the city.
The second level of analysis involves challenging normative conceptions of sectarian violence. The rich and detailed arguments presented in chapters 2, 5, and 6 show that explanations through sectarian lenses alone do injustice to the complexity of some of the urban incidents in this crucial transitional phase from empire to nation-state. In Jeddah (chapter 5), for instance, Freitag explains that not only ambassadors representing imperial powers, but also the local Christian population that became identified with those powers, were targets of urban violence. In the 1850 uprisings in Aleppo (chapter 6), the attack on Christians, Krimsti argues, happened less on the grounds of religion than because of associations with an elevated social and economic class; this wealth was expressed at religious sites and thereby made those sites targets as well. In chapter 2, Lévi-Aksu provides an excellent analysis of violent eruptions between Greek and Jewish communities in Late Ottoman Istanbul, where initially unresolved murder cases or the desecration of religious symbols led to specific mechanisms of blame, intensified by biased news outlets, which the state used to maintain control.
Third, highlighting the diverse groups involved in conflict, the authors challenge and dismantle popular but dichotomized ideas of state versus citizen or company versus citizen. Chapter 3 stands out in this volume for its focus on gender-related violence in interwar Cairo: Hammad's central argument shows that the ways in which courts judged and handled swearing in cases of gendered violence had less to do with the damage done to particular victims (though sometimes their social or sexual status did lead to harsher punishments for perpetrators) than the damage to and the infringement on the moral compass of the middle class.
The book is a timely contribution to the field, despite sometimes lacking a contextualization of the case studies in the broader sociopolitical circumstances of the time. In this regard, the chapters of Freitag and Lévy-Aksu, which combine historical contextualization and detailed analysis, are a welcome exception. Yet the details provided in this book are also its worthwhile contribution to the field. Without the depth of analysis that is traceable throughout the book's chapters, more nuanced arguments for the causes, mechanisms, and resolutions of urban incidents of violence in the Middle East's past would not be possible. As such, the book is not only suited for historians of the region and social scientists with a historical focus, but also scholars of contemporary conflicts who seek to enrich their analysis through historical comparison. In that regard, the book conveys its most important message: simplistic or ethnocentric explanations of violence falsely represent not only contemporary eruptions of violence in the region, but also those of the region's past.
Urban Violence in the Middle East provides a point of reference for mitigating the power of claims that violence is solely rooted in cultural or religious and sectarian problems that are doomed to recur. By analyzing the complexity of violent urban phenomena, the book implores us to stop seeing violence in the Middle East as exceptional. Instead, it suggests we look at the intersecting claims to a right to the city, equally enunciated by its different local inhabitants and various representations of power that were specific to the transitional phase from empires to evolving nation-states.
