August 23
Classes begin today: one section of Rhodes College's celebrated great books course, The Search for Values in the Light of Western History and Religion, and two sections of a new course for me and (surprisingly) for Rhodes, Southern Politics. Today, as on subsequent Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays for the next 14 weeks, I'll begin at noon with Search and keep going until 2:50 with my other two classes. Over the years I've found that it's easier (not easy, but easier) to teach my classes back-to-back-to-back than to pump myself up for a class, come down afterward, and have to climb that motivational hill again before meeting the next one.
It is great to see the campus come alive with students after the summer. A good summer for me is like a good vacation—something I look forward to before it begins, enjoy while it is happening, and am ready to see end when the time comes to re-enter real life.
Like some of our students, I was the first person in my family to go to college. At some level I knew from an early age that I wanted to be a teacher, but for years I couldn't imagine being a college professor. To me, professors were like stock SciFi movie characters from planets with superior intelligence—they all had enormous bald heads to contain their outsized brains. I remember when Mr. Hoopes, the superintendent of schools in my hometown of New Milford, New Jersey, and a friend of my father's, became Dr. Hoopes. “To become a doctor,” my father told me, “he had to write a book about something that no one had ever written about.” What could possibly be left to write about if I ever tried to become a “doctor,” I wondered—the government of New Milford, New Jersey?
Once I got to college, I realized that although my professors were really smart, they were smart in ways that I could imagine myself becoming if I worked hard enough. Great mentors at William and Mary—Jack Edwards and George Grayson in the government department, Richard Maxwell Brown in the history department, and David Holmes in the religion department—gave me the enormous gift of their time, encouragement, and example. Years later, credentialed by Johns Hopkins and tenured by Vanderbilt, I went to Rhodes as a way of going back to the future—back, that is, to a liberal arts college in which close contact between professors and undergraduate students is the rule rather than the exception.
The first day of classes goes well. The students are just as bright-eyed and eager to return to the classroom as I am. We'll all be tired by midterm but not, I hope, tired of learning or of each other.
September 1
“I begin this talk with fear and trembling,” I tell the audience at the “Presidential Moments” panel organized for this year's APSA meeting in Philadelphia by Gary Gregg of the University of Louisville's McConnell Center. “Fear because the text of my talk, which I haven't looked at in weeks, is somewhere in the bowels of Northwest Airlines' lost-baggage bureaucracy. Trembling because I'm afraid some Transportation Security Administration officer will open my suitcase, read my title—‘The President Dies’—and not realize that it's William Henry Harrison I'm talking about.” No one thinks this is as witty an opening as I do, but I get enough courtesy chuckles to launch me into a talk improvised from memory.
It has been a good meeting so far, seeing old friends, meeting people previously known to me only by name, talking with publishers and seeing what new wares they have on display, walking around Philadelphia (tropical storm Ernesto isn't due until tomorrow), and making pilgrimages to Independence Hall and the National Constitution Center, each site spectacular in its own way.
Last night I had dinner with the search consultant who has been encouraging me to apply for a very appealing administrative position (a phrase I never thought I'd write) at a very appealing school. Young as he is, his experience in these matters greatly exceeds mine, including experience at putting nervous academics at ease. Our conversation went well, I think, and I tell him that if I'm invited for an airport interview (roughly comparable to making the Elite Eight in the NCAA basketball tournament, except that it's at an airport), I'll probably come. I will know something later this month and so, Dear Diary, will you.
September 6
I gratefully return the copy-edited version of How the South Joined the Gambling Nation: The Politics of State Policy Innovation to Louisiana State University Press—gratefully because the editor, Julia Smith, did such a fine and careful job. I took my time going through the edited manuscript, working hard to make it current, complete, clear, and felicitous. I want people to read this book with, among other things, pleasure.
Thinking, wrongly, that the copy editing portion of the day was over, I open my email just before going into class at noon and find a message from Alex Kafka, my editor at the Chronicle of Higher Education's Review section: “I think [your congressional elections article] could well go into our next issue if you can zap these line edits back to me ASAP. Doable?” Yes, I reply, if you can wait for me to teach three classes, pedal home on my bike to get the copy-edited version, pick it up, ride back (admittedly, only two blocks), review your edits, and respond to your queries. Go for it, Alex replies, and I do.
