If you have the energy to read only one book on music education this year I suggest you read this one. In one sense it is only 25 versions on the theme of social justice, but this is actually its strength in that by the time you get to the end you are left with an overwhelming desire to do something different. There is also a sense in which nothing is new: I found myself making notes on as much material quoted from other sources as from the authors themselves. But this is also good because it brings together such a diverse amount of literature so as to give an understanding of scholarship that has come before.
The book itself is divided into three sections: theoretical frameworks; research initiatives; and emerging practices. Elizabeth Gould introduces the chapters by saying that ‘music educators at all levels cannot ignore the worlds in which we live and work and its concerns if, for no other reason, than the world has come to us’ (pxi). and offers this volume as ‘a way to proclaim that teaching and learning musics in contexts that are profoundly implicated in and by the social and natural world around us is both an imperative and our shared responsibility’ (pxiii)
Theoretical Frameworks consist of seven chapters addressing social justice through the theoretical lenses of North American scholars: Lise Vaugeois looks at the critical concepts that ground society and music education in terms of social justice; Roger Mantie looks at how daily life links with democratic theory; in considering the notions of othering, musical ownership, authenticity, and hybridization June Countryman talks of the tensions that are inherent in these issues; Carol Beynon bases her chapter around her male community choir and describes critical ethnographic research methods to look at tensions associated with songs of war; Deborah Bradley writes to her interest in multicultural choral education by critiquing the anti-racist perspective personal, professional, and cultural tensions; Susan O'Neill talks of examining music education in terms of a critical lens involving marginality, essentialism, translation, and love; and Lee Willingham encourages us to see music education as ‘a flame of hope’.
Different chapters within this book will speak to different people, but in this first section I was particularly struck by the work of Vaugeois, Willingham and O'Neill. Vaugeois bases her chapter on power, discourse and the works of Foucault. She argues that we need to get into a way of thinking that goes beyond ‘taken-for-granted ideas about contemporary social relations’ (p. 2). Defining social justice as ‘undoing structures that produce raced and gendered oppressions and systemic poverty as well as the work of challenging discourses that rationalize these structures’ (p. 3), she sees discourse in the terms of Mills, that is to say ‘a system which structures the way we perceive reality’ (p. 4). Her thesis rests on three tasks as the basis for music education: ‘troubling knowledges, noticing and addressing systemic barriers and opening spaces for non-hierachical relationships that take difference and multiplicity as both given and desirable’ (p. 15).
Willingham addresses the music as hand-maiden dichotomy in suggesting that many of our criteria are based on outcomes that are extrinsic to music education rather than intrinsic. However, he also warns of going down the route of music for music's sake and reminds us that Small talked about music as a verb not a noun. So, he asks, what is worth teaching? His creed is that ‘the only one curriculum that should matter to us is the one designed to include learning outcomes for peace, social justice, diversity and planetary sustenance’ (p. 60), but does add the rider that this is not just the responsibility of music within the curriculum. Willingham ends by declaring ‘with confidence that music is a means of grounding, provoking, and connecting’ with himself and his community (p. 67).
Coming on to O'Neill she bases her chapter around the idea that we have to get away from believing that ‘the other is the same as me’ (p. 83). She looks at a cultural diversity theory of difference based on four key concepts: marginality; essentialism; translation; and love. Beginning with the theory of Friere she reminds us that those people who are marginalised or oppressed are usually the ones best placed to tackle that oppression, rather than those who are at the centre. The job of those of us who believe we are at the centre is to open up spaces in order to allow for ‘thinking about the dynamics of cultural power’ (Ferguson in O'Neill p. 80). Turning next to Edgerton's notion of essentialism she talks of the need to change from looking at the universe as fixed, and translate our attitudes in a way that allows us to connect with one another. ‘Love’ gave me a feeling of unease which I needed time to think about. Why was this? It seemed like a very strange concept to come across in a book about music education but perhaps that is because as professionals it seems out of place. However it is not love of individuals but love for humanity, and when used by Edgerton refers to listening: “listening is love, love pays attention. . . This type of listening (love) is both unsettling and exhilarating because it can pull us in several dimensions at the same time”(p. 83).
In Part 2 of the book there are nine chapters based on Research Initiatives from Brazil, Canada, Sweden, South Africa and USA examining popular music, multi-culturalism, urban issues, life-long learning, and the impact of policy: Karen Snell looks at informal learning processes of popular musicians in relationship to democratic ideals. In rebuking teachers for continuing to teach the elitism of the canon suggests that teaching should be product/performance focused rather than isolated from real life; Robbie McKay takes women from formal music education backgrounds and looks at their participation in popular music; Edwin Wasiak discusses what he terms ‘musical tourism’ his study involving Aboriginal cross cultural collaborations. He asks that ‘Music educators are challenged to counter the superficiality of musical tourism and dilettantism with approaches that lead to deeper musical and cultural understanding and ultimately enact social justice’ (p. 212). This is a very fair point and led me to consider the often tokenistic approach that teachers in the UK adopt to music from non-Western traditions.
Examining identity construction Valerie Peters researches in a multi-ethnic sub-culture; Louisa Sotomayer & Isabella Kim consider marginalised children, youth and seniors in their multi-cultural research; Katie Carlisle is interested in independent school learning and seeks to find ‘independent school music environment[s] that encourage self – development and self-determination in students’ (p. 139); Beatiz Ilari has researched musical practices of underprivileged Brazilian children; Alvin Peterson looks at post apartheid South Africa and asks what impact human rights and social justice had had on music education stating, ‘We need an equitable, sustainable, and inclusive curriculum which reflects all our cultures and is suitable for all learners, irrespective of their race, creed, gender, political persuasion or economic level’ (p. 164); and Sidsel Karlsen investigates the notion of musical agency as a means for students to overcome socio-economic challenges that would otherwise limit their participation in life long, informal music education opportunities. All of these were heart-warming in privileging narrative accounts rather than quantitative research.
The nine chapters in the final section, Emerging Practice, consist of: Brianne Whyte reflecting on her journey as an undergraduate music education student towards involvement with social change in music education; in discussing the Raging Nannies Carol Roy describes and reflects on her involvement with a music-infused community artistic organization; Doug Friesen tells the story of introducing non-traditional improvisation techniques into his high school classroom and how this unexpectedly destabilised power relations in such a way that he was as much a learner as his pupils; Andrew Zinck also deals with power relations in the restructuring he undertook with one of his university courses; Mark Campbell looks at the notion of ‘remix’ from a musical and socio-political standpoint, where students are encouraged to foster critical questions about the structure and order of our society, with social inclusion as the focus. Steven Lashbrook and Roger Mantie are carrying out an Africentric studio-music recording project in a Toronto high school.
Two chapters remain and these are the two that spoke most strongly to me. Janice Miles reflects on her experiences in an elementary school and describes her personal crusade to privilege global perspectives in her music teaching. This is particularly relevant to UK schools because it is usually only in elementary schools in North America that music is taught in the way it is in the UK: that is to say as an holistic combination of listening, appraising, performance and composition. Finally, Frank Abrahams looks at how Jewish students have been marginalized. In particular he draws attention to not taking enough notice of their festivities and their musical culture. This led me to think about the situation in the UK with Muslims. We certainly acknowledge Muslim festivals but if all children are expected to play a musical instrument, as the UK government prescribes, this is against the culture of many of them. Where does social justice and inclusion come into this? I will leave you with Abrahams' request to consider the Jewish prayer Tikkun Olam meaning ‘the repair of the world’ (p. 325) when exploring social justice.
