I. INTRODUCTION
In England in the 1840s, politicians and political economists hotly debated the future of Ireland. Poor and unproductive, Ireland had recently suffered a devastating potato famine. Nearly everyone agreed that something should be done. Yet, what should be done was not at all clear. The debate coalesced around a handful of issues, perhaps none more important or controversial than that of the ownership and cultivation of land. The debate over land—the so-called Irish Land Question—attracted the most influential thinkers in England, not least of whom was John Stuart Mill.
A myriad of works examine the debate and Mill’s engagement in it. One can find discussions about Ireland’s condition in the mid- to late nineteenth century (e.g., Kinzer Reference Kinzer2001; Gray Reference Gray1995; Collison Black Reference Black and Robert1968); descriptions of the changes that Mill’s proposals for Ireland underwent during more than two decades of involvement in the debate (e.g., Steele Reference Steele1970a and Reference Steele1970b; Kinzer Reference Kinzer2001); studies on the importance of Mill’s concerns with internal and external politics for understanding some of these changes (e.g., Kinzer Reference Kinzer, Robson and Kinzer1988; Steel Reference Steele1970a and Reference Steele1970b); and detailed examinations of the reaction in England and Ireland to Mill’s agenda for Ireland (e.g., Kinzer Reference Kinzer2001) and of the position assumed by other political economists and politicians on the issues of the debate (e.g., Collison Black Reference Black and Robert1953; Kinzer Reference Kinzer2001; Kawana Reference Kawana2010); alongside many other topics concerning Mill’s engagements with the neighboring country.
The present paper analyzes Mill’s position in the Irish Land debate from a somewhat different perspective: from the viewpoint of his conceptions of the role to be fulfilled by social institutions. As argued in Mattos (Reference Mattos2000), Mill believed that, to be adequate, social institutions should promote progress without undermining the elements that hold society together.Footnote 1 In the case of economic institutions, to promote progress meant, essentially, to increase economic efficiency, to augment social justice, and, above all, to further human betterment.Footnote 2
I argue that Mill’s position in the Irish Land debate emerged from his views on how well the three institutional arrangements under discussion—the cottier system, the “English model” of capitalist agriculture, and peasant proprietorship—performed according to these criteria. From this viewpoint, we can understand Mill’s rejection of the cottier system and of adopting in Ireland the “English model” of capitalist agriculture. These institutional forms he considered to be unsuited to Irish cultural, economic, and political reality, and, for this reason, he deemed them incapable of promoting progress (in its three dimensions) and maintaining social order.
The cottier system, in Mill’s view, posed three problems. One, it promoted laziness, disregard for the future, and other negative traits in the Irish; two, it led to low agricultural productivity; and, three, it fomented intense feelings of revolt and injustice in the population that threatened to reach a disruptive level. Thus, the system, he argued, should be replaced by a better land arrangement.
Mill also rejected the alternative of consolidating land and establishing the “English model” on a large scale in Ireland. He recognized that, although this arrangement could solve the economic problem by raising agricultural productivity, it would not, in his evaluation, regenerate the Irish character; moreover, it would increase the level of injustice and aggravate the social and political problem and possibly disrupt social order.
I argue that Mill’s position in the Land debate shed light on his passionate defense of peasant proprietorship. Given the moral and intellectual development of the Irish people, the economic and social characteristics, and the prevalent notions of justice in this country, adopting peasant property seemed the surest way to maintain social order and promote progress in all the relevant dimensions. Mill believed that the introduction of this institution would better Irish character, augment agricultural productivity, promote social fairness, and diminish existing social and political tensions. In short, he defended peasant property because it would be more suitable than other systems to Ireland’s reality and would solve the main problems faced by the country.
My approach here sheds light not only on Mill’s stand concerning land ownership in Ireland but also on his broader views on social change. The Irish case illustrates the criteria Mill used to evaluate and compare alternative economic institutions; the elements he took into account when dealing with their reform; and his view that nations with different histories, cultures, and levels of moral, political, social and economic developments require different institutions in order to progress. In this sense, the investigation of this aspect of Mill’s thought can illuminate his more general conceptions on the possibility and limits of institutional reform—be it in Ireland, England, or elsewhere.