September 13
At the coach's invitation, I meet with the baseball team for pizza and conversation about how to succeed at Rhodes while playing a time-consuming varsity sport. For the past three years, I've been the team's faculty associate, a kind of informal academic adviser. I know all the seniors, juniors, and sophomores, so it's the freshmen I'm really talking to. “When you're on the field, you know exactly where you need to be when a ball is hit to the outfield or a runner breaks for second,” I tell them as prelude to giving a specific bit of advice. “It's the same in the classroom. Get in position to communicate that you're a serious student. Sit near the front or in the middle, don't be one of the boys in the back row. Maintain eye contact with the professor, don't stare out the window. Establish yourself in the professor's mind as someone who is there to learn.” Most of these young men are fine students, and most of my faculty colleagues will readily perceive them as such. But a few won't—they went to Division I schools as undergraduates or for graduate school and they're inclined to think of athletes as jocks first, students second. I want my guys to be so good that even their most doubtful professors will be impressed.
September 16
An invitation to an airport interview for the deanship arrives. Just as I'm about to fire an email of acceptance, my life Linda says, “Honey, we need to talk.” She tells me that as hard as she has been trying to embrace the possibility of moving to another school and another city, it just isn't happening. “We might be happy there,” she says, “but we know we're happy here.” She's right.
I've had colleagues who at this point would have (or at least claim they would have) pursued their candidacy anyway, in hopes of getting an offer that they could use for leverage at their home institution. I think too highly of the school where I teach, the school that has been wooing me, and, frankly, of myself to play that game. I email the search consultant to tell him that I'm withdrawing.
September 22
Great news: Ted Lowi has accepted my invitation to write the foreword to How the South Joined the Gambling Nation. Ted, whom I got to know during a visiting stint at Cornell in the early 1980s, is famously generous with his time and talent. But the quality that comes to mind first when I think of Ted is exuberance—about himself, about others, about ideas, about life. Look up exuberance in the dictionary: if it doesn't have a picture of Ted Lowi, get another dictionary.
September 30
I'm at Providence College to try to help the faculty review the school's Development of Western Civilization program—a four-semester, 20-credit course that all Providence students take as freshmen and sophomores. “Civ,” which is broadly similar to Rhodes's Search course, is taught by a multidisciplinary faculty drawn mostly from the humanities. The invitation to consult came from Bill Hudson who, like me, is an American politics guy who decided at mid career that he wanted to be part of his college's great books program. Bill is chairing Providence's review of the core curriculum.
I claim no special expertise in curriculum matters. I was invited to Providence because, around 10 years ago, when Rhodes was engaging in a similar process of self-scrutiny about the Search course, it occurred to me that finding out what kindred programs were like at other institutions might be helpful. We did not have to be like the teenager whose body is undergoing all sorts of wild transformations, thinking all the while that he's the only person in the world having this experience. The result of my ruminations was a 1998 conference at Rhodes that brought together scholars from a large numbers of colleges and universities, as well as a book, Alive at the Core: Exemplary Approaches to General Education, that recounted in detail the experience of 13 Search-style programs.
What I do at Providence, in a series of small and large meetings with faculty, students, and administrators, is practice comparative politics. Here's how other schools' programs cope with intrinsically difficult issues like breadth v. depth and finding the right mix of lectures and seminars, I tell them. Do any of these alternatives seem better than what you are doing now? If so, would they work at Providence, given its history, culture, faculty, and resources? I also borrow a page from George W. Bush's first-term playbook and encourage the faculty to ask for whatever resources they need to do Civ right. “Don't compromise with yourself,” I advise them, repeating Bush's line when he was pressed to reduce his proposed 2001 tax cuts at an early stage of the legislative process. Tell administrators what would be best, and let them decide if it's affordable.
October 16
I get the green light from our new provost, historian Charlotte Borst, to launch some initiatives I have proposed to further integrate athletics and academics at Rhodes. The challenge is a happy one: to take a good situation and help make it better. The first lecture in our new Sports and Society series, by New York Times reporter Warren St. John, drew a large and enthusiastic student audience a few nights ago. The Faculty Associates program now has the provost's clear imprimatur, which puts it in position to become even stronger than it already is. And, with full support from President Bill Troutt, I can now set the wheels in motion for Rhodes to host a Mellon Foundation-supported Integration Institute (integration, that is, of athletics and academics) next summer for colleges in our Division III Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference.
October 17
Midterm grades in and fall break begun, I'm off to West Point for a few days as a visiting lecturer at the United States Military Academy. Every yearling (sophomore) is required to take a core course in American politics in a class limited to 15 cadets, which means the academy must offer nearly 75 sections per year to accommodate each 1,100-cadet class. I'll speak to the American politics faculty (a reprise of my APSA talk, with notes this time) and to a number of classes. On Friday morning that will mean giving the same talk (this one about the Bush presidency) three consecutive times. It helps to think of stage actors who, although they perform the same play day after day, never forget that what's old to them is new to each audience.
Political science at West Point is folded into the department of social sciences. The pot at the end of the rainbow during my time here will be the department's tailgate party before Saturday's Army-TCU football game. The “Sosh” party has been rated one of the top dozen in the country by Sports Illustrated.
