Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T12:45:15.447Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Wing sweep effects on laminar separated flows

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 October 2022

Jean Hélder Marques Ribeiro*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA
Chi-An Yeh
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USADepartment of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC 27695, USA
Kai Zhang
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ 08854, USA
Kunihiko Taira
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: jeanmarques@g.ucla.edu

Abstract

We reveal the effects of sweep on the wake dynamics around NACA 0015 wings at high angles of attack using direct numerical simulations and resolvent analysis. The influence of sweep on the wake dynamics is considered for sweep angles from $0^\circ$ to $45^\circ$ and angles of attack from $16^\circ$ to $30^\circ$ for a spanwise periodic wing at a chord-based Reynolds number of $400$ and a Mach number of $0.1$. Wing sweep affects the wake dynamics, especially in terms of stability and spanwise fluctuations with implications on the development of three-dimensional (3-D) wakes. We observe that wing sweep attenuates spanwise fluctuations. Even as the sweep angle influences the wake, force and pressure coefficients can be collapsed for low angles of attack when examined in wall-normal and wingspan-normal independent flow components. Some small deviations at high sweep and incidence angles are attributed to vortical wake structures that impose secondary aerodynamic loads, revealed through the force element analysis. Furthermore, we conduct global resolvent analysis to uncover oblique modes with high disturbance amplification. The resolvent analysis also reveals the presence of wavemakers in the shear-dominated region associated with the emergence of 3-D wakes at high angles of attack. For flows at high sweep angles, the optimal convection speed of the response modes is shown to be faster than the optimal wavemakers speed suggesting a mechanism for the attenuation of perturbations. The present findings serve as a fundamental stepping stone to understanding separated flows at higher Reynolds numbers.

JFM classification

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.The problem set-up. Instantaneous flow over a spanwise periodic NACA 0015 profile at $\alpha = 30^\circ$ and sweep angle $\varLambda = 15^\circ$ visualized with isosurfaces of $Q$ criterion coloured by streamwise velocity $u_x$. A 2-D slice of airfoil in coordinate systems ($x,y,z$) and ($x',y,z'$), with $x'$ and $z'$ perpendicular and parallel to the wingspan, respectively. Here DNS and resolvent grids are shown as grey lines in the background.

Figure 1

Table 1.Time-averaged lift and drag coefficients ($\overline {C_L}$ and $\overline {C_D}$) compared with Zhang et al. (2020a) for laminar separated flow over NACA 0015 airfoils with $\alpha = 20^\circ$, $\varLambda = 0^\circ$, $15^\circ$, $30^\circ$ and $45^\circ$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Instantaneous flow field visualization with isosurfaces of $Q$ criterion coloured by the vorticity component $\omega _z$. For $\alpha \ge 26^\circ$, the wake is 3-D. As $\varLambda$ increases, the vortices become slanted with the sweep angle and wake three-dimensionality is reduced for $\alpha \ge 26^\circ$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Time-averaged flow field visualization with $z$-velocity component, $\bar {u}_z \in [0,0.5]$, in greyscale, for $0^\circ \le \varLambda \le 45^\circ$ and $\alpha = 16^\circ$ and $30^\circ$. Red solid contours mark the laminar separation bubble, with six equally distributed isolines of $x$-velocity component, $\bar {u}_x \in [0,0.5]$. Cross-flow component $\bar {u}_z$ strengthens with $\alpha$ and $\varLambda$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Time-averaged lift, $\overline {C_L}$, drag, $\overline {C_D}$ and coefficient ratio $\overline {C_L / C_D}$, for all $\alpha, \varLambda$ pair of the present study compared with 2-D incompressible results shown by Zhang et al. (2020b). Panels (d–f) show the scaled time-averaged coefficients where the flow is analysed in ($x',y,z'$), and the results collapse for each $\alpha$, for all sweep angles.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Scaled lift power spectrum density (PSD) for (a,c) $\alpha = 16^\circ$ and (b,d) $\alpha = 30^\circ$ at sweep angles $\varLambda = 0^\circ$, $30^\circ$ and $45^\circ$. In (c,d) the Fage–Johansen Strouhal number is analysed in the $(x',y)$ plane and the dominant and harmonic frequencies for swept wings collapse with the unswept wings.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Time-averaged pressure coefficients (a,b) $C_p$ and (c,d) $C_p/\cos ^2 \varLambda$ over the airfoil surface at (a,c) $\alpha = 16^\circ$ and (b,d) $30^\circ$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Characterization of force elements on swept wings. The symbols refer to $\boldsymbol {\circ }$ (yellow), force elements only near the leading and trailing edges; $\boldsymbol {\square }$ (blue), additional equally spaced small lift elements; and $\boldsymbol {\triangle }$ (red), large force structures observed on the suction side. On the right-hand side, we show isosurfaces of lift force elements, $(\boldsymbol {\omega } \times \boldsymbol {u}) \boldsymbol {\cdot } \boldsymbol {\nabla } \phi _L \in [-0.3,0.3]$ and isosurfaces of $Q$ values coloured by streamwise velocity component $\bar {u}_x$ with range $[0,1]$ for the time step with the highest lift coefficient $C_L^\prime$ for $\alpha = 30^\circ$ and $15^\circ \le \varLambda \le 45^\circ$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.(a) Forcing (red boxes) and (b) response (blue boxes) contours for the $|u_x| / \|u_x\|_\infty \in [0.1,1]$ in blue–green–red scale at the largest $\sigma _1$ with $k_{z^\prime } = 0$ at $\varLambda = 0^\circ$ and $45^\circ$. Forcing modes extend in the wake and response modes become closer to the airfoil in swept wings. Isosurfaces of dominant resolvent gain $\sigma _1$ in the $\varLambda$–$St^\prime$–$k_{z^\prime }$ space for $\alpha = 16^\circ$ to $30^\circ$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.The leading resolvent gain contours at $\alpha = 20^\circ$ and $30^\circ$ for $0^\circ \le \varLambda \le 45^\circ$. The dash–dotted slopes represent spanwise convection speeds. The green line exhibits the convection speed prediction with $0.25 U_\infty \tan \varLambda$.

