Drawing heavily on analysis from post-colonial studies, Japan and the Specter of Imperialism gives a novel account of the relationship between Western imperialism and the spaces of Japanese national political cultures. The strength of this work lies in its analysis of the debates on what constituted a nation. These debates raged across a broad set of disciplines (literature, philosophy, social sciences, art, ethics), colonizing the imagination via the production of knowledge about history, peoples and places, whilst simultaneously contributing to the formation of an oppressive and territorially aggressive Japanese nation-state.
Anderson argues that the key characteristics of the modern Japanese state—radical (some would say reactionary) nationalism and territorial ambition—can be traced to what the author calls the Ansei-treaty period (1858–1910). This period is marked by an anxiety in Japan's ability to survive that had an external and internal dimension. Externally, the source of this anxiety was international law, or the law of nations, jus genitum, which in effect denied recognition of Japan as a sovereign entity on equal footing with other states in a space of competition and rivalry. As such, the Japanese experienced the Ansei-treaty period as semi-colonial domination; overturning the unequal treaties forced upon Japan by Western powers was both a political and existential goal. Internally, the question of Japan's survival crystallized around how to secure the substantive condition for the survival of the Meiji State. Survival depended on finding new forms of rule, as the existing apparatus of the government was no longer considered up to the task of keeping Japan free from foreign control. Anderson brilliantly shows how the “national question” gave rise to a new field of politics where self-determination was linked with creating new forms of solidarity based on voluntary association.
Securing the substantive condition for the survival of the fledging Meiji State became the endgame of Japanese politics. However, there was little consensus on how this was to be achieved. Anderson indicates that the reason for a lack of consensus was due to competing notions about what constituted the nation. The conflict was inherent in the notion of the nation itself: it was based both on a principle of intelligibility of an already existing reality (the work and function of the Meiji State) and at the same time on an objective to be realized (how can we Japanese as a collective come together to overthrow the yoke of Western domination). For example, Mori Arinori's educational reforms were aimed at increasing the strength of the Meiji State by using education to nurture stronger bodies and to coach students in tasks necessary for a strong Japan to emerge. In contrast, public intellectuals such as Shiga Jūkō, Miyake Setsurei, and Kuga Katsunan linked the exercise of power to the benevolence and wisdom of the Emperor, in which the latter's authority was modeled in terms of truth; the truth of the natural, divine and human order of the world. Haga Yaichi, on the other hand, fused German philology with the Mito domain kokugaku school to give a definition of the Japanese nation across time. Anderson shows that Haga's masterstroke was to make the nation as the only subject capable of self-assertion and for the realization of Japan's manifest destiny as a world power through the direction of Japanese energy and power in imperial conquest in Asia.
Anderson's book reveals that ultimately the intense debates on how to overcome the fragility of the Meiji State was also a question of how to make Japanese subjects governable. The specter haunting Japanese leaders and intellectuals was the fear that Japan would follow the fate of China and rip itself apart because of a lack of national consciousness. Inoue Tetsujirō's commentary on the Imperial Rescript on Education keenly recognizes this problem. Anderson correctly points out that the commentary was an attempt to graft national objectives onto the practicalities of everyday life of Japanese subjects. Meiji intellectuals and leaders were also aware that the Japanese state was incapable of a vital historical existence on par with Western powers because of the aforementioned lack of consciousness of nationality by the Japanese people. Inoue's commentary on the Imperial household was a solution to this problem. He posits the Imperial household as the ideal precondition for political unity by making the emotional bonds between the Japanese people and the Emperor the foundation of the nation. The emotional bond was supposed to be above politics, effectively transcending the mistrust and conflict found in the arguments of the more forceful sections of the population which advocated for a greater public role in government.
Japan and the Specter of Imperialism is an ambitious project, and as a consequence, it has some flaws. One issue is that Anderson's key concepts to help us understand the Ansei-treaty period—”governmentality” and “vitalist ontologies”—get in the way of, rather than enhance, understanding. Both concepts are left under-developed and largely unexplained. In particular, Anderson's use of “governmentality” is highly eclectic and mystifying to this reader. Another tension is the post-colonial claim that texts and ideas create not only knowledge but also the very reality they describe. This is an important claim for Anderson in his explanation both of Japan's subordination to the West and for Japanese imperial adventures. The question is: How can texts and the ideas they circulate both create objects of study and at the same time be a misrepresentation of the original object?
Nonetheless, Japan and the Specter of Imperialism is a bold work, which has much to offer to scholars and advanced students with its innovative analyse of how contradictory and competing notions of the nation shaped the political culture and imagination of pre-war Japan.
