As Alan Walker rightly opens this volume, Peter Townsend ‘was one of the world's greatest social scientists’ (p. xv). He was rigorous in his research, explicit in his values and he contributed more to the understanding of social policy than any of his peers. He was also an active campaigner for social justice who, as Walker makes clear, played an important part in the promotion of sheltered housing for older people, de-institutionalisation of people with mental health problems, the introduction of Attendance Allowances, increases in child benefits and the current child poverty reduction targets (p. xvii).
If any social scientist deserves a volume made up of selections from his writings, all beautifully crafted and powerfully argued, it is Peter Townsend. It is divided into parts which are edited by academics well-qualified in their appreciation of Peter Townsend. They are, in order, Alan Walker on ‘Sociology and social policy’, Nicola Yeates on ‘From welfare state to international welfare’, David Gordon on ‘Poverty’, Ruth Levitas on ‘Inequality and social exclusion’, Peter Phillimore on ‘Health inequalities and health policy’, Chris Phillipson on ‘Older people’, Alan Walker on ‘Disability’ and Margot E. Salmon on ‘Social justice and human rights’.
In a book of 678 pages, I have space to dwell on just a couple of the parts, starting with ‘Sociology and social policy’.
In 1963, at the age of 35, Peter was appointed Professor of Sociology at the University of Essex. He was happy to develop social policy and research within his department of sociology. His hope was, he wrote, ‘that a concern with social policy must be central rather than peripheral to sociology’ (p. 11), but this has not happened in many universities. But what did he mean by social policy?
In the early 1960s, I was taught social policy by the young Peter Townsend at LSE. He was magic because he went beyond the traditional – and often the text book approach – of simply examining the development and coverage of separate social services like housing, social work and the voluntary sector. He examined how these services not only contributed to social progress, but also how they might impede it. He constantly returned to looking at the social class structure of who ran and who received the services. As shown in selections from his writings, social policy covered not just the traditional local authority, voluntary services and central government departments but also – as Richard Titmuss likewise insisted – the taxation system. Townsend points out that ‘the extension of employers welfare benefits in kind for high-income groups may quickly neutralise the effects of the introduction of a more progressive system of taxation’ (p. 8).
His definition of social policy emerges as ‘the underlying as well as the professed rationale by which social institutions and groups are used or brought into being to ensure social preservation or development’ (p. 8). He elaborated, ‘Social policy is, in other words, the institutional control of services, agencies and organizations to maintain or change social structures and values’ (p. 8).
Townsend has been one of the few academics and activists to argue consistently that inequality is as great, if not greater, a problem than poverty. Section IV on Inequality and Exclusion provides extracts from nine articles. Five of these are taken from newspapers and magazines. He was able to present his views graphically and soundly in short pieces which were widely available to the general public. I can but pick out three themes.
First, inequality had not been tackled. In 1971, he declared in The Times in a piece entitled ‘Poverty: has the welfare state failed?’, that ‘in spite of social and incomes legislation, greater equality of real incomes was not achieved between the mid-1950s and 1970’ (p. 286).
Second, a major reason for the lack of change was that all the main political parties did not desire reform. An article in The New Statesman in 1976 was tellingly called, ‘The truce on inequality’. One reason for the truce was that most politicians asserted, wrongly, that the welfare state had ensured near equal incomes and treatment for all citizens. Further, he wrote that ‘There is near unanimity between Tories and Socialists on the desirability of ever increasing production. Why have a war of attrition between different sections of society about inequality and redistribution when all can share in increasing wealth?’ (pp. 278–9). In fact, increasing wealth was not fairly distributed. Nonetheless, the Labour Party put less and less emphasis on socialist principles, accompanied by the fading of interest in the subject of inequality (p. 276).
Third, Townsend responded by insisting that inequality should be tackled. In a piece in Poverty in 1983, called ‘The pursuit of equality’, he did not argue from the philosophical base that all people were of equal value and should share as equally as possible in the advantages of civilisation. Instead, he argued that gross inequalities were entirely man-made. ‘they flow directly and indirectly from the operations of industry, the banking system, the wage system and the property system’ (pp. 297–8). It followed that it was possible for humankind to reverse the process. The reform was desirable because inequality meant not just that a section of the population experienced social deprivations while others were in luxury, but also because it prevented them from enjoying the choices about life styles and occupations that were available to those at the top.
Peter's death in 2009 almost coincided with the publication of the study by Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett The Spirit Level: Why more equal societies almost always do better (Reference Wilkinson and Pickett2009). This is global research which, as shown in Part 11, was one of his abiding interests. Wilkinson and Pickett established that greater equality promoted fewer social disadvantages and more contentment. They confirmed what Peter Townsend had always claimed that greater equality led to a better society.
My only suggestion for improving this outstanding volume is the inclusion of a few paragraphs about Peter's early life. He was brought up by a lone mother (and sometimes a grandmother). For a while, they lived in a small upstairs flat with the cooker on the landing. He had a love–hate relationship with Cambridge University where he loved the facilities for learning but hated the elitism. As a young research worker, he gave much time to interviewing unemployed people in their own homes and learning from them. As Chris Phillipson does point out, when researching for his classic The Last Refuge, Peter worked as an attendant in one of the old workhouses. Peter told me that the job included washing down old men, a task he tried to do with dignity.
From these experiences, Peter knew what poverty was like at the hard end, detected the central importance of social class and discovered that a researcher had to be in close, personal contact with those he studied. The lessons stayed with him all his life.