Figure 10

Table 2.The maximum leading resolvent gain ${max}(\sigma _1)$ for each $\alpha,\varLambda$ pair. In the inset figure, we plot ${max}(\sigma _1)$ in $St^\prime$–$k_{z^\prime }$ space coloured in blue scale with respect to the minimum and maximum $\sigma _1$ for each $\alpha$.

Figure 11

Figure 10.(a,c) Forcing ($\,\hat {f}$, red boxes) and (b,d) response ($\hat {q}$, blue boxes) modes isosurfaces with $y$-velocity components $\hat {u}_y / \| \hat {u}_y \|_\infty \in \pm 0.2$ in red–blue colour scale for $\alpha = 20^\circ$ and $\varLambda = 45^\circ$. Wingspan length is $10 L_c$. Forcing and response modes are associated with the largest resolvent gain for each $k_{z^\prime }$ as shown in the $\sigma _1$ contours over $St^\prime$–$k_{z^\prime }$ plane.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Contours of $\xi = (\sigma _1 / {max}(\sigma _1)) \langle \hat {q}_i, \hat {f}_i \rangle$, the inner product between forcing and response modes, scaled by the ratio of $\sigma _1$ and the maximum $\sigma _1$ for each $\alpha$. Green line shows the convection speed $c = \text {d} \omega / \text {d} k_{z^\prime }$ for the optimal wavemakers. Spatial modes shown by the Hadamard product of $\hat {q}_i$ and $\hat {f}_i$, in magnitude, normalized by their maximum value, and coloured in purple scale.

Figure 13

Table 3.Convective speed $c = \text {d} \omega / \text {d} k_{z^\prime }$ for the optimal response and the optimal wavemakers for the 3-D flows at $\alpha = 26^\circ$ and $30^\circ$ and sweep angles $0^\circ \le \varLambda \le 45^\circ$.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Dominant eigenvalues of $\boldsymbol{\mathsf{L}}_{\bar {\boldsymbol {q}}}$ for (a) $\alpha = 16^\circ$, (b) $20^\circ$, (c) $26^\circ$ and (d) $30^\circ$, for different sweep angles $\varLambda$, and spanwise wavenumbers $k_{z^\prime }$. Here $St_r^\prime$ and $St_i^\prime$ are the $St^\prime$ numbers for growth rate and temporal frequency, respectively. Black solid lines connect the eigenvalues for the same $k_{z^\prime }$.