II. A GENERAL BACKGROUND: THE IRISH CONTEXT WHEN MILL ENGAGED IN THE DEBATE
Before the Norman Conquest, land in Ireland was not privately owned in the modern sense. Rather, people established rights to land based on status and customs: “the land virtually belonged to the entire sept; the chief was little more than the managing member of the association” (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 513). Under English rule, the lands were confiscated and a system of private ownership of land similar to that in England replaced the pre-existing informal arrangements based on status and customs. From the beginning of the eighteenth century onwards, Ireland’s land was basically owned, from generation to generation, by landlords, mostly foreigners (English and Scottish) who were almost all Protestants, and who showed little interest in improving the soil (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 513).
By the beginning of the nineteenth century, despite the ostensible similarities between the Irish and the English land laws, very different results followed from their operation (Collison Black Reference Black and Robert1968). The combination of “subdivisions, sub-letting, tenancy at will, and absentee landlords had produced a situation in Ireland which was patently different from that in England” (Collison Black Reference Black and Robert1968, p. 323)—the cottier system. And it was this system that prevailed in the 1840s, when Mill engaged in the debate.
In this system, the landowner, who often resided somewhere other than Ireland (or in urban areas in Ireland) and had little connection to the land, rented his land directly to the person who cultivated it; there was no capitalist farmer in the middle. The rent was determined by competition, with no moderating influence of custom (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 313).Footnote 3 As indicated by Robert Collison Black (Reference Black and Robert1953, p. 28) and Eileen Sullivan (Reference Sullivan1983, p. 616), in the context of high population growth and in the absence of other forms of economic occupations, this kind of arrangement led to an intense competition for land. Since most people had no real choice other than to farm, they bid up the rent for land (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, pp. 515–516). The extremely high rents were incompatible with land productivity, and the tenants frequently could not pay the agreed rent. Additionally, the land was frequently lent without a formal contract and the landlord had the power (even when rent was adequately paid) to evict the tenant at short notice and lease the land to others. The tenants were not compensated even for the investments they eventually had made in the land.
Thus, under this institutional arrangement tenants were not protected by custom or by law. They were at the mercy of the landlords, without any guarantee to the soil. “In Ireland alone,” Mill writes,
the whole agricultural population can be evicted by mere will of the landlord, either at the expiration of a lease, or, in the far commoner case of their having no lease, at six months’ notice…. So long as they remain in the country of their birth, their support must be drawn from a source for the permanence of which they have no guarantee. (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 515)
This situation gave rise to conflicts over land and to secret agrarian societies that aimed at protecting the rights of tenants. The members of these societies intimidated and even murdered landowners who did not behave according to their code of justice, causing fear and hatred among the landlords (Gray Reference Gray1995, pp. 24–25). These agrarian conflicts also nourished several movements during the nineteenth century that advocated the end of Ireland’s union with England. As will be seen, Mill was especially worried about the rising Fenian separatist movement in the 1860s, which had strong popular support in Ireland.
The Land debate in Ireland gained force in the mid-1840s, when the country suffered successive severe potato crop failures due to a fungus infection. With the potato blight, the number of tenants who could not pay their rents and were evicted multiplied. Whole families of evicted tenants died along roads with nowhere to go (Gray Reference Gray1995, pp. 68–73). The famine that followed had no parallel in modern Europe. Between 1845 and 1850 more than one million people died of starvation or of diseases related to extreme poverty and malnutrition (Gray Reference Gray1995, p. 94) and more than two million Irishmen left the country (Kinzer Reference Kinzer2001, p. 89).Footnote 4
Although land problems did not start with the Irish famine, the famine made the Land question the order of the day, and attracted J. S. Mill to the debate.
This theme was central to the relations between England and Ireland in the second half of the nineteenth century, and the land conflicts led to the Irish Land Acts of 1870 and 1881, which gave many guarantees to the tenants and tipped the balance to their side. Mill saw the social chaos occasioned by the famine as an opportunity to make profound and lasting changes in Ireland’s social structure. In the winter of 1846–47 he wrote, in the course of six months, forty-three articles for the Morning Chronicles on the Irish condition (Mill [1873] Reference Mill, Robson and Stillinger1981, p. 242), pressing for changes in the landed property of the country and defending the creation of a class of peasant proprietors. But this was just the first round of Mill’s engagement in the debate. In all editions of the Principles of Political Economy, he discussed at length the negative impacts of the cottier system and the virtues of peasant property—revealing that his interest in the subject never ended (although it varied in intensity). At the end of the 1860s, under the impact of the Fenian movement, Ireland again became the center of Mill’s concerns. As a member of Parliament, he tried to influence England’s policies in relation to Ireland, always emphasizing the importance of land reform that protected those who tilled the soil against the interests of the landlords. In 1868, he published England and Ireland, in which he took a radical stand and defended tenant rights more firmly. This influential piece found more admirers in Ireland than in England, and was the climax of his involvement in the debate.
