Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T13:23:56.607Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Generation and characterization of fully developed state in open channel flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 January 2022

S. Das
Affiliation:
Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, ON N9B 3P4, Canada
R. Balachandar
Affiliation:
Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, ON N9B 3P4, CanadaDepartment of Mechanical, Automotive & Materials Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, ON N9B 3P4, Canada
R.M. Barron*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical, Automotive & Materials Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, ON N9B 3P4, CanadaDepartment of Mathematics & Statistics, University of Windsor, Windsor, ON N9B 3P4, Canada
*
† Email address for correspondence: az3@uwindsor.ca

Abstract

A fully developed approach flow is necessary in open channel studies to maintain commonality among datasets obtained from different facilities. Two-component planar particle image velocimetry is used to study the characteristics of fully developed smooth open channel flow at a constant Reynolds number of 3.9 × 104 based on the maximum velocity and flow depth. The near-bed boundary layer is tripped to achieve a fully developed state and compared with the under- and over-tripped cases. The Reynolds stresses and higher-order moments are used as indicators to establish the fully developed state. Flow properties are explored by identifying uniform momentum zones (UMZs) using the probability density function of streamwise velocities. The instances are grouped based on the number of UMZs (NUMZ) and conditional averaging of flow variables of each group is used to evaluate the difference in flow properties between the developed and the developing flow. Large-scale ejections are found in the logarithmic layer when NUMZ is higher, whereas a lower number indicates the existence of large-scale sweeping motions. The distribution of the conditionally averaged ratio of the shear contribution from ejections and sweeps and velocity deficits shows a vertical variability in the fully developed state. The large-scale and pointwise quadrant events are used simultaneously to depict variability in inner flow properties between developing and fully developed flow which cannot be recognized in the mean flow characteristics. The sweep events have much higher shear generation in the outer flow in the fully developed state whereas the shear stress contribution from ejection is lower than that in developing flow.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of the recirculating flume and test set-up.

Figure 1

Table 1.Details of the test conditions, trip characteristics and flow parameters.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Deviation in the mean and turbulence quantities with increase in sample size.

Figure 3

Table 2.Shear velocities for different test cases.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Streamwise variation of (a) normalized wall-shear velocity $({U_\tau }/{U_\infty })$ and (b) shape factor for the fully developed states. Every seventh data point is shown for clarity.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Mean streamwise velocity profiles at H = 0.135 m normalized by inner scaling, compared with the log-law profile. Velocity profiles for tests T1, T1&T2 and T1&T3 are shifted vertically by a constant value to enhance visualization. The figure is generated using a subset of the total data points to avoid clutter.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Collapse onto Krogstad's velocity defect law (VDL) for different trip conditions at H = 0.135 m with the normalization of y coordinate by (a) δ and (b) δ′. The profiles of T1, T1&T2 and T1&T3 are shifted by a constant value. Every fifth point is shown for clarity.

Figure 7

Table 3.Boundary layer thickness.

Figure 8

Figure 6.Distribution of normalized streamwise, bed-normal and shear stresses: (a–c) H = 0.135 m and (d–f) H = 0.170 m. Every fifth point is shown for clarity.

Figure 9

Figure 7.Distribution of normalized third-order and fourth-order moments: (a–d) H = 0.135 m and (e–h) H = 0.170 m. Every fifth point is shown for clarity.

Figure 10

Figure 8.Comparison of fully developed profiles with previous studies: (a) mean streamwise velocity $(U/{U_\infty })$, (b–d) Reynolds stresses $(\overline {{{u^{\prime}}^2}} /U_\infty ^{\; 2},\overline {{{v^{\prime}}^2}} /U_\infty ^{\; 2}, - \overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} /U_\infty ^2)$, (e–h) third- and fourth-order moments of streamwise velocity fluctuation (Su, Sv, Fu, Fv). The grey region presents a variation of ±10 % from the fully developed flow data of test case T1&T3 at H = 0.170 m. Every seventh point of the current experimental data is shown for clarity.

Figure 11

Table 4.Details of previous studies used to check the self-similarity of the fully developed state (OCF: open channel flow, CF: channel flow, TBL: turbulent boundary layer).

Figure 12

Figure 9.(a) Normalized mean TNTI location $({Y_{TNTI}})$ for all test cases at H = 0.170 m and the distribution of ${Y_{TNTI}} + 3\sigma $ for the fully developed state T1&T3 (inset) corresponding to a value of Kth between 0.3 to 5.0. (b) The probability distribution of ${Y_{TNTI}}$ for test cases T0 and T1&T3 at H = 0.170 m, estimated using Kth = 0.9.

