The recent failure by the leadership of the PLO and Palestinian Authority (PA) to obtain recognition and admission by the United Nations for the state of Palestine appears to be the latest indication that the “two-state solution” to the Palestinian–Israeli conflict is dead. Menachem Klein's The Shift, however, contends that while the road to a peaceful settlement may be longer and the cost higher than before, two states “appears to be the only feasible solution” (p. 5).
The Shift expands upon Klein's 2008 International Spectator article, “One State in the Holy Land: Dream or Nightmare?” and focuses on the period from the failure of the Camp David summit to the initial attempts by U.S. President Barack Obama to restart negotiations. Klein asserts that during this period the Palestinian–Israeli conflict has been transformed from one between two national movements—each hoping to establish a state in all or part of historic Palestine—into an ethnic conflict. A lecturer of political science at Israel's Bar-Ilan University, Klein was an advisor to the Israeli negotiating team at Camp David and later assisted with the negotiation of the 2003 Geneva Accord. He states that Israeli actions over the past decade, from settlements and the separation wall to military operations, “created a qualitative change” that has “stripped political negotiations of any value” (p. 4). Israelis and Palestinians, Klein argues, are “trapped between what is unachievable today—the two-state solution—and what can never be achieved—a unitary non-ethnic democracy” (p. 4).
Relying largely on press accounts and public opinion polls, Klein offers a sobering assessment of the current situation. Israel, he writes, “seems to have achieved a complete victory over the Palestinian national movement.” Its policies during the second Palestinian intifada “crushed” the PA, and the Authority “became for all intents and purposes the administrator of an Israeli protectorate” (p. 21). In return, PA officials and Palestinian elites retain privileges and benefits from Israel's intensified colonization and control. Meanwhile, what Klein calls Israel's “ethno-security regime” imposed inside and outside the occupied Palestinian territories, continues unabated and with virtually no international repercussions.
The discussion of Israel's ethnosecurity regime and its variable system of control of the Palestinians is The Shift's major contribution. Klein contends that Israel's treatment of its Palestinian citizens and those in the occupied territories is based on a “strategy of differentiation” that creates “commonalities while maintaining differences” (p. 117). This regime includes differential levels of state supervision, security control, bureaucratic rules, civil rights, and citizen benefits. Klein states that the “fundamental and most visible division” is based on territory and law, effectively dividing Palestinians into five groups (pp. 96–97). He asserts that the “commonality of different Palestinian groups is empowered by the Israeli containment of the occupied territories,” adding that “there is a reciprocal relationship between exclusion and inclusion, both of which change over time” (p. 117). The goal of Israel's system, Klein writes, is to “prevent international criticism or keep it at a tolerable level” (p. 120).
This is a substantial departure from Klein's previous work. Both Jerusalem: The Contested City (New York: New York University Press, 2001) and The Jerusalem Problem: The Struggle for Permanent Status (Gainesville, Fla.: University of Florida Press, 2003) were grounded in the details of the peace process and tended to elide the reality and implications of Israel's policies toward the Palestinians. Unfortunately, the promise of his discussion of Israel's ethnosecurity regime is not realized in the remainder of the book.
Klein presents substantial evidence to demonstrate the change in Israel's approach to the conflict since 2000. However his assessments of Israel's policies are overly cautious at times, and the conclusions he draws are wanting. Klein states that “Israel is a regional power that uses imperial methods and colonial practices to pursue its national struggle with the Palestinians.” Nevertheless, he notes that: “This does not mean that it is a colonial power, only that it has adapted some of the methods used by such powers” (pp. 129–30). Klein concedes that “the ideology and practice of expanding borders through settlements goes back to the early days of Zionism, as does the correlation between settling on the land and armed defense of it” (p. 130), but his discussion of the influence of Zionist ideology and the related historical processes and policies of settlement, transfer, and erasure on Israel's ethnosecurity regime is insufficient.
Although his argument is dependent upon the role and importance of ethnicity, Klein does not discuss or cite the considerable literature on the resolution of ethnic conflicts—even works that advocate for a two-state solution in Israel–Palestine. (Interested readers should see Ethnopolitics 10 [3–4] for a detailed discussion of this topic). Indeed, Klein's repeated emphasis on “the shift” from a national struggle to an ethnic conflict and his attempt to link the present political situation with that of British Mandate Palestine results in a flawed and ahistorical discussion in which ethnicity not only encompasses (and essentializes) ideology as well as religious and political beliefs but is also used to justify the two-state solution as the only available option.
Perhaps most disappointing is Klein's discussion of the “one-state solution.” The brief space allotted to the subject in The Shift is hardly satisfactory and represents little more than a reiteration of Klein's 2008 article with no further analysis or insights. In assessing the literature on the one-state solution, he mistakenly identifies Tony Judt's 2003 New York Review of Books article, “Israel: The Alternative,” as “inaugurating” the interest in and writing on the subject. Although Judt's article was clearly influential within American liberal intellectual circles, Edward Said and other Palestinian scholars were writing on and advocating for a one-state solution before the collapse of the Oslo Accords, as in Said's well known 1999 New York Times Magazine article “The One-State Solution.” Klein asserts that a single state in Israel–Palestine is the “current problematic reality rather than a viable solution” and that the belief that this situation will lead to a Western egalitarian democracy is “an illusion” (p. 5). He dismisses the literature on a one-state solution as either the work of “radicals” hoping to revive the PLO's pre-1988 position of calling for a secular, democratic state in all of historic Palestine or of “pragmatists” cynically using it as a tactic in the hopes of pressuring Israel into agreeing to a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Klein declares that “given the exacerbation of ethnic conflict, it is unrealistic to expect that the two rival communities can live together in a liberal democratic state” (p. 137). He adds that “a state founded on citizenship alone will not satisfy the ethnic-national needs of either community” (p. 138).
Klein concludes that once the cost of the conflict becomes too high, “Israel will inevitably exert itself once again to achieve a two-state accommodation” (p. 142). However, previous negotiations failed to achieve an agreement in spite of the supposedly “generous” offers made by Israeli prime ministers Ehud Barak and Ehud Olmert. In large part, and contrary to press reports, this was because Israel's concessions were hardly far reaching and were not official proposals. Indeed, the “Palestine Papers” released by Al-Jazeera revealed that the most significant concessions during the Annapolis talks from 2007 to 2008 were made by the Palestinian negotiators, not Olmert. Nor did Olmert make a formal offer before leaving office (see Clayton Swisher, The Palestine Papers: The End of the Road? [London: Hesperus Press, 2011]). Thus, if the one-state solution is not realistic neither is Klein's contention that Israel will eventually be forced to seek an agreement to establish two states.
Unfortunately The Shift is a missed opportunity, and its analysis and conclusions are already outdated. One hopes, however, that Klein and other scholars will build on his discussion of Israel's ethnosecurity regime in future works.