This paper will not analyze the changes that occurred in the specific policies Mill defended for Ireland during the more than twenty years in which he took part in the debate.Footnote 5 Instead, it emphasizes the comparative analysis he presents of the effects of the different institutional arrangements that were under discussion: the cottier system, the “English model” of capitalist agriculture, and peasant property.
III. MILL’S EVALUATION OF THE COTTIER SYSTEM
Mill’s diagnosis of the cottier system in Ireland could not be worse. In his view, the system was responsible for the moral backwardness of the people, for the low productivity of agriculture, and for the feelings of resentment and injustice that prevailed among the agrarian population and endangered social order.
Regarding the moral state of the Irish people, there was a consensus at the time that the Irish character (that is, the character of the Irish peasantry) was defective, and was the origin of several other evils.Footnote 6 There was, however, an important divide about the causes underlying this national character. At one side of this divide was a well-established tradition of philosophers and political economists who adopted an environmentalist approach: that is, attributed the ‘dark side’ of the Irish character to historical and institutional causes (Romani Reference Romani1997; Kawana Reference Kawana2010). At the other side, there were racist interpretations—which increasingly gained strength and influence on the political debates concerning Ireland—that ascribed these moral defects to a natural, inherent inferiority of the Irish people (Peart and Levy Reference Peart and Levy2005; Horshman 1976; Romani Reference Romani1997).Footnote 7
For his part, Mill emphatically repudiated the idea that some people were naturally inferior to others, and considered the existing tendency to regard the marked differences in human character as innate and indelible as “one of the chief hindrances to the rational treatment of great social questions” (Mill [1873] Reference Mill, Robson and Stillinger1981, p. 270).Footnote 8 Mill believed this erroneous view resulted from ignorance concerning the laws of formation of character (Mill [1850] Reference Mill and Robson1984, p. 93; and [1869] Reference Mill and Robson1984, p. 277). Accordingly, he opposed the views that regarded the existing negative traits of the Irish people as natural (thus, unchangeable) characteristics of the Celtic race.Footnote 9 Mill affirmed: “Of all vulgar modes of escaping from the consideration of the effect of social and moral influences on the human mind, the most vulgar is that of attributing the diversities of conduct and character to inherent natural differences” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 319). Consistent with his understanding of character formation, which attributed great weight to institutions and social relations in molding the characteristics of a people (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 955), Mill embraced an environmentalist interpretation of the Irish character. He related several of the existing negative traits and behaviors of the people to the operation of one specific institution: the cottier system.
The cottier system seemed to Mill particularly unsuitable to a country with a large population and with almost no occupations outside agriculture (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 314). As mentioned, in Ireland the intense competition for land had led to extremely high rents, most of the time higher than what could be obtained by the working of the land. The result was that everything other than bare subsistence of the farmer and his family would end up being transferred to the landlord (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, pp. 317–318).
In Mill’s evaluation, this situation created a perverse state of affairs in which the tenant had no stimulus whatsoever to exertion, temperance, or prudence: “If he were industrious or prudent, nobody but his landlord would gain; if he is lazy or intemperate, it is at his landlord’s expense. A situation more devoid of motives to either labour or self-command, imagination itself cannot conceive” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 319).
Hence, important negative traits of the Irish character—laziness, lack of discipline, negligence in work, lack of foresight, and irresponsibility in reproduction—were associated with the cottier system. Mill states: “No labourers work harder, in England or America, than the Irish; but not under the cottier system” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 319). Thus, this system failed utterly in the paramount criterion of promoting human betterment. And a great deal of Mill’s motivation to eliminate it and to create a class of peasant proprietors was based on his belief that this institutional change would regenerate the Irish character.
The cottier system also failed to promote economic efficiency. Unlike what happened in England, in Ireland the absolute property in land by landlords did not lead to investments on land. With few, but honorable, exceptions, absentee landlords aimed mainly at extracting the utmost possible from the soil (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, pp. 229–230) and gave no equivalent for their rent (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 892). In addition, the lack of any permanent right to the land on fixed terms discouraged investments on the part of tenants, since improvements would probably elevate rents in the future when the investments matured (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 315). And, as seen, the tenant could even be evicted without any compensation for the betterments he eventually made in the land. As a consequence, the land was systematically cultivated with an insufficient amount of capital, being very inefficient and unproductive.
