This edited volume is an excellent contribution to literature on the harem for its inclusion of scholars committed to approach the subject from different angles and disciplines over the longue durée. It broadens our understanding of the topic through an interdisciplinary conversation. With these merits, the book puts itself in the select company of other works in the field, such as Leslie Peirce's The Imperial Harem, Women and Sovereignty in the Ottoman Empire (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993), Reina Lewis’ Rethinking Orientalism: Women, Travel, and the Ottoman Harem (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 2004) and Mary Roberts’ Intimate Outsiders: The Harem in Ottoman and Orientalist Art and Travel Literature (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 2007). Marilyn Booth's signal achievement is her conceptual insight in skillfully integrating essays that deal with harem and domestic space from the 9th to the 20th centuries based on a variety of historical materials ranging from archival documents and architecture to visual and literary representations.
The book's title, Harem Histories, perfectly summarizes the basic goal behind the compilation: the essays show that there is no fixed meaning and singular history of “the harem” but rather “histories” of a “geographically and socially variable concept, which helps us to understand broader notions of gendered space in Muslim-majority cultures” (p. 4). Booth's introduction and many essays in the collection emphasize the importance of thinking about space as constitutive of gender identities and boundaries. In this conceptual framework, “harem” at times refers to a social institution or architectural arrangement of domestic life along gender lines while at other times to literary or visual representations of Western imagination as well as the self-representation of Muslim-majority societies. Furthermore, this collection of essays goes beyond dwelling on mere Orientalist notions of the harem as exotic, sexual constructs toward revealing how the harem was in fact a dynamic arena in which “West” and “East” or “indigenous” and “foreign” representations competed in disparate genres and formats ranging from historical novels and photographs to socialization.
Despite the volume's commitment to making theoretical contributions whilst engaging the existing body of literature on harem studies, the division of these essays into three subsections based on chronology rather than thematic concerns detracts from the book's overall goals and utility. As Booth admits, “the book's divisions are to some extent artificial, as all chapters range across methodologies, source material, and focuses” (p. 11). Indeed, the conceptual framework Booth proposes in the introduction would have made for a much better organization of the book. For example, Asma Afsaruddin's essay in the first section (“Normative Images and Shifting Spaces”), which compares the construction of gendered space in Abbasid and Mamluk textual representations of the female companions of the Prophet, would have fit perfectly in the second section alongside Heghnar Zeitlian Watenpaugh's chapter addressing representations of a 19th-century poetess in a biography written in Aleppo in 1995 (“Rooms and Thresholds: Harems as Spaces, Socialities, and Law”). Similarly, İrvin Cemil Schick's essay might have served well as an introductory chapter due to its methodological and conceptual discussion of the harem as a gender construct and space as constitutive of gender. Nevertheless, the success of the book as a whole overshadows these organizational caveats, especially when one considers the difficulty of bringing together such distinguished essays whose themes intertwine in multiple ways.
The first section of the volume, “Normative Images and Shifting Spaces,” is composed of three essays that address normative representations of the harem in the Islamic context. Afsaruddin's essay, “Early Women Exemplars and the Construction of Gendered Space,” can be distinguished from the other two because it engages more deeply with historical sources. By analyzing Islamic biographical texts, the essay shows how biographical representation of the same early women exemplars varied in the Abbasid and Mamluk eras due to different gender conceptions regarding the seclusion of women. In contrast, Yaseen Noorani in his “Normative Notions of Public and Private in Early Islamic Culture” and Schick in “The Harem as Gendered Space and the Spatial Reproduction of Gender” start with theoretical questions and use the harem as explanatory tools for their arguments. The interesting discussion that both authors have brought to the surface is the adaptability of the Western division of public and private to the Islamic context. Both authors rightfully criticize the use of this division to explain the gendered segregation of space in Islamic normative discourse and practice. Furthermore, Schick points out that many Western scholars argue that “it is Western ideas of private and public that need revision” (p. 77). Yet, despite Noorani's brilliant and nuanced analysis of Classical Arabic adab literature, his comparison of the Habermasian notion of the 19th-century bourgeois public/private dichotomy with social spheres described in Islamic literature from the 8th through 10th centuries leaves the reader unconvinced, while he admits that the former conceptual framework does not fit the latter.
The second section of the volume, “Rooms and Thresholds: Harems as Spaces, Socialities, and Law,” collects five essays that deal with the harem more as a space and institution. Together, the essays reveal that “harem culture,” to borrow Leslie Peirce's term and apply it to either imperial or household harems, were political institutions in the sense that multiple actors within them exercised “power” along the lines of gender hierarchies and the domestic imagination. Nadia Maria El-Cheikh (“Caliphal Harems, Household Harems”) and Jateen Lad (“Panoptic Bodies”) show how caliphal and imperial harems in Abbasid Baghdad and the imperial Ottoman harem, respectively, were arenas in which court women and eunuchs participated in the politics of courtly hierarchies. Similarly, Julia Clancy-Smith (“Where Elites Meet”) emphasizes the political character of the harem by addressing the diplomatic character of the intimate encounters of European and Tunisian families in sea-bathing scenes in precolonial Tunisia.
