One way of judging an edited collection covering a range of different themes is how far the separate contributions cohere to present a common analytical position. On this criterion The Bachelet Government is successful, as successive chapters reinforce certain themes – most of them critical of the overall performance of the Concertación governments in power from 1990 to 2010, and disappointed in the performance of the Bachelet administration. Most chapters finish a year or so before the end of that government, so the assessments overall are to some extent provisional, though what happened during that period does not greatly affect the overall arguments presented.
The starting point of most authors is that the Concertación government has simply continued the market model of the Pinochet government, but was the Pinochet model such a clear example of unfettered free-market economics? The Pinochet model itself shifted significantly after the crisis of 1982–3 towards greater involvement in the part of the state. The privatisations of the Pinochet regime were hardly models of neoliberalism, as they simply transferred public monopolies to private ones without an adequate regulatory framework – a model of crony capitalism rather than neoliberalism. And if the Pinochet model was strictly neoliberal, how is this compatible with the largest state enterprise in the country, the Corporación Nacional del Cobre de Chile (National Copper Corporation of Chile, CODELCO), remaining in the state sector?
Another objection to the notion of simple continuity of the model after dictatorship is that if the models both of and after Pinochet were the same, how can we explain the fact that the growth record of the Pinochet government over 17 years was mediocre and came with immense social costs, whereas the growth record of the Concertación was impressive and saw major social improvements? The same model, but very different outcomes? This seems odd. However, the real and very considerable value of this book lies not in an overall analysis of any presumed model but in the close and specific examination of several sectors which does indeed demonstrate that Concertación policy has in almost all areas been far too business-friendly and over-anxious to reach consensus across the political divide. But the chapters also show that various attempted reforms of the democratic governments have been effectively vetoed or have lost most of their reformist edge through the opposition of the Right. It is true that the Right agreed to certain reforms such at tax reform in 1990 and the constitutional reforms of 2005, but given the power of the Right in Congress, the business sectors, the media, the Church and the military, it had an effective veto power of reforms that were not to its liking.
The book is divided into two sections. The first part deals with politics. Peter Siavelis acutely points out that what made Bachelet an attractive candidate – her image as a consensual figure, detached from the political parties – were precisely those features that militated against her constructing a successful governing coalition and implementing the reforms she promised. Overall this is an excellent account of the decline of the governing ability of the Concertación. Robert Funk covers similar ground, arguing forcefully that Bachelet's personal history and policy of elite regeneration and greater participation were inimical to creating effective government. Gregory Weeks provides an illuminating account of the varying interpretations of when the transition to democracy actually finished; he argues that the claims that a civil–military consensus existed were not true, and that this caused problems for the process of democratisation.
Part 2 of the book deals with socio-economic policies. Silvia Borzutzky provides an overview of such policies in Chile and analyses in some detail the nature and pattern of inequality in the country. Her treatment of the various social sectors points to a failure to make significant changes in the pattern of inequality, although she does draw attention to the positive nature of pension reform and increased health budgets during the Bachelet government. Mary Rose Kubal analyses the major protest movement of schoolchildren – the ‘Penguins’ – and offers a convincing account of the weakness of the movement (and others like it, presumably) in terms of affecting policy, or at least policies that are to their liking. The chapter by Kirsten Sehnbruch on labour is an acute critique of the failure of the democratic governments to deal with inequalities in the labour market. Arguably this is the biggest defect of the overall social policies of the democratic government, with profound implications for inequality. Sehnbruch's chapter is a model of clear exposition of a complicated and neglected theme, highlighting the importance of labour contracts in explaining the failure to improve job security but also in failing to create a skilled labour force capable of transforming the Chilean economy. She offers feasible policy alternatives that would promote both equity and economic development. Susan Franceshet emphasises the negative role of the Right in blocking attempts to improve gender equality, but argues that if there has been little improvement in increasing women's political participation or in reproductive rights, there has been significant progress in policies to counter violence against women. The chapter by Eduardo Silva and Patricio Rodrigo, another model of convincing exposition, argues that the Concertación's emphasis on property rights blocked the demands of the environmental and indigenous movements. Silva and Rodrigo explain why such movements employ contentious policies and the limited extent to which they have achieved success, and they credit the Bachelet government with having the most progressive indigenous policy so far.
The various chapters of the book present well-founded criticisms of democratic government in Chile. Perhaps the overall bias is too much towards criticism, for surely the democratic governments have good reasons for pride – creating a stable democratic order and overseeing important transformations in the Chilean economy are no small achievements, not least when made in the face of an intransigent and powerful Right. Not far short of half of the electorate voted for four more years of the same government in 2010, which would seem to imply very considerable support still for the Concertación – not many coalition governments could claim the same after 20 years in power. Nevertheless, the themes chosen by the editors (though one on human rights would have been welcome) and the overall high quality of the chapters make this an important contribution to our understanding of the nature of democracy in Chile.