Figure 13

Figure 10.(a) PDF of streamwise velocities below TNTI for a single instance. The inverted triangles ‘▾ - blue’ indicate the modal velocities and the dashed lines differentiate the UMZs. The continuous blue line represents the curve fitted over the probability data to find the modal velocities. (b) Corresponding contour plot of the UMZs. The average bed-normal position (i.e. the adjacent upper contour level) and the thickness of the momentum zones are presented by ${Y_{UMZ}}{|_{{R_i}}}$ and ${t_{UMZ}}{|_{{R_i}}}$, where i is the rank of the corresponding momentum zone.

Figure 14

Figure 11.(a) PDF of NUMZ corresponding to bin size $0.5{U_\tau }$; (b) bed-normal distributions of ${Y_{UMZ}}{|_{{R_i}}}$ and ${Y_{MV}}{|_{{R_i}}}$ (shown by ‘$\bullet$ - black’ and ‘▴ - ash’, respectively) for the fully developed flow (test case T1&T3 at H = 0.170 m). The subscript i indicates the value of the rank.

Figure 15

Figure 12.Conditional averaging of the data corresponding to a specific value of NUMZ based on their rank $({R_i})$ of (a) modal velocities $({U_{MV}}{|_{{R_i}}})$, (b) bed-normal position of the mean contour level of UMZs $({Y_{UMZ}}{|_{{R_i}}})$ and (c) the corresponding thickness of UMZs $({t_{UMZ}}{|_{{R_i}}})$. Same markers are used for the same rank whereas similar colours are used for a specific value of NUMZ. The markers represent the centred values and the bars show the distribution around the centred value based on the magnitude of 25th and 75th percentiles. The distributions corresponding to NUMZ = 3 are presented for (d) ${U_{MV}}{|_{{R_1}}}$, (e) ${Y_{UMZ}}{|_{{R_1}}}$ and (f) ${t_{UMZ}}{|_{{R_1}}}$. The magnitudes of the 25th and 75th percentiles are shown by the dashed lines and the zone between them presents the centred 50 % of the data.

Figure 16

Figure 13.(a) PDF of NUMZ corresponding to bin size 0.5Uτ for the developing flow (T0 at H = 0.170 m) and the fully developed flow (T1&T3 at H = 0.170 m). Distributions of conditionally averaged (based on the value of NUMZ) ratio of shear stress contribution from Q2 and Q4 events for (b) the fully developed flow and (c) the developing flow. For clarity, plots are generated using a subset of total data points. In (b,c), every fifth point is shown.

Figure 17

Figure 14.Distributions of conditionally averaged (based on the value of NUMZ) normalized streamwise and wall-normal velocity deficit for (a,b) the fully developed flow (T1&T3 at H = 0.170 m) and (c,d) the developing (T0 at H = 0.170 m). Every fifth point is shown for clarity.

Figure 18

Figure 15.Distributions of conditionally averaged (based on large-scale ejection events, E1 or large-scale sweep events, E2) ratio of shear stress contribution from Q2 and Q4 events for (a) the fully developed flow (T1&T3 at H = 0.170 m) and (b) the developing flow (T0 at H = 0.170 m). The dashed line represents the edge of the logarithmic layer. Every fifth point is shown for clarity.

Figure 19

Figure 16.The distribution of conditionally averaged (based on the large-scale Q2 events defined as ${E_1}$ and the large-scale Q4 events defined as ${E_2}$ in the logarithmic layer) shear stress contribution (a) $- {\overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} _{Q2}}{|_{{E_1}}}$, (b) $- {\overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} _{Q4}}{|_{{E_1}}}$, (c) $- {\overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} _{Q2}}{|_{{E_2}}}$and (d) $- {\overline {u^{\prime}v^{\prime}} _{Q4}}{|_{{E_2}}}$) for the fully developed flow (T1&T3 at H = 0.170 m) the developing flow (T0 at H = 0.170 m). The subscript Qi indicates the contribution in ejection and sweep events for i = 2 and 4, respectively. Every fifth point is shown for clarity.

Figure 20

Figure 17.Variation of ${\bar{N}_{peaks}}$ with the change in (a) threshold kinetic energy deficit $({K_{th}})$ and (b) length of FOV (L+).

Figure 21

Figure 18.PDF of NUMZ corresponding to bin size (a) 0.25Uτ and (d) 0.75Uτ for the fully developed flow (T1&T3 at H = 0.170 m) and the developing (T0 at H = 0.170 m). Corresponding bed-normal distribution of ${R_{Q2/Q4}}$ for bin size 0.25Uτ and 0.75Uτ for (b,e) the fully developed flow and (c,f) the developing flow. In (b,c,e,f), every third point is shown for clarity.