Another common theme of this section, spaces and thresholds, is well represented in the arguments of Leslie Peirce and Jateen Lad. In a skillful and nuanced way, Peirce shows in “Domesticating Sexuality” how the expansion of imperial territory during the reigns of four Ottoman sultans (Mehmed II, Bayezid II, Selim I, and Süleyman I) of the 15th and 16th centuries broadened spatial imagination regarding the domestic order while erecting well-defined thresholds between illicit sex and “respectable” harem culture through imperial legal regulations. Lad's essay persuasively argues that the harem was not “a space defined exclusively by gender or sexuality” (p. 138) but rather by forbiddances and inviolability. Carefully analyzing architectural evidence, Lad points out that black eunuchs administered the thresholds of power by controlling and guarding the harem's seclusion and hierarchies, though she describes the phenomenon a bit anachronistically by defining the black eunuchs as Foucaultian “panoptical bodies” of disciplinary power. It is anachronistic because Foucault used the metaphor of panopticon to refer to modern disciplinary techniques, and black eunuchs did not have such “disciplinary” power over harem members. Watenpaugh's interesting and compelling article, “The Harem as Biography,” somewhat fits into this section with its discussion of a nostalgic construction of space in the reproduction of the “old courtyard house” in late 20th-century Syria. Yet, her intelligent paper deserves to be treated within a discussion of the imagery and representations of the harem as well because it deals with the contemporary rewriting of the biography of a famous and radical 19th-century Aleppine poetess as the hostess and domesticated figure of this imagined courtyard house.
This leads to the third and final cluster of essays, “Harems Envisioned,” which analyze “harems” in visual and literary representations of Orientalists and in the work of local artists in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The essays in this section utilize the trope of “encounter” in postcolonial theory: the encounter between the indigenous and the foreign, the imaginary and the real, and the domestic and the street. Both Orit Bashkin's article (“Harem, Women, and Political Tyranny in the Works of Jurji Zaydan”), highlighting the self-Orientalist notion of harem in the works of Jurji Zaydan, a 19th-century Egyptian novelist, and Joan DelPlato's analysis (“Dress and Undress”) of the Orientalist construction of the eroticized Eastern female Other in the pictures of four 19th-century artists demonstrate very skillfully that the borders between indigenous and Western as well as between authentic and constructed are blurred in these artistic representations. The use of the Orientalist image of the harem, borrowed from the West, in Zaydan's novels to fight against the despotism of the Ottoman ruler, or the “inter-textuality” of images and literary texts in the pictures that DelPlato analyzes resist such binaries by revealing the encounters between the West and the East and the image and the text. In “Between Harem and Houseboat,” Booth also shows how the gendered social space of the new Egyptian nationalist modernity of the 1920s was represented in female memoirs in their construction of a binary between the home (harem) and the street (house of the prostitutes). Similarly, A. Holly Shissler's article (“The Harem as the Seat of Middle-Class Industry and Morality”) shows how a modern notion of the harem as the house of “private virtue”—a guarantee of social solidarity and a new model of morality—was constructed in the fictional work of Ahmed Midhat Efendi, a modernist Ottoman intellectual. However, Shissler unfortunately stops at the point where further analysis would have engaged the feminist reader. The gender analysis of a new bourgeois conservatism that is absent in Shissler's piece is well addressed in Booth's work, as she depicts the restrictive nature of such an ideal space for women. Finally, Nancy Micklewright's essay (“Harem/House/Set”) comparing photographs of the Ottoman harem and domestic life taken by European and Ottoman photographers between 1858 and 1913 also deals with notions of imaginary and actual harems. Yet, the article pays little attention to the fact that the domestic interiors of Ottoman families, which were identified as “real” by the author, were in fact “imagined” in the sense that they also “mimicked” the European domestic style.
Booth has performed a great service in collecting the recent articles of leading scholars working on the harem and on domesticity in the Middle Eastern context. By bringing together conceptually and empirically oriented works encompassing disparate historical eras in such a concise book, Booth has made a major contribution to the study of both gender and history. The interdisciplinary approach of the volume challenges the old-fashioned yet still widely used Orientalist image of the “harem” and replaces it with multifaceted “harem histories” shaped by different gender bodies in varied geographical, architectural, and representational spaces. The book will serve as a cornerstone for harem studies and will be read for years to come by scholars working on space, the body, and gender in Middle Eastern and world history.