October 20
What a fine visit to West Point, thanks mostly to faculty members Ken Robbins, Brian Dietzman, and Chris Hornbarger, to the wonderful cadets with whom I spent time and to spectacular fall weather. Most of the teaching here is done by officers with graduate degrees who rotate through for three-year stints on the faculty. Chris, for example, already knows he's headed for Iraq at the end of the academic year. I vary my three consecutive talks on Bush as party leader by starting at a different point in my outline each time. That keeps me from getting bored—indeed, just the opposite as I'm forced to improvise new ways to reconnect the dots coherently. My not getting bored is a necessary although not sufficient condition for keeping the cadets from getting bored. And, yes, the Sosh tailgate party was just as good as advertised.
November 1
A noble experiment limps to an unsuccessful conclusion. Last night was the final installment of the five Tuesdays-long Politics Film Series at Rhodes, and the turnout was about average: three. I inaugurated the series this fall with funds from my Fulmer chair and assistance from one of my students, Matt Jack. Matt (especially) and I did everything right: we chose good movies, picked the best time to show them, publicized them well, and even provided free snacks. In the end we had to acknowledge that we were putting out a good product for which there was almost no demand. Rhodes students stay extremely busy with curricular and extracurricular activities, and when they do kick back it usually involves more than just watching an old movie like The Candidate or The Last Hurrah.
Working with Matt has reminded me of something my grad school mentor, Frank Rourke, told me years ago, when I was about to take a detour from my dissertation and spend a year working as an editor-writer for the Washington Monthly. Afraid that I might never come back, Frank said, “You know, Mike, one of the great joys of the academic life is that you're always in close contact with young people.” Being young myself at the time, this meant nothing to me. But through the years the wisdom of Frank's statement has become more and more apparent. Friendships like the one that Matt and I have developed despite the difference in our ages are rare, and all the more valuable for that.
November 8
“Hey, you looked good on television last night,” one of my Southern Politics students says as I enter the classroom. “I don't know,” says another, “you kind of looked like you didn't know what to do with your hands.” Others merrily offer their own critiques of how I looked during the local NBC station's Election Night telecast. Not a word is spoken about anything I actually said. Television is such a visual medium.
We spend the hour discussing the results, nationally (a big win for the Democrats), regionally (a not-so-big win for Southern Democrats), and in the Tennessee Senate race (a win for the Republicans). Three of my students worked virtually full time for either Democratic Senate nominee Harold Ford or his Republican opponent Bob Corker. Toward the end of class I ask the three—deferentially, as to those who know from experience what the rest of us know only by observation—to pass along something they had learned during their time in the political trenches. Each of them speaks about the joys and frustrations of political life with the weariness of the sadder but wiser veteran. They do so in ways that, for the moment at least, unite them as budding professionals more than divide them as opposing partisans.
November 13
A weeklong blizzard of advising appointments (students are registering for the spring semester), search committee meetings (we're hiring to fill two tenure-track positions), and paper grading (don't ask). In the midst of all this, I'm writing the chapter on the Ford-Corker Senate election for Larry Sabato's post-midterm book, The Sixth-Year Itch: The Elections of 2006. It's interesting: I spent the whole campaign wondering whether Ford or Corker would win and, now that the outcome is known, am writing an essay explaining why Corker's victory was inevitable. As a colleague once told me, “We political scientists are really good at predicting things that have already happened.”
Today is Monday—with any luck, I will have a draft of the chapter by Thursday afternoon. On Friday I'll drive down to the Clinton Presidential Library in Little Rock for a two-day conference on the midterm elections co-sponsored by the State Legislative Leaders Foundation and the Clinton School of Public Service. With more luck, I'll pick up a few things at the conference that I can plug into the final draft.
November 14
The two positions my department is filling are in urban politics and classical political philosophy. It is no disrespect to the pool of urban applicants to say that the philosophy pool is extraordinarily strong. In my 25 years of reviewing applicant files, it has been ever thus, reflecting the chronic mismatch between the number of brilliant people doing political philosophy and the number of teaching positions that are available for them. Years ago at Vanderbilt, I once blurted out at a department meeting in which we were deciding whom to interview for a junior philosophy position, “My God, any one of the top 20 people in this pool would be the smartest person in the room if they came here.” A dark silence greeted this remark. But nobody said I was wrong.
November 16
Got that chapter drafted a day earlier than I'd hoped. Luck? Luck had nothing to do with it.
Author Bio
Michael Nelson is the Fulmer Professor of Political Science at Rhodes College. Later this year, Louisiana State University Press will publish How the South Joined the Gambling Nation: The Politics of State Policy Innovation and CQ Press will publish the fourth edition of The American Presidency: Origins and Development, 1776–2007. This article is the third of a four-part series.