With respect to legitimacy and social justice, this social arrangement also failed strikingly. According to Mill, the main argument for private property—that is, to guarantee to the individual the results of his labor or abstinence—does not apply to land (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 227). Land was a collective good, and its private appropriation could be justified only if it led to investments and betterment on the part of the owner and to more goods for the community,—that is, if it fulfilled a social function (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 230): “Whenever, in any country, the proprietor … ceases to be the improver, political economy has nothing to say in defence of landed property, as there established” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 228).
And in response to those who appealed to political economy to justify the inviolability of private ownership of land, Mill affirmed the following: “In no sound theory of private property was it ever contemplated that the proprietor of land should be merely a sinecurist quartered on it” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 228).
Ireland was seen as emblematic of an unjust and illegitimate private ownership of land. In Mill’s judgment, in that country “the greatest ‘burthen on land’ is the landlords” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 229). Thus, it is not surprising that he fought for drastic changes in the proprietorship of land in Ireland.
Additionally, Mill noted an incompatibility between the laws of property in land imposed upon Ireland after the Conquest—which ascribed absolute ownership of the country’s land to a small number of families—and the notion of the “right to land” prevalent in the population: “Before the Conquest, the Irish people knew nothing of absolute property in land … and never to this day been recognised by the moral sentiments of the people.… In the moral feelings of the Irish people, the right to hold the land goes, as it did in the beginning, with the right to till it” (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 513). The dissonance between laws and customs nourished a great deal of the existing revolt and resentment of the Irish against the great landlords who exerted their legal rights to land without respecting the “moral right” of the tenants who tilled it.
As early as the mid-1840s, Mill warned that, if nothing was done to solve the land problem in Ireland, there would be a great risk of social disruption:
Unless those who have influence in Parliament and in the public can find another remedy, and apply it too, they will not long persuade an uneducated peasantry, who have never yet seen a friend in the law, to respect the proprietary rights which the law gives, when those rights have no sanction in their own feelings; and the choice may soon lie between a real confiscation and a second Cromwellian conquest.
(Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 906)For all these reasons, Mill believed that at the heart of the Irish problems was a totally inappropriate social arrangement concerning land. The cottier system did not foster the needed moral qualities in the population and simply did not suit the economic, social, and cultural particularities of Ireland. This institution could eventually succeed in a country with a highly morally developed population, but in a condition of backwardness, as found in Ireland, this system would be “an almost insuperable obstacle to their emerging from it” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 317).
IV. MILL’S OBJECTIONS TO THE ADOPTION OF THE “ENGLISH MODEL” OF CAPITALIST AGRICULTURE IN IRELAND
It was obvious to Mill that the cottier system should be eliminated and replaced by another arrangement. Otherwise, Ireland would be trapped in a state of economic, social, and moral backwardness; and would experience escalating tensions that could endanger social order. This was also the opinion of most political economists, particularly after the Irish famine. However, the solution typically proposed by English economists was to transpose to Ireland the “English model” of agriculture (Koot Reference Koot1975, p. 320; Collison Black Reference Black and Robert1953, p. 36). In England, landlords rented large tracts of lands to capitalist farmers who, in turn, used hired labor to cultivate them. Economists thought that this would result in increased land productivity, since it involved larger farms and a higher level of investment in this activity.
Mill did admit that the adoption of the “English model” would raise productivity; notwithstanding, he emphatically rejected this alternative, and this rejection was intrinsically related to his views of social institutions. Mill opposed what he considered an English bent of perceiving her home institutions as universally valid and beneficial; and this tendency revealed itself clearly in the attitude of his compatriots towards Ireland: “We [England] had got a set of institutions of our own, which we thought suited us … we, or our ruling class, thought that there could be no boon to any country equal to that of imparting these institutions to her … Ireland, it seemed, could have nothing more to desire” (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 511).
According to Mill, the idea that there existed a given set of institutions that could equally suit different kinds of societies was misplaced. He believed that the different people of the world were situated at different levels in the “scale of civilization” (Sullivan Reference Sullivan1983, p. 610; Mill [1836] Reference Mill and Robson1977).Footnote 10 To promote progress without endangering social order, institutions had to conform to the moral, economic, and social development of the specific country in question (Mill [1861] Reference Mill and Robson1977, pp. 394–396). As he affirmed: “the same institutions will no more suit two nations in different stages of civilization, than the same lesson will suit children of different ages” (Mill [1833] Reference Mill and Robson1969, p. 16).
