While ‘Oriental cults’ and ‘Mystery cults’ (coined as such by Franz Cumont) have been studied for more than a century, such cults still hold the power to intrigue a broad scholarly community. The volume under review is proof of this ever-continuing fascination with these cults, but is also an attempt at understanding the broader societal settings within which these cults were set and their places in a global world that was in constant flux and interaction with other regions and peoples, ideas and knowledge in the Roman period. The volume brings together sixteen contributions, preceded by an introduction by the editors (dominated by footnotes, which the reader should not miss out on, since they contain essential information).
The papers stem from a conference held in 2009, and the focuses of the contributions are the cults of Isis, Mithras and Jupiter Dolichenus. The book is structured around five main sections: (1) The Concept of ‘Oriental Cults’ in Recent Debates (Alvar, Steinhauer); (2) Origins and Diffusion of ‘Oriental Cults’ within the Imperium Romanum: the Case of Jupiter Dolichenus (Winter, Blömer, Dészpa); (3) Expanding from Egypt into Globality: the Case of Isis and Osiris (Moyer, Nagel, Stadler, Quack); (4) The Visual Conceptualization of ‘Oriental Gods’ (Versluys, Frackowiak, Krumeich); and (5) Changing Forms of Sacred Space, Sanctuaries and Rituals (Kleibl, Saragoza, Hensen, Gordon). The volume takes a comparative approach and involves contributions by scholars from a variety of disciplines (ancient history, classical archaeology, Egyptology and philology).
It has often been claimed that cults such as those of Isis, Mithras and Jupiter Dolichenus were carried out in much the same fashion across the Roman Empire, but the findings of this volume (especially Krumeich, Gordon, Nagel) show that even within the same cult differences existed and that such differences were influenced by regional and local traditions and frameworks. While this might not come across as particularly surprising, it is still an important and refreshing conclusion, that here is underpinned in each and every contribution by the broad variety of evidence presented and which also is voiced by the editors in their introduction (12).
One of the central issues when dealing with ‘Oriental cults’ or ‘Mystery cults’ is terminology; there has long been a widespread scholarly consensus that the terms are unhelpful and should be abandoned. But, as J. Alvar rightly points out in his contribution ‘The “Romanization” of “Oriental Cults”’, even scholars who have sternly dismissed the terms often end up using them anyhow in the absence of better alternatives (25). Therefore one of the strengths of this volume is that it does not overall argue either for the use or the dismissal of these terms, but sets out to tackle issues embedded in the various strings of scholarship adhering to or dismissing the idea of ‘Oriental cults’ and ‘Mystery cults’. Furthermore the historiography of the terms is dealt with and acknowledged as part of the problem which needs to be tackled (Alvar, Gordon, Steinhauer and the editors’ introduction).
It becomes obvious through the broad variety of papers that archaeological and textual evidence often give very different insights into the cults. Such material is all too often treated too separately — also in this volume — and would benefit from being tied closer together (e.g. Blömer, Moyer, Winter). The discourse often ends up being one about terminology and meaning, which in turn is coloured by schools and disciplines (Alvar, Steinhauer). In some cases, the discussions are heavily based on the exposition of evidence which needs a lot of description, be it archaeological or textual (Frackowiak, Saragoza, Quack). Other papers follow a path of developing new ways of enquiry, starting either by dismissing earlier theoretical frameworks (Dèszpa) or developing new ones (Verschluys). While such approaches in themselves underline the solid and good scholarship presented in this book, one still misses the echo of the editors’ introduction in the individual contributions. While all contributions one way or the other touch upon variety, diversity, the imperial framework, regional and local settings, the role of globalisation and connectivity as well as otherness and universality, and while all acknowledge that the Roman imperial period was characterised by a single distinct framework that differed from earlier periods, it is still hard for the reader to pin down what the reasons for this were and what this means for the cults under discussion — apart from the fact that the local and imperial framework mattered more than we might have acknowledged until now.
The editors have developed a solid structure for the book, which shows their and the contributions’ engagement with the various themes. The volume is well edited; anyone who would like to immerse themselves in the battles still being played out within the fields of scholarship surrounding these cults can begin here and be properly informed. What remains disconcerting, however, is the constant and necessary use of the inverted commas around ‘Oriental cults’, an obvious admission that the issues that have developed around this term have still not been solved; what we in fact imply and dismiss by using or not using this term is not clear. Furthermore, while embracing a variety of disciplines and even mixing contributions from various disciplines in the various sections of the book, no single contribution in the book transcends disciplinary borders. It would have been interesting to see what would have happened if, for example, each section had concluded with an essay written in response to the other contributions; the potential value of a more comprehensive mixing of disciplines would, I think, have become very much clearer to the reader.
The volume does not solve the issues which continue to rage around these cults, but it does clearly and openly address a variety of the issues that need to be tackled, some of which are in fact tackled in this publication. One strength of the volume is that several schools of scholarship are represented, and it therefore gives the reader a good impression of the directions which research on these cults is currently taking (apart from the fact that the conference was held more than a decade ago). It also leaves the clear impression that there are battles still being fought about the very existence of ‘Oriental cults’ and ‘Mystery cults’, and that we still need to think hard and innovatively about these cults and their broader settings if we want to contribute to their further understanding; much potentially good research gets lost in the battles of the different fundamentalist schools dealing with these cults. These issues remain to be tackled by future generations.
In itself, every single contribution in the volume is strong, and the volume stands as an important contribution to the scholarly status quo on the cults included. However, it remains unclear what the overall outcome of the discussions at the conference were, apart from agreeing to disagree on approaches to what we still term ‘Oriental cults’ and ‘Mystery cults’. Cumont did not live in vain.
