In this book, the author has focused on both the theory and practice of international law from the 13th to 15th centuries in Nasrid, Granada. In brief, this study argues for the exceptional nature of Granada's legal culture and for the importance of understanding Granada to be as much part of early modern Europe as it was part of the Muslim world (pp. vii, 144). Centered on a series of close readings of treaties and contracts between Granada and its Christian neighbor the Kingdom of Aragón, the author argues that Nasrid Granada was distinguished from more conservative Muslim North African states by the practicality of its foreign policy (pp. 17, 21, 85).
The book is divided into thirteen chapters, in which the author deals with a remarkable variety of subjects. The first four chapters introduce the study, situate Granada within Renaissance Europe, offer an overview of Granada's political history, and outline Granada's economic importance. In Chapters 5 through 10 the author offers a summary of previous work on Islamic international law (Völkerrecht), an explanation of the importance of the formal language employed by scribes when drawing up treaties, an analysis of nine treaties between Granada and Aragón, a comparison of three treaties between North African states and Aragón, a survey of Islamic international contract law, and finally, references in Granadan sources to piracy and how Granadan rulers employed treaties to protect captured subjects. The final three chapters discuss the practice of Islamic law in Granada and debates on whether it was legally permissible for a Muslim to remain living under non-Muslim rule and conclude with a summary of the exceptional characteristics of Islamic international law as practiced in Granada. In each of the legal subjects examined, it is argued that Granadan legal practice was distinguished by a practical realism.
This brief summary of the book speaks to the broad number of topics the author has addressed—and the impressive number of secondary sources with which he has familiarized himself—in order to support his secondary argument. This argument can be summarized as follows: whereas classical Islamic law on international relations (often referred to as siyār) foresaw only temporary truces with non-Muslim opponents that were principally justified by Muslim weakness (p. 41), Granadan jurists justified truces that lasted as long as the life of the ruler who signed them (p. 52), allied Granada with Aragón against other Muslim states (pp. 54, 60), and acknowledged Christian rulers as equals (pp. 50–51). These jurists, who were closely monitored by Granada's rulers (p. 15), justified these departures from precedent by invoking maṣlaḥa, the general good of the Muslim community (pp. 95–96). Although this legal principle was known outside of the Maliki law school prevalent in Granada and North Africa, the author relies on previous scholarship to argue that it had achieved particular prominence in Nasrid Granada (p. 113). To his credit, the author does show how the use of maṣlaḥa did not always lead to a break with precedent and could in fact play a conservative role (p. 131). Still, the prominence and prevalence of references to maṣlaḥa in the writings of Granadan jurists (the most notable of whom is al-Shatibi, p. 131) is held to be indicative of a broader pragmatism in Nasrid legal decisions (pp. 120–21, 139), which can be contrasted with the conservative, narrow legalism of the North African scholars both before and after the fall of al-Andalus (pp. 85, 141). This pragmatism is in turn indicative, the author implies, of a departure from a blind legalism that did not consider historical realties and, more importantly, of the modernity of Granada (pp. 143–44).
The scope of this argument is extraordinary for such a short book, and the study is convincing in its demonstration of the exceptional nature of Granada. Yet several problems with the argument should be noted. In order to emphasize the exceptionalism of Nasrid Granada, the author repeatedly stresses the conservatism of the Almohads and their legacy in North Africa (pp. 47, 85). Yet, as much recent scholarship on the Almohads has shown (see inter alia, the work of Maribel Fierro), the Almohad revolution not only propounded an exceptionally “rational” interpretation of Islam, but also supported the study of philosophy in an unprecedented fashion. Regardless of what the author is referring to with the term “conservative,” it would then seem insufficient to argue for a broad North African conservatism based on a comparatively small body of primary sources. In addition, although stressing the importance of reading Granadan treaties in their historical context (p. 76), by labeling them as conservative the author seems to ignore the possibility that North African Muslim states were acting just as practically within their own particular contexts. Even more striking, while repeatedly referring to the “modernity” of Granada, almost always with reference to the work of Gottfried Liedl (pp. 47, 143), the author never explains what he means by this term. This omission is especially frustrating because in his conclusion he very briefly notes that as a characteristic “modernity” is not to be understood as primarily European and should be applied not only to Granada but also to other parts of the early-modern world system (p. 144). Although suggestive, such an observation needs to be developed further in order to be convincing.
The author's argument would have been substantially strengthened if he had narrowed his focus and explained the framework of his argument at considerably greater length. Despite these flaws, this study offers a welcome addition to the study of Islamic international law and to the place of Nasrid Granada in Muslim intellectual history.
