Being a feminist, which by my definition is simply a woman who respects herself both in thought and in action, I often find myself using theatre as a way to talk about the masculinities of the society in which I live—in which we all live. And I've always used theatre as a means of externalizing experience, and of having the temerity and humility to ask a group of strangers to become a collective of responsive citizens bearing witness to experiences that are expressions of our shared humanity. I consider this to be a feminine and a feminist definition of theatre's agency.
Rosemary Malague's An Actress Prepares: Women and “the Method” has therefore gotten me very excited. In acknowledging everything that can go wrong in the process of bringing women (and men) to the stage, she reminds us of everything that can also go right with this process. I recognize my life—our lives—as students and practitioners and teachers of theatre in her critical volume.
As James Baldwin famously said, life is more important than art, and that's what makes art important. Things happen in every artist's life that tango and conflate with her art.
When I was having one of many surgical biopsies that finally got me diagnosed with Hodgkin's lymphoma, I ended up in the care of an arrogant young ENT surgeon who wore tight-fitting, expensive tweed pants and led his interactions with patients with his sexual side. (I had long since noticed that part of the power dynamic in the doctor–patient relationship is shaped by the fact that the doctor is always dressed, and the patient is stripped of clothing and feels her nakedness under a gown of some flimsy sort.) He took out the roof of my mouth to get at a tumor he could have reached through other means, though I begged him not to, as I am a teacher and an actor. In a scene that might have been ripped from Gone with the Wind, he put his arms around me and told me to just trust him.
I needed to, and did, write a play that dealt with the brutal masculinities of the medical establishment: Bringing the Fishermen Home. The protagonist, a female professor, gets caught up in a sexualized net of interactions with medicine men, now slick, now awkward; all lack a compassionate vision of her as a human spirit struggling for answers and for her life. In one scene, a dream scene under the influence of anesthesia, the protagonist finds herself out on a romantic date with her sexy, Big Daddy surgeon at a very refined and expensive French restaurant. He is dressed in a tux and tails; she is completely naked.
I usually play my protagonists myself, but, honestly, I did not want to show my breasts to my friends at the small theatre that had commissioned the play. Instead, I hired a beautiful, responsible, gifted actress to play the role; she was nervous about the nudity, but she agreed to it, understanding that its purpose was far from prurient and was designed to highlight a painful power dynamic.
The play went into rehearsal and was coming along tremblingly, tenderly.
Then, the night before we opened, there was a delay getting into the theatre to rehearse, and the director, actors, and I met outside an alternative location. As we were getting ready to file in for a run-through, a man rode up on his bicycle and said he was our lead actress's husband. He told us her mother was dying, and that she would not be able to perform that weekend because she needed to fly to her mother in hospital.
We were all stunned, and wished her our condolences; we thanked the man on the bicycle, and he rode away. The director sent everyone else into the rehearsal room, and he and I sat together on a bench outside in silence for ten minutes. Then he said:
“Well: you're on!”
Rosemary Malague: you have illuminated everything!
Indeed, I did go on. The director felt sure that, since I wrote this play, I knew exactly how to perform it, which is one of the many myths about self-scripting. Just because one writes something doesn't mean one has any idea how to act/embody/perform it; in fact, sometimes, having written a script creates ever deeper layers of protective material between the writer and the actor when she is one and the same person.
Getting into the rehearsal room, we faced the process of telling everyone that I would, for that weekend, replace our leading actress. The actor playing the main doctor/Messiah/rapist/destroyer of the protagonist's voice, an experienced and trained artist with his own masculine ascendancy, said:
“Oh my God, that's like a nnn … dream!”
It did not escape my notice that the idea of sexualized contact with me onstage struck this man as a nightmare. I am not a sexy, beautiful blonde, as was our bereaved leading actress.
But I am a Method actor, among other things. I remembered what it was like to be treated in this way by this surgeon, and I brought all of that to this sudden weekend of command performances. The actor who had called it a nightmare, my scene partner, said he had never worked with anyone who behaved with such incendiary feeling in a scene, and he horrified me by “overacting” in one of our intimate moments onstage.
As I look back on this experience through the lens of An Actress Prepares, I realize that the book has elegantly delineated for me some of the difficulties that necessarily come with what is so very personal about training for and acting in the theatre, as a woman. I had written a play about a woman suffering the vulnerabilities of the body in the presence of men, and now I had to enact that very vulnerability in a theatre of men that echoed and upheld this very same vulnerability. Reading Malague's book, and thinking through it about my experience performing in my play, made clear for me several things.
First, that we need to separate the Method from the madness of its purveyors. Method acting, as variously defined by Strasberg, Meisner, Adler, and Hagen, is actually very helpful! The ability to find emotion within one's body/mind and employ it in service of a playwright's fictional landscape is an essential, and learnable, skill. We—artists and academics—need to continue to take Method seriously, as this book resolutely does.
Second, that the theatre remains, of necessity, a site of utmost vigilance for women actors, directors, and teachers, as they/we give and receive direction, both in the classroom/studio and in the theatre. Sexism is still acceptable, and sometimes seems ineluctable, in these spaces. We still look differently at women onstage; we still expect certain shades of beauty, a certain availability, from a woman onstage; and we still call upon women performers sexually in ways we do not call upon men.
Finally, that our consciousness of, and solid vigilance around, these potential dangers can revitalize the Method, guarding its most useful strategies against misuse, and generating an environment in which all of us, men and women equally, may discover our different truths onstage.
As a historical document, An Actress Prepares does a great service to women's studies, placing Stanislavsky's preeminent American inheritors within a feminist context. For me, as a teacher and practitioner of methods—plural—in the theatre, Malague's careful study reminds me how important is the ethical framework within which a craft as deeply personal, as profoundly revealing, as that of acting must be handed from one practitioner to another.