The suggested alternative would make sense only if England and Ireland were countries with similar economic and social characteristics, with analogous levels of moral development and with a similar set of habits and sentiments. In that case, one could expect similar consequences arising from the adoption of analogous institutions (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 514). But Mill believed the two countries differed significantly in all these dimensions:
There is no other civilized nation which is so far apart from Ireland in the character of its history, or so unlike it in the whole constitution of its social economy [than England]; and none, therefore, which if it applies to Ireland the modes of thinking and maxims of government which have grown up within itself, is so certain to go wrong.
(Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 511)He associated England’s resounding failure in Ireland with this habit of imposing in that country her own policies and institutions without attending to the large economic and cultural differences between the two nations (Mill [1870] Reference Mill and Robson1967, p. 672).
The English had erred in the past when they imposed their property laws regarding land on the Irish, ignoring local customs and habits; and they were wrong, again, in their desire to replace the cottier system by the large-scale capitalist agriculture prevalent in their country.
According to Mill, the art of choosing institutions required a good knowledge of a country’s particularities. It would involve a thorough evaluation of the problems to overcome and of the way in which the introduction or elimination of the institution in question would advance their solution.
The main problems in Ireland were, according to Mill, the degraded moral state of the population, the low productivity of agriculture, the illegitimacy and injustice of the current form of ownership of land, and the social and political tensions engendered by the combination of all these factors. He rejected the idea of adopting the “English model” in Ireland because, despite being able to settle the economic question, it would not solve (and most probably would aggravate) the remaining problems.Footnote 11
The “English model” would fail to promote the needed regeneration of the Irish people. Since Mill deemed the impact of the cottier system on tenants’ character to be very perverse, he believed this institution was in great part responsible for several of the unwelcome traits of the Irish population. He judged it of crucial importance that the impact of its substitute be one of elevating the character of the people.Footnote 12 However, that was not, in his understanding, the case with the capitalist mode of agriculture. In this respect, Mill affirmed the following:
The status of a day-labourer has no charm for infusing forethought, frugality, or self-restraint, into a people devoid of them. If the Irish peasantry could be universally changed into receivers of wages, the old habits and mental characteristics of the people remaining, we should merely see four or five millions of people living as day-labourers in the same wretched manner in which as cottiers they lived before; equally passive in the absence of every comfort, equally reckless in multiplication, and even, perhaps, equally listless at their work.
(Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 326)While Mill did not deny that the consolidation of land and the adoption of the “English model” of capitalist agriculture would increase the productivity of Irish agriculture, he believed this solution would also create an enormous social and political problem. It would involve the eviction of the cottier peasantry from the land they cultivated and the handing of the land over to capitalist farmers; and the number of those who would be retained as day-workers would be much smaller than the number of those evicted. This alternative would, thus, generate a great mass of people with no available means to survive (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 894).
The advocates of this solution argued that those who were not able to be re-employed in this capitalist agriculture should be helped to emigrate, and, until they did, they should count on some kind of poor relief (Collison Black Reference Black and Robert1953, p. 33). Mill lodged strenuous objections to both alternatives. He believed poor relief in the manner given at the time in Ireland (with provision of relief outside the workhouses to able-bodied men) degraded the character of the population even more.Footnote 13 Mill also considered any forced mass emigration to be tremendously unjust.Footnote 14 As Lynn Zastoupil (Reference Zastoupil1983, p. 708) and Bruce Kinzer (Reference Kinzer2001, p. 61) indicate, this solution involved a social cost that Mill was absolutely not willing to accept. Mill was very emphatic about his position:
We shall here state at once our opinion, in plain terms, respecting this clearing system, by which a population, which has for generations lived and multiplied on the land, is, on the plea of legal rights, suddenly turned adrift without a provision, to find a living—where there is no living to be found. It is a thing which no pretence of private right or public utility ought to induce society to tolerate for a moment. (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 894)
Besides being extremely unjust—which would be reason enough to reject it—this solution would aggravate the existing social and political tensions. By taking to the limit the idea of absolute property of land (leaving small tenants completely without protection), the “English model” would reveal even more clearly the distance that existed between the land laws imposed by the English and the notion of property in land prevalent among the Irish population. This would probably cause widespread rebellion and defiance of the law:
[T]here is a force of resistance in human beings, in the last resort, which does not always suffer the extreme of injustice to be consummated with safety to the perpetrators. "Captain Rock" and his family have solved the question of Irish clearances. They have made it, and will continue to make it, impracticable to abolish the cottier system by the simple plan of abolishing the lives of the cottiers themselves. (Mill [1846–1847], p. 895)Footnote 15
For all this, Mill’s verdict concerning this solution was, overall, negative, especially because he believed an alternative institution was much more suitable to Ireland’s particularities and would perform much better in all the relevant dimensions: peasant property. With this alternative in mind, Mill demanded a change in English attitudes towards the neighboring country: “Let us show that our principles of government are not a mere generalization from English facts; but that in legislating for Ireland we can take into account Irish circumstances” (Mill [1850–1868] Reference Mill, Robson and Kinzer1988, p. 83).
V. MILL’S DEFENSE OF PEASANT PROPERTY IN IRELAND
Mill’s position in the Irish land debate was, in essence, that England should create a class of small peasant proprietors. But, crucially, his use of the term “property” when dealing with land was somewhat wider than the modern use. Mill demanded an institutional form that guaranteed permanence on the land on fixed terms. For him, “a tenant at quit-rent is, to all intents and purposes, a proprietor” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 164). The concrete measures Mill defended to create this small peasant proprietor class and to solve Ireland’s land problem changed substantially during the twenty-plus years in which he was engaged in the debate. He altered his position according to both the information he collected about the condition of the countryFootnote 16 and his understanding of the political climate in England.Footnote 17
In the mid-1840s Mill advocated State investment in the Waste Lands—which should be made arable, then repassed, after payment, to small cultivators—as a way to abolish the cottier system.Footnote 18 He believed that settling part of the population on the Waste Lands would make viable the consolidation of lands and the transformation of the remaining cottier tenants into paid laborers of the capitalist farms (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 901). At the time he discussed the Irish tenants’ claims for fixity of tenure, but he dismissed this solution as unnecessarily radical; he believed that other, less traumatic, alternatives could solve the problems of the country (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 906). Twenty years later he changed his mind and advocated that radical solutions were necessary; in the new political setting of the late 1860s, Mill embraced the idea of fixity of tenure (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 518). This position was very unpopular in Parliament, and Mill’s proposals were considered excessively radical, even by his close friends John Cairnes and William Thornton (Kinzer Reference Kinzer2001, p. 192).
Although Mill defended the establishment of a peasant proprietor class all along, the difference between the moderate measures suggested in the Morning Chronicle and the radical ones defended in England and Ireland is striking. But the idea that a definite solution to the moral, social, political, and economic problems of Ireland depended upon the adoption of peasant property gave unity to his proposals.
However, this would necessarily involve limiting the property rights of landowners, who would not be able to freely dispose of their lands. And a good deal of Mill’s efforts in this debate aimed at convincing the political economists, the English political class, and public opinion of the necessity, and convenience, of adopting this alternative.
There was enormous resistance to any attempt to change property rights regarding land on the part of politicians and political economists, who defended the absolute (and inviolable) right to property (Platteau Reference Platteau1983, p. 438).Footnote 19 This largely limited the scope of reforms that were considered acceptable, since it excluded not only the expropriation of landlords but also solutions that involved fixed rents, contracts in perpetuity, or any other arrangement that provided guarantees to tenants against the interests of landlords.
Mill described the existing state of feeling of the English towards property rights as akin to superstition or religion, in the sense that it precluded reason (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 1003), and he demanded a change of attitude towards the issue: “Let us show … that our care for landed property is an intelligent regard for its essentials, and for the ends it fulfils, and not a servile prostration before its mere name” (Mill [1850– 1868], Reference Mill, Robson and Kinzer1988, p. 83). Mill’s position was that property rights on land could never be absolute and that private ownership of land made sense only if it fulfilled a social function—which, evidently, it did not in Ireland. According to him, limiting property rights on land did not involve any injustice, as long as the landlords were adequately compensated. And on this issue Mill was consistent; even in his more radical moments, he maintained that landlords should lose their power to arbitrate freely over the use of land but never the right to a just pecuniary compensation (Mill [1868]Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 519).Footnote 20
The inviolability of property was not, however, the only source of resistance to the establishment of peasant property in Ireland among orthodox political economists. Many believed that small agriculture was unproductive and that part of Ireland’s problem was precisely the small size of the lots cultivated under the cottier system. Based on this argument, most economists advocated the consolidation of lands and the implementation of the “English model” of large-scale capitalist agriculture. Consequently, to give a solid foundation for his case for peasant property in Ireland, Mill argued that its introduction would increase agricultural production.
According to Mill, political economists thought little of peasant property in great part because they did not understand how it worked, since it was not usual in England. The system of great landlords was so ingrained in the English mind that even the language left little space for the notion of peasant property: “the very idea of peasant proprietors is strange to the English mind, and does not easily find access to it. Even the forms of language stand in the way: the familiar designation for owners of land being ‘landlords,’ a term to which ‘tenants’ is always understood as a correlative” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 253).
In short, the English resisted solutions, such as peasant property, that were unusual in the home country. And this was a major obstacle to overcome: “Men are not easily induced to submit to be cured, and still less to cure others, by remedies which are not upon their list … [and] peasant proprietary, as a cure for popular indigence, has not the honour of being in the Pharmacopoeia Londinensis” (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, pp. 949–950). Thereby, Mill took great pains to convince the English of the advantages of peasant property and to add this ‘medicine’ to the list of acceptable solutions. With such a purpose in mind, he provided extensive information about its good functioning and success in other countries.
To undermine the prejudice against small farming, Mill argued that the advantages of large-scale production were not as established in agriculture as they were in the industrial sector. He acknowledged some possible disadvantages of small vis-à-vis large agriculture (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, pp. 142–146); however, he claimed that if the peasant owned the land, there would be one advantage that would more than compensate for all the eventual disadvantages of small agriculture: “an ardour of industry absolutely unexampled in any other condition of agriculture” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 147). To reinforce this argument, Mill surveyed several cases of successful experiences of peasant property in different countries, such as Switzerland, Norway, Germany, Belgium, and France (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, pp. 253–273).Footnote 21
Based on this multiplicity of examples, Mill maintained that peasant property (in the broad sense) could be a good solution for the economic problems in Ireland. The introduction of this institution would represent an immense advance in relation to the existing state, and would not be inferior, even in economic terms, to the alternative of transposing the “English model” to this country. Over and over Mill made reference to the ‘miracle’ that the idea of property (or even the hope of acquiring it) exercised on the dispositions to work and save. And in the case of Ireland, this incentive was seen as essential to the increase of agricultural production. Mill argued that this institutional arrangement would be the most appropriate to deal with the impulsive and emotional characteristics of the Irish people. They would need more powerful incentives than those given by wage work:
To make them work, they must have what makes their Celtic brethren, the French peasantry, work, and those of Tuscany, of the self-indulgent and luxurious south. They must work, not for employers, but for themselves. Their labour must not be for wages only, it must be a labour of love—the love which the peasant feels for the spot of land from which no man’s pleasure can expel him, which makes him a free and independent citizen of the world, and in which every improvement which his labour can effect belongs to his family as their permanent inheritance.
(Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 916)However, the increase in production derived from an increase in the effort applied to work would not be the only positive effect of attributing ownership of the land to those who cultivate it. And it was not even the one in which Mill was most interested. He believed that the introduction of peasant property to replace the cottier system would have an extremely positive effect on the character of the Irish people. This institution would be able to teach exactly the ‘lessons’ that more urgently needed to be learned:
A people who in industry and providence have everything to learn —who are confessedly among the most backward European populations in the industrial virtues—require for their regeneration the most powerful incitements by which those virtues can be stimulated: and there is no stimulus as yet comparable to property in land.
(Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 327)The ownership of the land would inculcate various desirable moral qualities in the population and, thus, would help rescue the population from the existing degraded intellectual and moral state that resulted from the operation of the cottier system. Mill thought it was time England assumed her moral responsibility towards the regeneration of Irish moral character, and believed this regeneration would begin with agrarian reform—that is, with the adoption of peasant property (Zastoupil Reference Zastoupil1983, p. 712; Robson Reference Robson and Skroupski1998, p. 359). He states that “no other existing state of agricultural economy has so beneficial an effect on the industry, the intelligence, the frugality, and prudence of the population, nor tends on the whole so much to discourage an improvident increase of their numbers” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, pp. 296–297).
Besides believing it to be England’s moral duty to ameliorate the problems of the population under its rule, Mill understood that the success of any plan depended on attacking simultaneously both the economic and moral ills: “Without the moral change, the greatest economical improvement will last no longer than a prodigal’s bounty; without the economical change, the moral improvement will not be attained at all” (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 907). Adopting the “English model” of agriculture would increase productivity (thus resolving temporarily the economic problem) but would not better the Irish character. Peasant property, in contrast, would solve both the economic and the moral problems. And, in great measure, that was the reason why Mill preferred this alternative: “In a backward state of industrial improvement, as in Ireland, I should urge its [peasant property’s] introduction in preference to an exclusive system of hired workers; as a more powerful instrument for raising a population from a semi-savage listlessness and recklessness, to a persevering industry and prudent calculation” (Mill [1871] Reference Mill1965, p. 768). In addition, since this institution was more compatible with the prevalent notion of justice in Ireland, it would also be the best means to end the present state of political dissatisfaction.
England’s decision to reproduce the landlord system in Ireland, distributing the land among a small number of families—a form of property alien to the traditions and sentiments of justice of the Irish—generated, as has been argued, rage and revolt that led to the separatist unrest in the country. With the strengthening of the Fenian movement, Mill radicalized his stand and argued that nothing less than the attribution of the property of land to those who cultivate it would mitigate the sentiment of injustice and the indignation of the Irish, and reduce the resentment they nurtured against the English (which was putting at risk the union of the two countries): “no accommodation is henceforth possible which does not give the Irish peasant all that he could gain by a revolution—a permanent possession of the land, subject to fixed burthens. Such a change may be revolutionary; but revolutionary measures are the thing now required” (Mill [1868] Reference Mill and Robson1982, p. 518).Footnote 22 Thereby, also in terms of maintaining social order, peasant property (understood broadly) would be the best alternative. By guaranteeing permanence in the land to those who cultivate it, this institution would satisfy the aspirations of the population and diminish the prevailing feelings of outrage—results not to be obtained by the introduction of capitalist agriculture. Thus, in addition to elevating economic efficiency and improving important aspects of the Irish character, Mill believed that peasant property, by transforming the Irishman into “an orderly citizen … a supporter of the law, instead of a rebel against all law” (Mill [1846–1847] Reference Mill, Robson and Robson1986, p. 974), would also diminish the risk of disruption of social order.
In the end, Mill did not succeed: he did not convince the politicians, public opinion, and the political economists of the pertinence of attributing the property of land to the small cultivators—England and Ireland was considered too radical. However, Mill’s engagement with the Irish Land Question set the stage for the Land Reform Acts that followed, which recognized peasant rights and tilted the balance against landlords (Kinzer Reference Kinzer2001, p. 208).Footnote 23 As Jeff Lipkes put it: “It is likely that the pamphlet [England and Ireland] contributed indirectly to the passage of the Irish Land Act of 1870, if only by holding out a far more radical option, and thus shifting the via medium leftwards” (Lipkes Reference Lipkes1999, p. 67).Footnote 24
VI. FINAL REMARKS
The analysis of Mill’s position in the Irish land debate discloses his specific ideas about the best land arrangement for Ireland and sheds light on his wider views as a social reformer.
Mill compares (explicitly or not) the relative merits and defects of three alternatives forms of land occupation, unraveling the reasons underlying his positions. Hence, this episode illustrates the several criteria he used when evaluating economic institutions: yes, economic efficiency was important, but so, too, were impacts on national character, social justice, and social order.
This debate also illuminates how Mill applied his views that “institutions are relative, not absolute” (Mill [1873], Reference Mill, Robson and Stillinger1981, p. 169) and that societies in different levels of development ought to have different institutions. That Ireland and England were in different stages of civilization, with dissimilar economic, moral, social, and political characteristics, was at the heart of his rejection of the capitalist mode of agriculture and of his advocacy of peasant property in Ireland. Thus, his views about the historical relativity of institutions appear clearly in the debate.
It is noteworthy that Mill did not evaluate the three alternative forms of land arrangements on absolute or abstract grounds; his choices were closely connected to an analysis of Ireland’s current moral, social, political, and economic conditions.
Mill excoriated the cottier system as it existed in Ireland, but he admits that this institution could have different effects if adopted by a highly developed nation. Though he firmly believed the English model of capitalist agriculture was inadequate for Ireland, he considered this form of culture more suitable (although open to criticism for other reasons) to his own country. Even his passionate defense of peasant property was context-dependent. While judging this institution to be extremely favorable to Ireland, he certainly did not see any advantage in its general adoption in England.Footnote 25
Mill’s arguments against the cottier system and the “English model” and in favor of peasant property were, thus, associated with his diagnosis of what were Ireland’s specific problems at the time and with his anticipation of what would be the impacts of these diverse institutions in that particular context. He advocated peasant property because he regarded it as the only way to overcome the main obstacles to Ireland’s improvement, without impairing social order. It was the most adequate institution for the stage of development of that country, since it would teach the Irish exactly those lessons that they, in his view, urgently needed to learn in order to advance.
